Skip to Main content
Don’t forget those takeout drinks!

  • Casa Nueva

Currently not accepting online orders

Casa Nueva 4 West State Street

4 West State Street, Athens, OH

Featured Items

  • Build Your Own Quesadilla

    Housemade flour tortilla grilled with Jack cheese and your choice of up to three fillings and served with your choice of salsa.
    $17.00

  • Build Your Own Burrito

    Housemade flour tortilla baked with onions, Jack cheese, your choice of beans, choice of two fillings and a salsa.
    $18.00

  • Albany Clucker Quesadilla

    A flour tortilla grilled with onions, bell peppers, and chicken with your choice of salsa on the side.
    $16.50

PM MENU

STARTERS

  • Chips and One Salsa

    One house made salsa with corn tortilla chips from Shagbark Seed & Mill
    $6.50

  • Chips and Guacamole

    House made guacamole with chips from Shagbark Seed & Mill
    $8.50

  • Salsa Sampler

    Shagbark chips with your choice of four salsas.
    $12.00

  • Guac Sampler

    Shagbark chips with guacamole and your choice of two salsas.
    $12.00

  • Muy Grande Nacho

    Shagbark tortilla chips baked with Jack cheese, choice of beans, tomatoes and shredded lettuce.
    $15.00

  • Queso con Chiles

    House made queso dip with chips, pita, or both.
    $13.00

  • Six Layer Dip

    Refried beans, Jack cheese, onions, tomatoes, sour cream and guacamole with your choice of chips, pita, or both.
    $14.00

  • Half Order Tofu Fries

    Deep fried tofu seasoned with cajun spice, served with spicy soy mayo.
    $7.50

  • Full Order Tofu Fries

    Deep fried tofu seasoned with cajun spice, served with spicy soy mayo.
    $14.50

  • Small Empanda

    Deep fried Jack cheese in a crispy pastry shell.
    $4.00

  • Vegetarian Chili Cup

    Tomato based black bean and tofu vegetarian chili.
    $5.50

  • Vegetarian Chili Bowl

    Tomato based black bean and tofu vegetarian chili.
    $9.00

  • Neighbor Loaves and Meals Chili

    The purchase of this item donates one bowl of our vegetarian chili to an individual in need in Athens county.
    $8.00

  • SMALLIES APPETIZER

    $12.00

SALADS

  • Side Salad

    Salad greens, carrots, red cabbage, house made croutons, seasonally available accoutrements.
    $7.00

  • House Salad

    Salad greens, carrots, red cabbage, house made croutons, seasonally available accoutrements.
    $12.00

  • Rice Salad

    Salad greens, carrots, red cabbage, jasmine rice, veggies of the day, seasonally available accoutrements.
    $14.50

  • Taco Salad

    Salad greens, carrots, red cabbage, tomato, black olives, Jack cheese, vegetarian chili, guacamole, tortilla chips.
    $14.50

CASA CLASSICS

  • Half Que Pasa Burrito

    Half a flour tortilla with onions, Jack cheese, cream cheese, guacamole, tomatoes, black olives, baked with your choice of salsa.
    $11.00

  • Que Pasa Burrito

    A full flour tortilla with onions, Jack cheese, cream cheese, guacamole, black olives, tomatoes, baked with your choice of salsa.
    $19.00

  • Half Vegan Burrito

    Half a flour tortilla with onions, tofu, veggies of the day, black beans, rice, baked with your choice of salsa.
    $9.00

  • Vegan Burrito

    A full flour tortilla with onions, tofu, veggies of the day, black beans, rice, baked with your choice of salsa.
    $16.50

  • One Enchilada Verde

    One corn tortilla with cream cheese, Jack cheese, green chiles, onions, and your choice of filling baked with our verde salsa.
    $11.00

  • Two Enchilada Verde

    Corn tortillas with cream cheese, Jack cheese, green chiles, onions, and your choice of filling baked with our verde salsa.
    $20.00

  • Quesadilla del Rey

    A flour tortilla grilled with onions, poblano chiles, and chorizo with your choice of salsa on the side.
    $16.50

  • Albany Clucker Quesadilla

    A flour tortilla grilled with onions, bell peppers, and chicken with your choice of salsa on the side.
    $16.50

  • Veggie Quesadilla

    A flour tortilla stuffed with Jack cheese, onions, bell peppers, tomatoes, and veggies of the day, grilled and served with your choice of salsa.
    $16.50

  • Que Pasa Quesadilla

    A flour tortilla grilled with Jack cheese, onions, black olives, tomatoes, guacamole, with your choice of salsa on the side.
    $16.50

SEASONAL ITEMS

FEATURED INGREDIENTS ||| HARVEST VERDE Our house verde, souped up with poblanos & tomatillos that we source locally and roast at our AceNet space, as well as some pepitas & fresh lime juice || MEXILACHIAN SUCCOTASH This twist on an Appalachian favorite features black & pinto beans from Shagbark Seed & Mill, sweet corn & tomatoes from the Chester Hill Produce Auction, and some other flavors of the borderlands || PEARL VALLEY FARMER CHEESE The sliceable, shreddable, meltable style, made in Fresno, OH || SWEET CORN ICE CREAM Yeah, you read that right. Once you try it you’ll want more!

  • Cheese & Pickle Plate

    Middlefield Farmer Cheese & other Ohio cheeses, house pickled veggies, house made crackers, & other local goodies market price Add Spicy Chicken Salad $4
    $15.00

  • Small Seasonal Salad

    Salad greens, succotash, farmer cheese, & other local/seasonal ingredients, honey mustard vinaigrette
    $8.75

  • Mexilachian Succotash

    Local sweet corn, local roasted tomatoes, Shagbark black & pinto beans, bell peppers, onions, and sometimes another secret local veggie Served with Shagbark chips
    $9.00

  • Half Seasonal Burrito

    Succotash, farmer cheese, rice, onions, Harvest Verde
    $9.50

  • Seasonal Burrito

    Succotash, farmer cheese, rice, onions, Harvest Verde
    $18.00

  • Seasonal Stacked Enchilada

    Succotash, farmer cheese, rice & onions layered between two Koki’s corn torts, Harvest Verde
    $16.00

  • One Street Taco

    BEERBACOA TACOS Local beer brined beef roast, braised with Beer Chile Roasted Garlic Salsa, in Koki’s corn tortillas with Snowville Cheddar, onions, cilantro $7 each (Other protein fillings are available, but it won't be presented quite the same) **Tofu contains peanuts, soy, and wheat
    $7.00

  • Two Street Taco

    BEERBACOA TACOS Local beer brined beef roast, braised with Beer Chile Roasted Garlic Salsa, in Koki’s corn tortillas with Snowville Cheddar, onions, cilantro $7 each (Other protein fillings are available, but it won't be presented quite the same) **Tofu contains peanuts, soy, and wheat
    $14.00

  • Three Street Tacos

    BEERBACOA TACOS Local beer brined beef roast, braised with Beer Chile Roasted Garlic Salsa, in Koki’s corn tortillas with Snowville Cheddar, onions, cilantro $7 each (Other protein fillings are available, but it won't be presented quite the same) **Tofu contains peanuts, soy, and wheat
    $21.00

  • Big Seasonal Salad

    Greens, succotash, tofu or pork chile verde, farmer cheese, & other local/seasonal ingredients honey mustard vinaigrette dressing. Market price
    $20.00

  • SIDE PICKLED RED ONIONS

    $3.00

  • Side Mexilachian Succotash

    This twist on an Appalachian favorite features black & pinto beans from Shagbark Seed & Mill, sweet corn & tomatoes from the Chester Hill Produce Auction, and some other flavors of the borderlands
    $4.00

BUILD YOUR OWN

  • Half Build Your Own Burrito

    Half flour tortilla baked with onions, Jack cheese, your choice of beans, choice of two fillings and a salsa.
    $9.50

  • Build Your Own Burrito

    Housemade flour tortilla baked with onions, Jack cheese, your choice of beans, choice of two fillings and a salsa.
    $18.00

  • Build Your Own Chimichanga

    THIS ITEM IS ONLY AVAILABLE AFTER 3PM. Please schedule your order accordingly. A build your own burrito, deep fried and then baked with your choice of salsa.
    $21.00

  • Build Your Own Quesadilla

    Housemade flour tortilla grilled with Jack cheese and your choice of up to three fillings and served with your choice of salsa.
    $17.00

  • Stacked Enchilada

    Onions, Jack cheese and your choice of two fillings and a salsa baked in between two corn tortillas.
    $16.00

  • One Rolled Enchilada

    Your choice of two fillings, onions, Jack cheese, wrapped in a corn tortilla and baked with choice of salsa.
    $10.00

  • Two Rolled Enchilada

    Your choice of two fillings, onions, Jack cheese, wrapped in corn tortillas and baked with choice of salsa.
    $19.00

  • One Taco

    Soft flour, soft corn, or crispy corn shell, protein filling sauteed in salsa Ranchera, topped with Jack cheese and shredded lettuce
    $6.25

  • Two Tacos

    Two tacos with soft flour, soft corn, or crispy corn shell, protein filling sauteed in salsa Ranchera, topped with Jack cheese and shredded lettuce
    $12.00

  • Three Tacos

    Three tacos with soft flour, soft corn, or crispy corn shell, protein filling sauteed in salsa Ranchera, topped with Jack cheese and shredded lettuce
    $18.25

  • Street Wrap

    Choice of beans with guacamole, onions, tomatoes, Jack cheese and shredded lettuce all wrapped in a warm flour tortilla.
    $11.00

  • To the Hills

    Rice & your choice of black or refried beans and your choice of tortilla.
    $8.00

  • Hills Deluxe

    Our basic Hills stepped up with shredded lettuce and your choice of two salsas.
    $12.00

  • Cheese Quesadilla

    Monterey Jack in a grilled house made flour tortilla
    $9.00

DESSERTS

  • Brownie Smackdown

    A warm double chocolate brownie, house made vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup, & Snowville Whipped Cream
    $15.00

  • SEASONAL SMACKDOWN

    A slice of Rhubarb Crumble Tart with a scoop of sweet corn ice cream, blackberry gastrique, & whipped cream made with Snowville cream and Sticky Pete’s maple syrup
    $16.00

  • Double Chocolate Brownie

    Our famous vegan chocolate brownie.
    $6.50

  • Spiced Apple Crumble Cheesecake

    Our housemade cheesecake flavors change often. Call for details.
    $10.00

  • House Made Vanilla Ice Cream

    A triple scoop of our house made vanilla or Mexican chocolate ice cream.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00+

  • Seasonal Ice Cream

    SWEET CORN ICE CREAM Yeah, you read that right. Once you try it you’ll want more!
    $4.50+

  • Pumpkin Pie Empanadas

    Featured vegan dessert
    $9.00

  • Pumpkin Pie

    Today's baker's choice dessert (May not be in the pic)
    $9.00

  • Rhubarb Crumble Tart

    $9.00

KID'S MENU

  • Hills Junior

    $5.00

  • Kid's Burrito Wrap

    $6.00

  • Kid's Quesadilla

    $6.00

  • Kid's Nacho

    $5.00

  • Kid Grilled Cheese

    $6.00

  • Kid's Taco

    $6.00

  • Kid's Empanada

    $6.00

SIDES

  • Extra Plate

  • Side Applesauce

    $3.00

  • Side Bell Peppers

    $3.00

  • Side Black Beans

    $3.00

  • Side Black Olives

    $3.00

  • Side Butter

    $1.00

  • Side Cheese

    $3.00

  • Side Chicken

    $7.00

  • Side Chips

    $4.50

  • Side Chips/Pita

    $6.50

  • Side Chorizo

    $7.00

  • Side Cilantro

    $2.00

  • Side Corn Tortilla

    $2.00

  • Side Dressing

    $3.00

  • Side Green Chiles

    $3.00

  • Side Ground Beef

    $7.00

  • Side Guacamole

    $5.00

  • Side Jalapenos

    $3.00

  • Side Peanut Soy Tofu

    Contains peanuts, soy, and wheat
    $5.50

  • Side Pita

    $4.50

  • Side Poblanos

    $3.00

  • Side Refried Beans

    $3.00

  • Side Rice

    $3.00

  • Side Salsa

    $3.00

  • Side Smack Sauce

    Applesauce Gastrique
    $3.00

  • Side Sour Cream

    $2.00

  • Side Spicy Soy Mayo

    $3.00

  • Side Tomatoes

    $3.00

  • Side Tortilla

    $3.00

  • Side Vegan Nacho Cheese

    $3.00

  • Side Veggie 1

    $4.50

  • Side Veggie 2

    $4.50

  • Side Both Veggies

    $4.50

  • Side Wax Peppers

    $3.00

  • Side Small Chips

    $3.00

BULK FOOD

Strawbanero Locally sourced strawberries and our house made habanero salsa loom large in this sweet and spicy sauce

  • 10 Flour Tortillas

    Hand rolled flour tortillas.
    $19.00

  • 5 Flour Tortillas

    Hand rolled flour tortillas.
    $10.00

  • Bloody Mix Pint

    $9.00

  • Bulk Beans and Rice

    Family sized portions of our black beans, refried beans, and jasmine rice.
    $6.00+

  • Bulk Guacamole

    $14.00+

  • Salsas/Dressings

    Find our salsas, dressings, queso dip, soysage gravy and vegetarian chili here!
    $8.00+

  • Coffee Pound

    Locally roasted Ridgerunner coffee for your home needs.
    $14.00

  • Granola Pound

    Casa's own housemade granola for your home.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $8.00

  • Seasonal Ice Cream Pint

    A full pint of our hand crafted lavender ice cream. Bargain city!
    $14.00

  • Shagbark Chips Bag

    Shargbark yellow corn tortilla chips.
    $7.00

  • Soysage Pound

    Our famous handmade soysage.
    $10.00

  • Vanilla Ice Cream Pint

    A full pint of our delicious house made vanilla bean ice cream!
    $12.00

  • Bulk Vegetarian Chili

    $8.00+

FRIDAY LATE NITE SPECIAL BEVERAGE

FRIDAY LATE NITE SPECIALS

  • $5 PINT

    $5.00

  • $4 Well Mixer

    Excludes sour mixers
    $4.00

Casa Nueva Location and Ordering Hours

(740) 592-2016
4 West State Street, Athens, OH 45701
Closed • Opens Saturday at 9AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement