small plates...BIG STEAKS!
Brooklyn and the Butcher
148 E Market St, New Albany, IN
Pickup Only
Soup & Salads

San Marzano Tomato Soup
San Marzano Tomato and Basil Pesto Soup / Parmesan / Focaccia$12.00
Brooklyn Wedge
Iceberg Wedge / Gremolata / Smoked Tomatoes / Bacon / House Blue Cheese Dressing$12.00
Caesar Salad
Roma Crunch / Parmesan / Brioche Croutons / House Ceasar Dressing$12.00
Golden Beet Salad
Roasted Candy Stripe & Gold Beet Salad / Arugula / Pickled Fennel / Goat Cheese / Blood Orange-Champagne VinaigretteOUT OF STOCK$16.00
Sides For The Table
Lemon Grilled Broccolini

Whipped SD
Creamy Red Potatoes / Boursin Cheese / Chives$9.00Baked Potato
Baked Potato / Butcher's Spice / Butter$7.00
Loaded Potato
Cheddar / Sour Cream / Smoked Bacon / Chives$9.00
Truffle Frites
Frites / White Truffle Oil / Parmesan$9.00
Asparagus SD
Sauteed Asparagus / Black Truffle Bearnaise$9.00
Broccolini SD
Haricot Vert/ Shallot / Garlic / Lemon Anchovy Butter$9.00
Brussels SD
Brussels Sprouts / Sorghum Mustard Dressing / Lardon / Pickled Fennel$12.00Mushrooms SD
Local Mushrooms / Worcestershire Butter$12.00
Mac +Chz SD
Cavatappi / Jarlsberg / Cheddar / Parmesan Breadcrumb$13.00
Parmesan Risotto SD
Parmesan Risotto & Fava Bean$12.00
Small Plates

Butcher Board
Chef's whim of rotating meats and cheeses, served with seasonal pickles and crostini$22.00
Baked Goat Cheese
Tomato Jam / Basil Pesto / Focaccia$20.00
Icy Blue Mussels
Icy Blue Mussels / White Wine / Roasted Garlic / Basil Pesto / Focaccia$24.00Calabrian Chicken Lollipop
Calabrian-Honey Glazed Chicken Lollipop / Celery Root PureeOUT OF STOCK$19.00Braised Octopus + Crispy Calamari
Braised Octopus & Crispy Calamari / Arrabbiata / Castelvetrano Olive / Caper BerryOUT OF STOCK$27.00
Big Steaks

Picanha 8oz
Boldly seasoned with Butcher's Spice blend and hard seared to perfection.$39.00
Filet 7oz
$65.00
Ny Strip 12oz
$46.00
Ribeye 12oz
$48.00
Composed Plates

Chicken Composed
Creamy Polenta / Wild Mushroom / Marsala Demi / Crispy Sage$33.00
Salmon Composed
Verlasso Salmon / Creamy Polenta / Lemon Charred Broccolini / Roasted Red Pepper Bruschetta$36.00
Osso Buco
Horseradish-Celery Root Puree / Crispy Wild Mushroom / Gremolata$39.00
Bucatini Carbonara
Shallot / Lardon / Fava Bean / Parmesan$24.00
Chicken Fettucine
Alfredo / Asparagus / Roasted Tomato / Parmesan$21.00
Sweets

Bread Pudding
Apple-Golden Raisin Bread Pudding / Bourbon Caramel / Candied Pecans / Vanilla Ice Cream$12.00
Tiramisu
Espresso Syrup Soaked Ladyfinger Layered w/ Sweetened Mascarpone Filling / Chocolate Covered Espresso Bean$12.00
Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake / Graham Cracker Crust / Amarena Cherries$12.00
Neapolitan Cake
Strawberry Vanilla & Chocolate Cake Layered w/ Sweetened Mascarpone Filling / Lemon Blueberry Compote$12.00
Brooklyn and The Butcher Locations and Ordering Hours
Brooklyn and the Butcher
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 5PM