Skip to Main content
Thank you for choosing Brewster's!
  • Brewsters New Buffalo

Brewster’s New Buffalo

11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI
Pickup Only
‌
‌
NA BEVERAGES
DINNER MENU
KIDS MENU
EXTRAS
DESSERTS

Featured Items

  • 12” BYO Pizza

    WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS – 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
    $16.00
  • 12” Sweet + Spicy

    cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
    $20.00
  • House Salad

    mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
    $7.00

NA BEVERAGES

OTHER BEV

  • Acqua Panna Still Water

    $8.00
  • Arnold Palmer

    $4.00
  • Fever Tree

    $8.00
  • Flavored Pelligrino

    blood orange or limonata
    $5.00
  • Fresh Squeezed OJ

    $6.00
  • Ginger Beer

    $4.00
  • gingergrass cbd

    $8.00
  • Iced Tea

    $4.00
  • Italian Soda

    $5.00
  • Juices

    orange, cranberry, or apple
    $4.00
  • Kids Bev

    $4.00
  • Large AquaPanna

    $7.00
  • Large Milk

    $4.00
  • Lavender Lemonade

    $6.00
  • Lemonade

    $4.00
  • Raspberry Lemonade

    $6.00
  • San Pellegrino

    italian natural mineral water 16oz
    $5.00
  • Small Milk

    $3.00
  • Soda

    coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
    $4.00
  • Strawberry Lemonade

    $6.00
  • Tonic

    $3.00
  • Topo Chico

    Topo Chico has always been known for the legend surrounding its origins. Whether you believe in the legend or not, you'll still be able to enjoy the crisp, no-calorie taste of Topo Chico.
    $5.00

DINNER MENU

12” SOURDOUGH PIES

garlic confit, provolone, fresh mozzarella, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta, hot honey on parmesan crust
  • 12” BETTY WHITE

    garlic confit, fresh mozzarella, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta and hot honey on a parmesan crust
    $18.00
  • 12” New Yorker

    fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
    $18.00
  • 12” Sweet + Spicy

    cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
    $20.00

12” THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES

  • 12” Bianco

    roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
    $18.00
  • 12” Fungi

    garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
    $18.00
  • 12” Marg Pie

    $18.00
  • 12” Quattro Formaggi

    aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
    $16.00

BYO 12”

  • 12” BYO Pizza

    WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS – 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
    $16.00

DINNER PASTA

  • Cacio E Pepe

    black pepper + parmesan + pecorino + linguini + scarpetta
    $26.00
  • Chicken Alfredo

    baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle + reggiano
    $31.00
  • Lemon Basil Chicken

    $31.00
  • Lobster Pomodoro

    $35.00
  • Meatballs

    house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta
    $29.00
  • Roma

    tri-color cheese filled tortellini sautéed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano
    $28.00
  • shrimp alfredo

    baby spinach, roasted pepper and parmesan cream sauce tossed with herb pappardelle and reggiano
    $31.00

DINNER ENTREES

  • Autumn Bourride

    $35.00
  • DINNER FEATURE

    $31.00
  • Halibut and Succotash

    $47.00
  • New York Strip

    $45.00
  • Short Rib & Hummus

    sumac braised short rib with roasted garlic hummus, pomegranate molasses, red onion and mint
    $31.00
  • Tikka Masala

    $31.00

DINNER SALADS

  • Chopped Margherita

    chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
    $17.00
  • Double House

    $14.00
  • Dressing

    $0.75
  • Extra Bread

    $2.00
  • Wedge Salad

    $17.00
  • Hot Soup

    $5.00
  • Hot Soup Quart

    $15.00
  • House Salad

    mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
    $7.00
  • Rustic Steak Salad

    sautéed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
    $21.00
  • Specialty Salad

    seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
    $22.00
  • 1/2 Chop Solo

    $8.00
  • Caesar

    $18.00
  • crispy chicken

    $7.00
  • GAZ BOWL

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

DINNER STARTERS

spicey soy marinated ahi tuna, lemon and wasabi aioli, lime infused basmati rice and avocado
  • Blueberries and Brussel Sprouts

    $16.00
  • Bruschetta

    roma tomatoes + red onion + basil + e.v.o.o. + reggiano aged balsamic reduction w/ crostini
    $18.00
  • Flatbread

    $5.00
  • NAAN Bread

    $3.00
  • Olives and Feta

    $18.00
  • Special App

    $13.00
  • Spinach + Artichoke Dip

    served w/ rustic flatbread
    $16.00

KIDS MENU

KIDS PIZZA

  • KIDS 5" BYO PIZZA

    5" cheese and one topping - choose your base: tomato sauce, pesto or olive oil
    $6.00

KIDS PASTA

  • Kids Pasta Of The Day

    chef's choice of pasta w/ your choice (1) sauce: marinara, olive oil, butter or cheese sauce
    $6.00
  • Kids Roma

    tri-color tortellini tossed in garlic oil w/ roma tomatoes, basil & reggiano cheese $3 per meatball / $3 chicken / $6 seafood
    $7.00

KIDS SIDES

  • SD Broccoli

    $4.00
  • SD Carrots

    $4.00
  • SD Mushrooms

    $4.00

EXTRAS

  • 1 MEATBALL

    $3.00
  • 1/2 PINT DRESSING

    $4.00
  • 4 Shrimp

    $11.00
  • Add Chicken Breast

    $6.00
  • ADULT SIZED MIXED VEG

    $8.00
  • HOUSE BREAD LOAF

    $11.00
  • MARINARA 1/2 pint

    $4.00
  • MARINARA PINT

    $8.00
  • MARINARA QUART

    $16.00
  • PESTO 1/2 pint

    $16.00
  • PESTO PINT

    $32.00
  • PINT DRESSING

    $8.00
  • QUART DRESSING

    $16.00
  • Side Alfredo

    $1.00
  • Side 4 Dinner Meatballs

    $12.00
  • Side 2 Meatballs

    $6.00
  • Side Marinara

    $1.00
  • Side Pesto

    $1.00
  • Side Pizza Sauce

    $0.50
  • Soup Quart

    $15.00
  • SOURDOUGH DOUGH BALLS

    raw dough ball
    $5.00
  • TRADITIONAL DOUGH BALLS

    raw dough ball
    $3.00
  • Salmon Filet 6 oz

    $13.00
  • Side House Dressing

    $0.75
  • Avocado

    $2.00
  • Side of Beef Tips

    $10.00
  • crispy chicken

    $7.00

DESSERTS

  • a la mode

    $3.00
  • Cookies

    $3.00
  • Hummingbird cake

    $12.00
  • Lemon Tres Leches

    $10.00
  • PB Pie

    $11.00
  • Sticky Toffee

    $10.00
  • Tiramisu

    $10.00
  • Pears and cheese

    $13.00

PINT DRESSING

$8.00
1

Brewsters New Buffalo Location and Ordering Hours

(269) 469-3005
11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Open now • Closes at 8:45PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement