Please contact the restaurant at (716) 656-7220 if you have any food allergies or intolerances.

Anderson's Frozen Custard Lancaster
4855 Transit Road, Depew, NY
Featured Items

All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.$10.48+
Curly Fries
$3.59+
Cake Slice - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles.$5.49
Food
Roast Beef & Turkey Sandwiches

All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.$10.48+
Hickory Smoked Ida Mashed Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's classic all natural roast beef sandwich topped with mashed potatoes, onion rings, hickory smoked cheddar cheese, and chipotle aioli$12.99+
BBQ Beef Sandwich
All natural roast beef slow-cooked in Anderson's original tangy barbecue sauce.$8.78
All Natural Turkey Sandwich
All natural turkey with no additives. Served hot or cold. Prepared to your liking.$9.01+
All Natural Old Fashioned Roast Beef
$12.18+
All Natural Old Fashioned Turkey
$10.71+
Burgers & Dogs

All Natural Angus Beef Hamburger
No preservatives, additives or hormones. Includes your choice of condiments. Cheese not included.$9.01+
Sahlen's Hot Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a hotdog bun. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.$4.05
Sahlen's Chili & Cheese Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a bun, topped with our Turkey Chili with Beans and melted cheddar sauce!$6.99
Chicken & Fish Sandwiches

Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich
Our crisp, all natural chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, with lettuce and blue cheese$9.01
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
4oz chicken breast grilled to perfection, on a toasted roll with your choice of toppings.$9.01
Wild Caught Alaskan Pollock Sandwich
Breaded wild caught pollock, fried to perfection. Served standard with lettuce, tomato, and a side of tartar sauce.$9.01
Chicken Tender Baskets
Veggie Sandwiches
Full Salads

Harvest Salad
Spring mix with harvest root vegetables, dried cranberries, feta cheese, and pecans$11.77
Spring Salad
Spring mix with mandarin oranges, red onion, feta cheese, and pecans$10.11
Greek Salad
Spring mix with fresh tomatoes, red onion, cucumber banana peppers and feta cheese, typically served with a side of Greek dressing!$7.45
Fries & Sides

Curly Fries
$3.59+
Cajun Fries
$4.18+
Onion Rings
$4.18+
Baked Potato
$3.31
Chili & Cheese Loaded Fries
Large order of golden curly cue fries loaded up with our turkey chili with beans and melted cheddar sauce!$9.75
Poutine Fries
Large order of golden curly cue fries topped with thick beef gravy and white cheese curds$8.09Turkey Chili w/ Beans
$6.94+Homestyle Mac n' Cheese
$6.94+Mashed Potatoes
$4.97Side Salad
$4.32Side of Root Veggies
$4.32Steamed Broccoli
$4.32
Potato Salad
$3.08
Extra Sides
Dippers & Dressing
SIDE of Ranch
$1.01SIDE of Blue Cheese
$1.01SIDE of Honey Mustard
$1.01SIDE of Buffalo Dipping Sauce
$1.01SIDE of BBQ Sauce
$0.55SIDE of Tartar Sauce
$0.55SIDE of Balsamic Vinaigrette
$1.01SIDE of Raspberry Vinaigrette
$1.01SIDE of Greek Dressing
$1.01SIDE of Chipotle Aioli
$1.01SIDE of Adobo BBQ Sauce
OUT OF STOCK$1.01
Beverages
Fountain & Bottled Beverages
Dessert
Classic Dessert Dishes
Sundaes

Reese's Pieces Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, and Reese’s Pieces®$5.84+
Turtle Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, and pecans.$5.84+
Mexican Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with rich chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts.$5.84+Create Your Own Sundae
$4.51+
Banana Split
Vanilla & Chocolate Signature Frozen Custard in between two banana halves. Chocolate syrup, strawberry, and marshmallow toppings. Topped with handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts$9.24
Brownie Overboard
Rich fudge brownie with vanilla & chocolate frozen custard, topped with hot fudge, handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts$9.24
Choco-Peanut Butter Passion
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups$9.24
Strawberry Glacier Sundae
$4.60+
Arctic Swirls

Arctic Swirl
$6.99+
Latte Toffee Crunch Arctic Swirl
Sweet Treat of the Month! Our signature latte frozen custard blended with chopped Heath bar pieces and smothered with decadent hot caramel.$7.82+
Reese's Pieces & Peanut Butter Arctic Swirl
Sweet Treat of the Month! Signature vanilla frozen custard blended with Reese's Pieces and smothered with peanut butter sauce. Topped with whipped cream.$7.82+
Frozen Pints
Pre-Packed Pints

Black Cherry Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Bubblegum Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Cake Batter Ice Cream (Pint)
OUT OF STOCK$8.50Caramel Apple Crisp Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Coffee Toffee Crunch Frozen Yogurt (Pint)
$8.50
Cookie Dough Ice Cream (Pint)
OUT OF STOCK$8.50
Graham Cracker Crunch Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Mint Chunk Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50Pumpkin Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Watson's Sponge Candy Ice Cream (Pint)
$8.50
Custom Hand-Packed Pints
Cakes, Pies, & Big Wheels
Traditional Round Cakes

Round Cake - Balloons
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Chocolate Frosting
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Confetti
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Pink Roses
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with pink frosting roses. Serves 8-10.OUT OF STOCK$26.49
Round Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$26.49Round Cake - Everyday Fun
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fun-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.OUT OF STOCK$26.49
Round Cake - Fall Seasonal
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.$26.49
Round Cake - Halloween
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with Halloween-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.OUT OF STOCK$26.49
Traditional Sheet Cakes

Sheet Cake - Balloons
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.OUT OF STOCK$40.99
Sheet Cake - Mini Cones
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with mini cones and confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.OUT OF STOCK$40.99
Sheet Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 16-20.$40.99Sheet Cake - Everyday Fun
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fun-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.OUT OF STOCK$40.99
Sheet Cake - Fall Seasonal
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.OUT OF STOCK$40.99
Buffalo Bills & Buffalo Sabres Cakes

Round Cake - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Bills logo and football-themed sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$33.99
Sheet Cake - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Bills logo and football-themed sprinkles. Serves 16-20.OUT OF STOCK$46.49
Round Cake - Buffalo Sabres
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Topped with an edible Buffalo Sabres logo and Sabres-themed sprinkles. Serves 8-10.$33.99
Specialty Cakes

Cookie Dough Fudge Cake
Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream with a center layer of cookie dough pieces and rich chocolate fudge. Topped with frosting and more of our delicious cookie dough pieces and fudge. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Rainbow Fudge M&M Cake
Chocolate ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our vanilla ice cream, more fudge, and real M&Ms. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Cookies & Cream Dream Cake
OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Candy Bar Snickers Cake
Vanilla and milk chocolate ice cream with a center layer of Snickers pieces and caramel, all topped with our chocolate icing, more snickers, caramel, and fudge. Serves 8-10.$32.99
Fudge Ganache Cakes

Mint Fudge Ganache Cake
Chocolate Mint ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our mint chunk ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.$39.99
Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache Cake
Peanut Butter ice cream with a center layer of our delicious peanut butter sauce and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our chocolate ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.$39.99
Cake Slices
Cake Slice - Buffalo Bills
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with an edible Buffalo Bills logo.$6.49
Cake Slice - OREO
OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies.$5.49Cake Slice - Cookie Dough
Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream with a center layer of cookie dough pieces and rich chocolate fudge. Topped with frosting and more of our delicious cookie dough pieces and fudge.OUT OF STOCK$5.49
Cake Slice - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles.$5.49
Whole Ice Cream Pies
Serves 8.

Turtle Pie
Chocolate pie crust layered with chocolate and vanilla ice cream and a center layer of caramel. Topped with a decorative fudge border and a center of caramel and pecans. Serves 8.$19.99
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with peanut butter ice cream. Topped with a decorative fudge border and peanut butter. Serves 8.$19.99
Pumpkin Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with pumpkin ice cream. Topped with decorative icing and finished with a dash of cinnamon. Serves 8.$19.99
Caramel Apple Pie
Graham cracker pie crust layered with apple crisp ice cream. Topped with caramel and decorative icing, and finished with graham cracker crumble and a dash of cinnamon. Serves 8.$19.99
Pie Slices
Big Wheel 6-Packs

6-Pack - Vanilla (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla w/ Assorted Toppings
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with various candies and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Chocolate (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Chocolate w/ Assorted Toppings
Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream and decorated with various toppings. Specific toppings may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla and chocolate ice cream.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Twist (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with twist ice cream.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate/Twist (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla, chocolate, and twist ice cream.$12.99
6-Pack - Buffalo Football
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with team colors and candy footballs. Specific decorations may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.996-Pack - Everyday Fun
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with fun-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Fall Seasonal
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with fall-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
6-Pack - Buffalo Hockey
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with team colors. Specific decorations may vary.$12.99
6-Pack - Halloween
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with Halloween-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.OUT OF STOCK$12.99
Individual Big Wheels

Jumbo Chocolate Chip Big Wheel
Jumbo chocolate chip cookies filled with vanilla ice cream.$9.99
Big Wheel - Vanilla (Plain)
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.$2.99
Big Wheel - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream, decorated with natural colored sprinkles.$2.99
Big Wheel - Buffalo Bills
Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream, decorated with an edible Buffalo Bills logo.$3.99
Strawberry Sensation
$0.00
Customize your item
Sensation Size
Required
Select 1
Fruit Options
Required
Select at least 1
1
Anderson's Frozen Custard Locations and Hours
Grand Island
Open now • Closes at 3:45AM
Main Street
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
West Amherst
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM







