Skip to Main content
PLEASE DOUBLE CHECK YOUR ORDER LOCATION. NO REFUNDS for incorrectly placed orders.
PLEASE DOUBLE CHECK YOUR ORDER LOCATION. NO REFUNDS for incorrectly placed orders.
  • Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop

Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop LANCASTER

1878 Lincoln Highway East, Lancaster, PA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
Full Menu
Catering

Featured Items

  • Bobby’s Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, house whiz, cherry pepper mayo
    $14.99
  • French Fries

    Skin on. Sea salt. Large is ideal for 2.
    $3.99+
  • Chicken Cheesesteak

    chopped grilled chicken, caramelized onions, cherry pepper mayo, Cooper sharp
    $13.49

Full Menu

Sides

  • French Fries

    Skin on. Sea salt. Large is ideal for 2.
    $3.99+
  • Loaded Fries

    House whiz. Bacon. Scallions
    $10.49
  • Tuscan Fries

    Parmesan. Mediterranean herbs. Truffle oil
    $8.99
  • Coleslaw

    Crisp & creamy. 8 ounces.
    $3.75
  • Dipping Sauces

    $0.65+

Salads

  • House Salad

    Iceberg, cherry tomatoes, red onions, carrots, boiled egg, and shredded cheddar
    $8.99
  • Kobb Salad

    Iceberg, tomatoes, onions, carrots, boiled egg, bacon, avocado and gorgonzola crumbles. Recommended with blue cheese
    $10.99
  • Puebla Salad

    Tajin grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, pickled red onions, avocado, grape tomatoes, and queso cotija. Recommended with Jalapeno Ranch
    $13.49
  • Sorrento Salad

    Arugula, fresh basil, fresh mozz, grape tomatoes, pine nuts. Topped with drizzled fig balsamic glaze & EVOO
    $10.99

Deli Sandwiches

Served on our house made bread. About 10"
  • Italian

    Cotto ham, Genoa salami, sharp provolone, cherry peppers, LTO, oil & vinegar
    $12.49
  • Big Vito

    Pistachio mortadella, spicy soppressata, cotto ham, sharp provolone, herb mayo, cherry peppers, arugula, oil & vinegar.
    $13.49
  • The Turk

    Roasted turkey, imported swiss, avocado, herb mayo, LTO
    $12.49
  • Pilgrim

    Roasted turkey, mild cheddar, cranberry mayo, applewood bacon, LTO
    $13.99
  • Brooklyn

    Pastrami, imported swiss, Carolina coleslaw, B&B pickles, russian dressing
    $13.99
  • el Ricky

    pastrami, horseradish cream, mild cheddar, pickled red onions, arugula
    $12.99
  • Don Parma

    Prosciutto crudo, fig jam, fresh mozzarella, arugula
    $13.99
  • Johnny Boy

    Prosciutto crudo, spicy soppressata, fresh mozz, arugula, extra virgin olive oil
    $13.99
  • Caprese

    Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, avocado, tomatoes, EVOO, & fig balsamic glaze
    $9.99
  • Ham & Cheese

    cotto ham, Sharp Provolone, herb mayo, LTO
    $10.99

Cheesesteaks

Served on our house made bread. About 10"
  • Bobby’s Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, house whiz, cherry pepper mayo
    $14.99
  • Cali Style

    Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, cherry pepper mayo, tomatoes, Cooper Sharp and lettuce
    $15.49
  • Chicken Cheesesteak

    chopped grilled chicken, caramelized onions, cherry pepper mayo, Cooper sharp
    $13.49
  • Rancher

    Chopped marinated chicken, sauteed onions, applewood bacon, mild cheddar, buttermilk ranch
    $14.65

Burgers

100% steak burger blend. Double patty (7 oz). Served on toasted-buttered Martin's potato bun
  • Classic Burger

    Double patty, special sauce, American, LTO
    $10.49
  • Texan

    Double patty, Memphis BBQ, Caramelized onions, applewood bacon, and mild cheddar
    $12.99

Kids

  • Burger & Fries

    Single patty with American and some fries
    $9.99
  • Ham & Cheese + Fries

    5" sandwich just cotto ham and Cooper American served with some fries
    $8.49
  • Turkey & Cheese + Fries

    5" sandwich just turkey and Cooper American served with some fries
    $8.49

Sweets

  • Chewy Marshmallow Bar

    Chewy marshmallow with brown butter & sea salt. (gluten-free)
    $3.25
  • Chocolate Chunk Cookie

    Intensely flavorful chunks and morsels of sustainable chocolates with the added crunch of savory pretzel bits all in a brown butter, caramelized, chewy-crispededged wonder.
    $2.99

Beverages

  • Fountain Beverage

    $2.49
  • 20 oz Soda

    $2.79
  • Water Bottle

    $1.49
  • Tea Bottle

    $2.99
  • San Pellegrino

    $2.49

Chips

  • Simply Sea Salt

    $2.49
  • Sweet Maui Onion

    $2.49
  • Honey BBQ

    $2.49
  • Fire Roasted Jalapeno

    $2.49
  • Chili Lime Caliente

    $2.49
  • Sour Cream & Onion

    $2.49

Merch

  • Bobby Bay Original Tee

    Original Bobby Bay Tee with pictured design on the back and our logo on the front left chest. Color: Faded denim
    $20.00
  • Rep Lancaster Tee

    Repping Lancaster, Bobby Bay Tee. Simple yet fashionable.
    $20.00
  • Golf Club Hat

    Snapback. White with green rope.
    $30.00
  • Bobby Bay 717 Hat

    Bobby Bay Original snapback representing 717. Color: off-white
    $30.00
  • Boat Club Hat

    $30.00
  • Corduroy BB Hat

    $30.00

Catering

Sandwiches

Please place orders over $250 at least 24 hours in advance to ensure it's ready for your scheduled pickup time.
  • Sandwich Lunch Box

    5” deli sandwich, bag of chips (your flavor choice), and chocolate chunk cookie or rice krispy treat (minimum 10 required) CALL IN OR SUBMIT A CATERING REQUEST ON OUR CATERING PAGE FOR THIS ITEM.
    $12.00
  • Sandwich Party Box

    10 - 5" sandwiches. Choose up to 2 different sandwiches. Presented nicely in our branded box. Made with all toppings unless specified otherwise. (we put no onions, on sandwiches that normally come with them) PLEASE PLACE ORDER AT LEAST 2 HOURS IN ADVANCE TO GUARANTEE ITS READY FOR DESIRED PICKUP TIME ***60 minutes minimum notice is needed to ensure it will be ready for your desired pickup time. Schedule hours in advance if need 3+ boxes
    $74.99

Salads

  • House Salad Tray

    Iceberg, cherry tomatoes, red onions, red cabbage, boiled egg, and shredded cheddar. Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
    $24.99
  • Kobb Salad Tray

    Iceberg, tomatoes, onions, red cabbage, boiled egg, bacon, avocado and gorgonzola crumbles. Served with blue cheese. Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
    $32.99
  • Sorrento Salad Tray

    Arugula, fresh basil, fresh mozz, grape tomatoes, pine nuts. Topped with drizzled fig balsamic glaze & EVOO.
    $32.99
  • Puebla Salad Tray

    Tajin grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, pickled red onions, avocado, grape tomatoes, and queso cotija. Served with Jalapeno Ranch
    $45.98

Sides

  • Coleslaw (3lb)

    Ideal for up to 6 people served with other food. Serving utensil provided.
    $14.99

Extras

  • Plate + Utensils

    $0.25
  • Serving Tong

    $1.50
  • Serving Spoon

    $1.25
  • Cherry Peppers (8z)

    $3.65
  • O/V Bottle

    $3.65
  • EVOO Bottle

    $3.99
  • Fig Glaze Bottle

    $3.99
  • Cherry Pepper Mayo (8oz)

    $3.65

Bobby’s Cheesesteak

$14.99

Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, house whiz, cherry pepper mayo

Customize your item

Bobby Cheesesteak Toppings

Optional

Cheese Substitute (cstk)

Select up to 1

Cheesesteak Add-Ons

Select up to 3
1

Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop Location and Ordering Hours

(717) 621-2511
1878 Lincoln Highway East, Lancaster, PA 17602
Open now • Closes at 7:45PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement