Skip to Main content
For Special Request please call us to place your order!
  • Wild Tomato Pizza

Wild Tomato Pizza Sister Bay

10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI
Pickup Only
‌
‌

FAVORITES

  • WOOD FIRED BREAD BASKET

    Cheesy pesto bread, cheese cracklins, fontina & gorgonzola bacon-onion marmalade flatbread, garlic ciabatta, and parmesan knots. Served with marinara, balsamic oil, and herb mascarpone.
    $15.00
  • FRIED CHEESE CURDS

    Hand-battered cheese curds deep-fried to golden brown.
    $12.00
  • PARMESAN KNOTS

    Fried bread tossed in garlic parmesan seasoning accompanied by house marinara
    $13.00
  • BRUSCHETTA DIP

    Herb mascarpone topped with diced Roma tomatoes, red onion, fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic glaze, served with crostini.
    $11.00
  • TERRY’S MAC

    Cavatappi pasta tossed with cheddar cheese sauce, topped with cheddar & garlic parmesan.
    $12.00
  • CHICKEN TENDERS

    Fresh tenders battered and served with french fries & your choice of BBQ sauce or ranch.
    $13.00

SALADS

  • CHERRY WALNUT

    Mixed greens, maple roasted walnuts, dried cherries, goat cheese and cherry vinaigrette.
    $13.00
  • GARDEN

    Mixed greens topped with carrots, tomatoes, sunflower seeds with your choice of dressing.
    $12.00
  • CAPRESE

    Fresh mozzarella & sliced heirloom tomato drizzled with olive oil & balsamic vinegar, served with basil  at bread.
    $11.00
  • ROASTED PEAR SALAD

    Spinach, roasted pears, candied pecans, golden raisins, creamy gorgonzola, and pear vinaigrette.
    $13.00
  • GREEK

    Spring mix, kalamata olives, red onions, tomatoes, feta cheese and pepperoncini, tossed in our house-made Greek vinaigrette.
    $12.00
  • CAESAR

    Romaine lettuce, house-made Caesar dressing, croutons and Wisconsin parmesan cheese.
    $12.00
  • PETITE

    Choose between Cherry Walnut or Caesar.
    $8.50
  • FAMILY STYLE

    Served in a large wooden bowl, serves four. Choose between Cherry Walnut or Caesar.
    $22.00

PIZZA

Small Pizza

  • SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN

    12" | Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
    $15.50
  • SMALL HALF & HALF

    12" | SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
    $23.00
  • SMALL D-LUX

    12" | Our house-made Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
    $23.00
  • SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO

    12" | Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
    $23.00
  • SMALL VEGGIE

    12" | Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
    $23.00
  • SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD

    12" | Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
    $23.00
  • SMALL MARGHERITA

    12" | Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
    $21.00
  • SMALL OLD SCHOOL

    12" | Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
    $23.00
  • SMALL MEDITERRANEAN

    12" | Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, red peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
    $23.00
  • SMALL HOT HONEY

    12" | Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
    $23.00
  • SMALL FUEGO

    12" | Chorizo, Mexican street corn, and jalapeños, over an árbol chile crema base, finished with cotija cheese and cilantro.
    $23.00
  • SMALL DONATION CREATION

    12" | November Donation Creation | The Hunter's Pie: It features savory venison, roasted potatoes, carrots, caramelized shallots, and cremini mushrooms over a rich beef gravy base, topped with Fontina cheese and finished with fresh thyme. The beneficiary is Operation Not Alone.
    $23.00

Large Pizza

  • LARGE CREATE YOUR OWN

    16" | Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
    $19.50
  • LARGE HALF & HALF

    16" | SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
    $27.00
  • LARGE D-LUX

    16" | Our house-made Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
    $27.00
  • LARGE SAUSAGE & PESTO

    16" | Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
    $27.00
  • LARGE VEGGIE

    16" | Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
    $27.00
  • LARGE THE GREEN & GOLD

    16" | Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
    $27.00
  • LARGE MARGHERITA

    16" | Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
    $25.00
  • LARGE OLD SCHOOL

    16" | Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
    $27.00
  • LARGE MEDITERRANEAN

    16" | Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, red peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
    $27.00
  • LARGE HOT HONEY

    16" | Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
    $27.00
  • LARGE THE FUN GUY

    16" | Five types of sautéed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
    $27.00
  • LARGE DONATION CREATION

    16" | November Donation Creation | The Hunter's Pie: It features savory venison, roasted potatoes, carrots, caramelized shallots, and cremini mushrooms over a rich beef gravy base, topped with Fontina cheese and finished with fresh thyme. The beneficiary is Operation Not Alone.
    $27.00

GF Small Pizza

  • GF SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN

    Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
    $19.45
  • GF SMALL HALF & HALF

    SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL D-LUX

    Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO

    Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL VEGGIE

    Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD

    Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL OLD SCHOOL

    Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL MEDITERRANEAN

    Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, red peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL MARGHERITA

    Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
    $24.95
  • GF SMALL HOT HONEY

    Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
    $26.95
  • GF SMALL DONATION CREATION

    November Donation Creation | The Hunter's Pie: It features savory venison, roasted potatoes, carrots, caramelized shallots, and cremini mushrooms over a rich beef gravy base, topped with Fontina cheese and finished with fresh thyme. The beneficiary is Operation Not Alone.
    $26.95

KIDS

Kids Menu

  • PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY PIZZA

    $8.00
  • KIDS MAC

    $8.00
  • NOODLES

    With Marinara sauce or butter
    $8.00

DESSERT

Desserts

  • NY STYLE CHEESECAKE

    With Door County cherries
    $9.00
  • FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE

    Decadent chocolate with raspberry sauce
    $9.00
  • DESSERT KNOTS

    Fried bread tossed in cinnamon sugar seasoning accompanied by pumpkin cream sauce.
    $9.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 2.95% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Wild Tomato Pizza Locations and Ordering Hours

Fish Creek

(920) 868-3095
4023 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 4PM

Sister Bay

(920) 854-4685
10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 4PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement