Please contact the restaurant at (716) 632-1416 if you have any food allergies or intolerances.

Anderson's Frozen Custard Main Street
6075 Main Street, Williamsville, NY
Food
Roast Beef & Turkey Sandwiches

All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.$10.48+
Hickory Smoked Ida Mashed Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's classic all natural roast beef sandwich topped with mashed potatoes, onion rings, hickory smoked cheddar cheese, and chipotle aioli$12.99+
BBQ Beef Sandwich
All natural roast beef slow-cooked in Anderson's original tangy barbecue sauce.$8.78
All Natural Turkey Sandwich
All natural turkey with no additives. Served hot or cold. Prepared to your liking.$9.01+
All Natural Old Fashioned Roast Beef
$12.18+
All Natural Old Fashioned Turkey
$10.71+
Burgers & Dogs

All Natural Angus Beef Hamburger
No preservatives, additives or hormones. Includes your choice of condiments. Cheese not included.$9.01+
Sahlen's Hot Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a hotdog bun. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.$4.05
Sahlen's Chili & Cheese Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a bun, topped with our Turkey Chili with Beans and melted cheddar sauce!OUT OF STOCK$6.99
Chicken & Fish Sandwiches

Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich
Our crisp, all natural chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, with lettuce and blue cheese$9.01
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
4oz chicken breast grilled to perfection, on a toasted roll with your choice of toppings.$9.01
Wild Caught Alaskan Pollock Sandwich
Breaded wild caught pollock, fried to perfection. Served standard with lettuce, tomato, and a side of tartar sauce.$9.01
Chicken Tender Baskets
Veggie Sandwiches
Full Salads

Harvest Salad
Spring mix with harvest root vegetables, dried cranberries, feta cheese, and pecans$11.77
Spring Salad
Spring mix with mandarin oranges, red onion, feta cheese, and pecans$10.11
Greek Salad
Spring mix with fresh tomatoes, red onion, cucumber banana peppers and feta cheese, typically served with a side of Greek dressing!$7.45
Fries & Sides

Curly Fries
$3.59+
Cajun Fries
$4.18+
Onion Rings
$4.18+
Baked Potato
$3.31
Chili & Cheese Loaded Fries
Large order of golden curly cue fries loaded up with our turkey chili with beans and melted cheddar sauce!OUT OF STOCK$9.75
Poutine Fries
Large order of golden curly cue fries topped with thick beef gravy and white cheese curds$8.09Turkey Chili w/ Beans
OUT OF STOCK$6.94+Homestyle Mac n' Cheese
OUT OF STOCK$6.94+Mashed Potatoes
$4.97Side Salad
$4.32Side of Root Veggies
$4.32Steamed Broccoli
$4.32
Potato Salad
$3.08
Extra Sides
Dippers & Dressing
Beverages
Fountain & Bottled Beverages
Dessert
Classic Dessert Dishes
Sundaes

Reese's Pieces Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, and Reese’s Pieces®$5.84+
Turtle Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, and pecans.$5.84+
Mexican Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with rich chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts.$5.84+Create Your Own Sundae
$4.51+
Banana Split
Vanilla & Chocolate Signature Frozen Custard in between two banana halves. Chocolate syrup, strawberry, and marshmallow toppings. Topped with handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts$9.24
Brownie Overboard
Rich fudge brownie with vanilla & chocolate frozen custard, topped with hot fudge, handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts$9.24
Choco-Peanut Butter Passion
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups$9.24
Strawberry Glacier Sundae
$4.60+
Frozen Pints
Pre-Packed Pints

Black Cherry Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Bubblegum Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Cake Batter Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50Caramel Apple Crisp Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Coffee Toffee Crunch Frozen Yogurt (Pint)
$8.50
Cookie Dough Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Graham Cracker Crunch Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Mint Chunk Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50Pumpkin Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Watson's Sponge Candy Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Custom Hand-Packed Pints
Cakes, Pies, & Big Wheels
Traditional Round Cakes

Round Cake - Balloons
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Chocolate Frosting
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Confetti
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Pink Roses
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with pink frosting roses. Serves 8-10.OUT OF STOCK$26.49
Round Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Fall Seasonal
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Halloween
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with Halloween-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.OUT OF STOCK$26.49
Traditional Sheet Cakes

Sheet Cake - Balloons
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.$40.99
Sheet Cake - Mini Cones
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with mini cones and confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.$40.99
Sheet Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 16-20.$40.99
Sheet Cake - Fall Seasonal
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.$40.99
Buffalo Bills & Buffalo Sabres Cakes

Round Cake - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Bills logo and football-themed sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$33.99
Sheet Cake - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Bills logo and football-themed sprinkles. Serves 16-20.$46.49
Round Cake - Buffalo Sabres
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Sabres logo and Sabres-themed sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$33.99
Specialty Cakes

Cookie Dough Fudge Cake
Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream with a center layer of cookie dough pieces and rich chocolate fudge. Topped with frosting and more of our delicious cookie dough pieces and fudge. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Rainbow Fudge M&M Cake
Chocolate ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our vanilla ice cream, more fudge, and real M&Ms. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Cookies & Cream Dream Cake
OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Candy Bar Snickers Cake
Vanilla and milk chocolate ice cream with a center layer of Snickers pieces and caramel, all topped with our chocolate icing, more snickers, caramel, and fudge. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Fudge Ganache Cakes

Mint Fudge Ganache Cake
Chocolate Mint ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our mint chunk ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.$39.99
Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache Cake
Peanut Butter ice cream with a center layer of our delicious peanut butter sauce and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our chocolate ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.$39.99
Cake Slices
Cake Slice - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with an edible Buffalo Bills logo.$6.49
Cake Slice - OREO
OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies.$5.49
Cake Slice - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles.$5.49
Whole Ice Cream Pies
Serves 8.

Turtle Pie
Chocolate pie crust layered with chocolate and vanilla ice cream and a center layer of caramel. Topped with a decorative fudge border and a center of caramel and pecans. Serves 8.$19.99
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with peanut butter ice cream. Topped with a decorative fudge border and peanut butter. Serves 8.$19.99
Pumpkin Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with pumpkin ice cream. Topped with decorative icing and finished with a dash of cinnamon. Serves 8.$19.99
Caramel Apple Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with apple crisp ice cream. Topped with caramel and decorative icing, and finished with graham cracker crumble and a dash of cinnamon. Serves 8.$19.99
Pie Slices
Big Wheel 6-Packs

6-Pack - Vanilla (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla w/ Assorted Toppings
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with various candies and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Chocolate (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Chocolate w/ Assorted Toppings
Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream and decorated with various toppings. Specific toppings may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla and chocolate ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Twist (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with twist ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate/Twist (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla, chocolate, and twist ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Buffalo Football
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with team colors and candy footballs. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Fall Seasonal
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Buffalo Hockey
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with team colors. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Halloween
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with Halloween-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
Individual Big Wheels

Jumbo Chocolate Chip Big Wheel
Jumbo chocolate chip cookies filled with vanilla ice cream.$9.99
Big Wheel - Vanilla (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.$2.99
Big Wheel - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream, decorated with natural colored sprinkles.$2.99
Big Wheel - Buffalo Bills
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream, decorated with an edible Buffalo Bills logo.$3.99

Turtle Sundae
$0.00
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, and pecans.
Customize your item
Turtle Sundae Size
Required
Select 1
Sundae Made With Custard
Required
Select 1
Sundae Toppings
Required
Select 1 to 3
Included Nuts/Candy (1 Free)
Select up to 1
Add Whipped Cream
Select up to 1
1
Anderson's Frozen Custard Locations and Hours
Grand Island
Open now • Closes at 3:45AM
Main Street
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
West Amherst
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM









