Skip to Main content
Thank you for choosing Brewster's!
  • Brewsters New Buffalo

Currently not accepting online orders

Brewster’s New Buffalo

11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI
NA BEVERAGES
DINNER MENU
KIDS MENU
EXTRAS
DESSERTS

Featured Items

  • 12” BYO Pizza

    WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS – 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
    $16.00
  • 12” Sweet + Spicy

    cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
    $20.00
  • House Salad

    mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
    $7.00

NA BEVERAGES

OTHER BEV

  • Acqua Panna Still Water

    $8.00
  • Arnold Palmer

    $4.00
  • Casa Mara Soda

    $8.00
  • Fever Tree

    $8.00
  • Flavored Pelligrino

    blood orange or limonata
    $5.00
  • Fresh Squeezed OJ

    $6.00
  • Ginger Beer

    $4.00
  • gingergrass cbd

    $8.00
  • Iced Tea

    $4.00
  • Italian Soda

    $5.00
  • Juices

    orange, cranberry, or apple
    $4.00
  • Kids Bev

    $4.00
  • Large AquaPanna

    $7.00
  • Large Milk

    $4.00
  • Lavender Lemonade

    $6.00
  • Lemonade

    $4.00
  • Raspberry Lemonade

    $6.00
  • San Pellegrino

    italian natural mineral water 16oz
    $5.00
  • Small Milk

    $3.00
  • Soda

    coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
    $4.00
  • Strawberry Lemonade

    $6.00
  • Tonic

    $3.00

DINNER MENU

12” SOURDOUGH PIES

garlic confit, provolone, fresh mozzarella, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta, hot honey on parmesan crust
  • 12” BETTY WHITE

    garlic confit, fresh mozzarella, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta and hot honey on a parmesan crust
    $18.00
  • 12” New Yorker

    fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
    $18.00
  • 12” Sweet + Spicy

    cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
    $20.00

12” THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES

  • 12” Bianco

    roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
    $18.00
  • 12” Fungi

    garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
    $18.00
  • 12” Marg Pie

    $18.00
  • 12” Quattro Formaggi

    aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
    $16.00

BYO 12”

  • 12” BYO Pizza

    WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS – 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
    $16.00

DINNER PASTA

  • Cacio E Pepe

    black pepper + parmesan + pecorino + linguini + scarpetta
    $26.00
  • Chicken Alfredo

    baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle + reggiano
    $31.00
  • Lemon Basil Chicken

    $31.00
  • Lobster Pomodoro

    $35.00
  • Meatballs

    house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta
    $29.00
  • Roma

    tri-color cheese filled tortellini sautéed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano
    $28.00
  • shrimp alfredo

    baby spinach, roasted pepper and parmesan cream sauce tossed with herb pappardelle and reggiano
    $31.00

DINNER ENTREES

  • Autumn Bourride

    $35.00
  • DINNER FEATURE

    $31.00
  • Halibut and Succotash

    $47.00
  • New York Strip

    $45.00
  • Short Rib & Hummus

    sumac braised short rib with roasted garlic hummus, pomegranate molasses, red onion and mint
    $31.00
  • Tikka Masala

    $31.00

DINNER SALADS

  • Chopped Margherita

    chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
    $17.00
  • Double House

    $14.00
  • Dressing

    $0.75
  • Extra Bread

    $2.00
  • Wedge Salad

    $17.00
  • Hot Soup

    $5.00
  • Hot Soup Quart

    $15.00
  • House Salad

    mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
    $7.00
  • Rustic Steak Salad

    sautéed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
    $21.00
  • Specialty Salad

    seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
    $22.00
  • 1/2 Chop Solo

    $8.00
  • Caesar

    $18.00
  • crispy chicken

    $7.00
  • GAZ BOWL

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

DINNER STARTERS

spicey soy marinated ahi tuna, lemon and wasabi aioli, lime infused basmati rice and avocado
  • Blueberries and Brussel Sprouts

    $16.00
  • Bruschetta

    roma tomatoes + red onion + basil + e.v.o.o. + reggiano aged balsamic reduction w/ crostini
    $18.00
  • Flatbread

    $5.00
  • NAAN Bread

    $3.00
  • Olives and Feta

    $18.00
  • Special App

    $13.00
  • Spinach + Artichoke Dip

    served w/ rustic flatbread
    $16.00

KIDS MENU

KIDS PIZZA

  • KIDS 5" BYO PIZZA

    5" cheese and one topping - choose your base: tomato sauce, pesto or olive oil
    $6.00

KIDS PASTA

  • Kids Pasta Of The Day

    chef's choice of pasta w/ your choice (1) sauce: marinara, olive oil, butter or cheese sauce
    $6.00
  • Kids Roma

    tri-color tortellini tossed in garlic oil w/ roma tomatoes, basil & reggiano cheese $3 per meatball / $3 chicken / $6 seafood
    $7.00

KIDS SIDES

  • SD Broccoli

    $4.00
  • SD Carrots

    $4.00
  • SD Mushrooms

    $4.00

EXTRAS

  • 1 MEATBALL

    $3.00
  • 1/2 PINT DRESSING

    $4.00
  • 4 Shrimp

    $11.00
  • Add Chicken Breast

    $6.00
  • ADULT SIZED MIXED VEG

    $8.00
  • HOUSE BREAD LOAF

    $11.00
  • MARINARA 1/2 pint

    $4.00
  • MARINARA PINT

    $8.00
  • MARINARA QUART

    $16.00
  • PESTO 1/2 pint

    $16.00
  • PESTO PINT

    $32.00
  • PINT DRESSING

    $8.00
  • QUART DRESSING

    $16.00
  • Side Alfredo

    $1.00
  • Side 4 Dinner Meatballs

    $12.00
  • Side 2 Meatballs

    $6.00
  • Side Marinara

    $1.00
  • Side Pesto

    $1.00
  • Side Pizza Sauce

    $0.50
  • Soup Quart

    $15.00
  • SOURDOUGH DOUGH BALLS

    raw dough ball
    $5.00
  • TRADITIONAL DOUGH BALLS

    raw dough ball
    $3.00
  • Salmon Filet 6 oz

    $13.00
  • Side House Dressing

    $0.75
  • Avocado

    $2.00
  • Side of Beef Tips

    $10.00
  • crispy chicken

    $7.00

DESSERTS

  • a la mode

    $3.00
  • Cookies

    $3.00
  • Hummingbird cake

    $12.00
  • Lemon Tres Leches

    $10.00
  • PB Pie

    $11.00
  • Sticky Toffee

    $10.00
  • Tiramisu

    $10.00
  • Pears and cheese

    $13.00

gingergrass cbd

$8.00
1

Brewsters New Buffalo Location and Ordering Hours

(269) 469-3005
11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Closed • Opens Saturday at 9AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement