The Upper Crust
Full Size Pie
Full Size Chilled
- Banana Cream Pie
Homemade vanilla pastry cream loaded with fresh sliced bananas and topped with freshly made whipped cream. Please note: Cream pie orders will be ready to pick up by 12pm.
$38.00 - Brown Sugar Buttermilk Pie
Just a good 'ol fashioned brown sugar custard.
$34.00 - Butterscotch Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM
Good old-fashioned butterscotch pudding with a mount of meringue to top it off! Pre-order your cream pies at least 48 hours in advance. We do not make large quantities of these daily...these are a specialty pie and the meringue is magical! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
$38.00 - Chocolate Cream Pie
Homemade chocolate pastry cream topped with freshly made whipped cream. Cream Pie orders will be ready for pickup after 12pm
$38.00 - Chocolate Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM
Homemade chocolate pastry cream with a mound of meringue to top it off! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
$38.00 - Coconut Cream Pie
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut, beautifully finished with freshly made whipped cream and toasted coconut.
$38.00 - Coconut Custard Pie
This pie will take you back in time! Granny's old fashioned custard pie enhanced with sweet coconut.
$34.00 - Coconut Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut and finished with a mound of meringue and toasted coconut. All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
$38.00 - Key Lime Pie
Our signature Key Lime pie is made with fresh lime juice and zest with just the perfect combination of sweet and tartness, this delicious pie is heavenly in our butter crust. Requires refrigeration
$35.00 - Lemon Curd Pie
Sweet and tart lemon curd made with lots of fresh lemon juice and zest. This pie is like a lemon bar baked into our signature all butter pastry crust.
$33.00 - Peanut Butter Pie
This may sound like kids' stuff, but this mousse-like filling and chocolate ganache makes for a decadent treat that appeals to adults & kids alike! Please note: Contains Nuts
$36.00 - Sour Cream Blueberry Pie
Wild blueberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a crumble topping. This pie is always a hit!
$34.00 - Sour Cream Raisin Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM
Nutmeg spiced custard filled with plump raisins finished with a mound of meringue. This one will take you back to Grandma's kitchen! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
$38.00 - Sour Cream Raspberry
The perfect combination of sweet and tart! Raspberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a subtly spiced brown sugar crumble topping
$34.00
Full Size Non Chilled
- Apple Crumb Pie
Thinly sliced apples with a hint of nutmeg and topped with a streusel crumble topping.
$35.00 - Apple Pie
Grandma's recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg.
$36.00 - Blubarb Pie
A winning combination of sweet and tart with blueberries & rhubarb. Perfect with a scoop of ice cream!
$34.00 - Blueberry Pie
Wild blueberries are the star of the show in this delicious pie
$34.00 - Bumbleberry Pie
Blueberries, blackberries, raspberries and apples heaped into our all-butter flaky pastry crust and finished off with a brown sugar crumble topping
$34.00 - Caramel Walnut Pie
All the goodness of a pecan pie - we just changed it up and replaced it with Walnuts!
$34.00 - Cherry Pie
Sour cherries make this one of our most popular flavors.
$35.00 - Chocolate Chess Pie
Chocolate Chess Pie is a rich and indulgent cross between a brownie and pudding pie. Lots of chocolate flavor packed into a flaky crust!
$33.00 - Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie
Our signature pecan pie recipe loaded with chocolate chips!
$35.00 - Chocolate Pecan Pie
A decadent and delicious combination of pecans and melted chocolate
$35.00 - German Chocolate Pie
This handsome pie is chocolate heaven loaded with coconut and pecans “Best Thing I Ever Ate” -The Cooking Channel / 2020
$34.00 - Oatmeal Brown Sugar Pie
If you are a fan of oatmeal cookies, this pie is a sure bet! A rich brown sugar, cinnamon and oat filling that is great for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Serve warm with vanilla ice cream!
$33.00 - Peach Blueberry Pie
A winning combination of wild blueberries and juicy peaches with just a hint of vanilla
$34.00 - Peach Crumb Pie
Sweet peaches baked inside our signature pie crust + cinnamon spiced brown sugar crumble topping
$34.00 - Peach Pie
Sweet peaches with a hint of cinnamon baked inside our signature pie crust.
$34.00 - Pecan Pie
Rich and gooey filling loaded with pecans, one of the great American classics
$35.00 - Raisin Pie
Cinnamon spiced filling loaded with plump and juicy raisins baked inside of our all butter, flaky pie crust
$36.00 - Raspberry Rhubarb
This beauty of a pie is loaded with raspberries and rhubarb spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and just a hint of orange zest
$34.00 - Rhubarb Pie
Rhubarb is the star of the show in this scrumptious dessert. Subtly spiced with nutmeg and orange zest, this pie pairs perfectly with a scoop of vanilla ice cream
$34.00 - Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
An all-time favorite fruit pie full of strawberries and rhubarb baked with a pinch of nutmeg and orange zest.
$34.00 - Wild Turkey (Derby)
Chocolate chips, pecans and a shot of Wild Turkey!
$35.00
Quiche
- Sweet Corn and Bacon Quiche
Our savory sweet corn, green onion, bacon and cheese quiche - delish! Perfect for a Sunday brunch or pair it with a salad for quick and easy dinner
$33.00 - Pie Lovers Coffee - 12oz
12 oz of our Signature Coffee beans. This is our signature Columbia blend. Locally roasted. Pairs perfectly with pie or if you just need a good cup of morning motivation! Notes for the coffee nerd: Very Balanced and Approachable overall with a Snappy Mouthfeel, Round Body and Long Coating Linger on the Palate. Notes of Caramel, Vanilla, Citrus, and a tiny bit of Nutty character but more like a Cashew than a peanut. Clean and Versatile. Sourced and Roasted to taste great across all coffee brewing applications. Might be a little bright as an Espresso but will still be a beautiful expression of the care and dedication it takes to produce a nuanced but adaptable all around daily drinker.
$17.50
Full Sugar Free Pies
- Sugar Free Apple
Grandma's Apple pie recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg. *The sugar free version is made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
$41.00 - Sugar Free Blueberry
Our traditional Blueberry pie made with wild blueberries and plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
$39.00 - Sugar Free Peach Pie
Our traditional Peach pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
$39.00 - Sugar Free Rhubarb
Our traditional Rhubarb pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
$39.00 - Sugar Free Strawberry Rhubarb
Our traditional Strawberry Rhubarb Pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
$39.00
Cookies & Bars
Dozen Cookies
- Banana Cookie - 1 dozen
They taste like a heavenly bite of banana bread with the addition of a smooth brown sugar frosting. And yes, they are that big! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$51.00 - Breakfast Cookie - 1 dozen
A hearty combination of dates, raisins, almonds, oats, grape-nuts cereal, oat bran and more! Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$48.50 - Chocolate Chip Cookie - 1 dozen
A brown sugary flavor full of mini chocolate chips with a crisp edge but slightly soft center. Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$38.00 - Coconut Macaroon - 1 dozen
This cookie is for the coconut lover! Naturally gluten free and approximately 4" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$40.00 - Decadent Chocolate Cookie - 1 dozen
Soft and rich brownie cookie loaded with pecans, walnuts and chocolate chips. Cookie is approximately 4-5" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$47.00 - Lemon Sugar Cookie - 1 dozen
Fresh squeezed lemon juice and lots of lemon zest baked into to this soft and refreshing lemon treat. Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$38.00 - Molasses Crinkle - 1 dozen
Perfectly spicy, soft and flavorful. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
$38.00 - Oatmeal Raisin Cookie - 1 dozen
Crisp on the edge, soft & chewy in the middle. Just good 'ol fashioned made from scratch cookies. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5" in diameter.
$38.00 - Peanut Butter Cookies - 1 dozen
And old fashion favorite, this cookie is packed with peanut butter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5 inch diameter
$38.00 - Salted Caramel Pecan Bars - 1/2 dozen (Qty: 6)
Rich salted caramel filling with pecans layered on top of a brown sugar shortbread crust. Highly addictive! 1 bar is approximately 5"x 5". Please note: You are ordering a 1/2 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like a dozen, please order 2 of this item.
$36.00 - Snickerdoodle Cookies - 1 dozen
An old-fashioned cinnamon & sugar favorite! Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: When specifying quantities, please keep in mind that you are ordering 1 of this item.
$38.00 - Monster Cookies - 1 dozen
Peanut butter, oats, chocolate chips, and m&m's - all the good things you'd expect in our from-scratch monster cookie. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep this in mind. 4-5" in diameter
$38.00
Ice Cream & Coffee
- Pint Ice Cream
Vanilla Ice Cream Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream made the Belfonte way, Pure & Rich. *1 Pint
$5.00 - Pie Lovers Coffee - 12oz
12 oz of our Signature Coffee beans. This is our signature Columbia blend. Locally roasted. Pairs perfectly with pie or if you just need a good cup of morning motivation! Notes for the coffee nerd: Very Balanced and Approachable overall with a Snappy Mouthfeel, Round Body and Long Coating Linger on the Palate. Notes of Caramel, Vanilla, Citrus, and a tiny bit of Nutty character but more like a Cashew than a peanut. Clean and Versatile. Sourced and Roasted to taste great across all coffee brewing applications. Might be a little bright as an Espresso but will still be a beautiful expression of the care and dedication it takes to produce a nuanced but adaptable all around daily drinker.
$17.50