Skip to Main content
  • Harp and Fiddle

Currently not accepting online orders

Casey's New Buffalo

136 N WHITTAKER ST, New Buffalo, MI
Appetizers
Tacos
Soup
Salads & Bowls
Entrees
Burgers
Sandwiches
Dessert
Kids
Extra Sides
Forge Party

Featured Items

  • Kids Burger

    Kids' size cheeseburger with American cheese, choice of fries or applesauce
    $8.00
  • Sriracha Chicken Sandwich

    Chicken breast marinated in our buttermilk and fried with sliced pickle, coleslaw, and pepper jack cheese, with a siracha ranch sauce (option for grilled)
    $18.00
  • Casey’s Original

    Two 4oz certified prime beef patties, includes upon request lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Add cheese and other toppings of your choice
    $17.00

Appetizers

  • Artichoke Spin Dip

    Spinach and artichokes, blended with cheddar and Monterey jack cheeses topped with Bruschetta. Served with homemade corn tortilla chips
    $15.00
  • Beer Cheese Fondue

    Wisconsin aged cheddar, infused with beer from the tap and served with mini pretzel balls
    $12.00
  • Cheese Curds

    Beer battered Wisconsin cheddar cheese curds, served with marinara sauce and ranch
    $14.00
  • Chips and Dip

    Casey’s signature chips with creamy beer and onion dip or briny pickle dip
    $7.00
  • Firecracker Shrimp

    Lightly dusted and fried, tossed in a sweet and spicy sauce and sprinkled with shredded coconut
    $15.00
  • Fried Pickles

    Pickle spears beer-battered and deep fried, served with gochujang mayo and ranch dipping sauces
    $12.00
  • Maryland Crab Cakes

    Fresh crab with bell peppers, cilantro, garlic and spices. Lightly sautéed and served with a Baja sauce
    $17.00
  • New Buffalo Wings

    Crispy style. Choose form BBQ, buffalo or garlic-parmesan.
    $16.00
  • Black and Blue Tater Tots

    Crispy cajun spiced tater tots smothered in melted creamy brie and topped with bleu cheese, green onions and bacon
    $15.00

Tacos

  • Birria Tacos

    Stewed, shredded beef, white cheddar on a crispy, grilled corn tortilla
    $17.00
  • Mahi Mahi Tacos

    Blackened mahi-mahi, pineapple, red pepper, and cilantro salsa, drizzled with a lime-avocado sauce
    $18.00
  • Carne Asada Tacos

    Slices of marinated sirloin steak, cooked to medium with white cheddar, cilantro, chimichurri sauce and onion
    $19.00

Soup

  • Clam Chowder-Cup

    A Casey's signature item! Creamy chowder with clams and potatoes.
    $6.00
  • Clam Chowder Bowl

    A Casey's signature item! Creamy chowder with clams and potatoes.
    $9.00
  • Chicken Tortilla Cup

    Hearty flavors of the Southwest! Topped with tortilla strips
    $5.00
  • Chicken Tortilla Bowl

    Hearty flavors of the Southwest! Topped with tortilla strips
    $8.00
  • Cup Chili

    Hearty steak chili served with onions and shredded cheese Add sour cream $1
    $7.00
  • Chili Bowl

    Hearty steak chili served with onions and shredded cheese Add sour cream $1
    $10.00
  • Chili Quart

    $18.00

Salads & Bowls

  • Banh-Mi Bowl

    Marinated and grilled tofu, with pickled daikon slaw, fresh jalapeño and cilantro served over rice and quinoa, with a miso vinaigrette
    $17.00
  • Beet and Goat Cheese

    Arugula and mixed greens, with diced beets, goat cheese crumbles and candied walnuts, and a maple vinaigrette.
    $15.00
  • Caesar Salad

    Romaine, shaved parmesan, homemade croutons and a tarragon Caesar dressing.
    $13.00
  • Dinner Side Salad

    Mixed greens with cucumber, cherry tomatoes, red onion and croutons. Choice of dressing
    $6.00
  • Poke Bowl

    Ahi tuna dressed with miso vinaigrette over sushi rice, cucumber, edamame, shaved carrot, sliced avocado, and drizzled with a sriracha mayo
    $19.00
  • Southwestern Cobb

    Chipotle grilled chicken, chopped bacon, corn & black bean salsa, pico de gallo, scallions, boiled egg, blue cheese crumbles and tortilla strips on a bed of mixed greens, with Southwestern ranch dressing
    $16.00
  • Sirloin Salad

    Sirloin steak cooked medium, with red onions, bleu cheese, and a chimichurri vinaigrette over fresh spring greens
    $18.00
  • Mahi-Mahi Bowl

    Quinoa and rice tipped with blackened mahi-mahi, fresh avocado, purple cabbage slaw, Baja and Greek yogurt sauces, cotija cheese and crunchy tortilla strips. Add jalapeños for a kick!
    $19.00
  • Harvest Bowl

    Quinoa and wild rice topped with honey roasted acorn squash, crispy shaved Brussels Sprouts, dried cranberries, goat cheese and pepitas and a maple vinaigrette.
    $17.00

Entrees

  • Cherry Smoked BBQ Ribs

    Slow cooked and smoked in-house, smothered in blackberry BBQ sauce. Served with coleslaw and your choice of side
    $20.00+
  • Fish & Chips

    Beer-battered fresh Atlantic cod, with lemon, tartar sauce and fries
    $24.00
  • Great Lakes Perch

    Fresh Great Lakes perch lightly dusted in seasoned flour and fried crispy. Served with lemon and gin lime butter, vegetable of the day and your choice of side
    $29.00
  • Irish Pub Curry

    Sautéed chicken in a creamy curry sauce with golden raisins. Served with jasmine rice
    $21.00
  • Casey’s Mac & Cheese

    Cavatappi noodles, smoked Gouda, cheddar and Monterey jack chesses, topped with a herb breadcrumb crust
    $17.00
  • Salmon Chimichurri

    Seared salmon filet topped with a chilled tomato and olive salad and served on chimichurri rice
    $26.00
  • Chicken Shawarma Bowl

    Spiced, marinated chicken over tabouli with hummus, cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes and onions and topped with a Greek yogurt sauce.
    $19.00
  • 14 oz Ribeye

    Boneless ribeye steak, cooked to your liking, topped with a garlic shallot butter and served with mashed potatoes and roasted carrots.
    $37.00
  • Sausage and Red Pepper Rigatoni

    Rigatoni and spicey Italian sausage tossed in a creamy roasted red pepper sauce
    $20.00
  • Braised Short Rib

    Braised short rib over creamy parmesan polenta and red wine gravy, served with roasted carrots.
    $23.00
  • Fresno Chicken

    Airline chicken marinated in a Fresno chili vinaigrette with an Asian broccoli salad and rice
    $22.00

Burgers

  • Casey’s Original

    Two 4oz certified prime beef patties, includes upon request lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Add cheese and other toppings of your choice
    $17.00
  • Blackberry Jalapeno Burger

    Blackened patty with Havarti cheese, bacon, jalapenos, red onion and a blackberry BBQ sauce
    $19.00
  • Harbor Burger

    8oz certified prime patty with cabernet glazed onions, smoked bacon, fired egg, provolone cheese and ground pepper aioli
    $19.00
  • Shroomed Burger

    8oz certified prime patty with sautéed mushrooms, gouda cheese, crispy fried onions and truffle aioli
    $19.00
  • The Melt Down

    Melted Havarti cheese, grilled onions, bacon and a schmear of pickle infused cream cheese, on toasted sourdough bread.
    $19.00

Sandwiches

  • Banh-Mi Sandwich

    A Vietnamese sandwich with grilled marinated tofu, pickled daikon slaw, fresh jalapeños and cilantro, and gochujang mayo served on a baguette
    $17.00
  • BBQ Pulled Pork

    Slow-cooked pulled pork, blackberry BBQ sauce and coleslaw
    $17.00
  • Grilled Cheese and Bacon

    Havarti cheese, smoked bacon, and sliced tomato, with blackberry jam, and sourdough toast
    $15.00
  • Perch Po' Boy

    Cajun battered perch with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and chipotle mayo, on a toasted hoagie roll
    $19.00
  • Philly Steak

    Prime sirloin sliced and grilled, sautéed onions and peppers with our house beer cheese sauce served on a toasted hoagie
    $18.00
  • Sriracha Chicken Sandwich

    Chicken breast marinated in our buttermilk and fried with sliced pickle, coleslaw, and pepper jack cheese, with a siracha ranch sauce (option for grilled)
    $18.00
  • Sirloin Steak Sandwich

    Tender sirloin steak with horsey sauce, grilled onions, and arugula topped with crumbled seasoned potato chips on a hoagie roll.
    $20.00
  • Open-Faced Short Rib Sandwich

    House made short rib and red wine gravy with havarti on a toasted baguette, drizzled with horsey sauce. Topped with onion straws.
    $18.00

Dessert

  • Bread Pudding

    Homemade vanilla, cinnamon bread pudding with streusel topping, drizzled with an Irish cream liqueur sauce and topped with whipped cream. Enough for 2-4 ppl to share!
    $10.00
  • Flourless Chocolate Torte

    Rich flourless chocolate cake drizzled with caramel sauce and whipped cream
    $10.00
  • Peach Cobbler

    Housemade cobbler with fruit and topped with a crumble. Served with vanilla ice cream and caramel drizzle
    $10.00
  • Designer Cake-Chocolate Mousse

    Delicious delicacies baked fresh for Casey's by our friends at Designer Desserts! This week's flavor: Chocolate Mousse
    $14.00

Kids

  • Kids Mac & Cheese

    Kraft mac and cheese with fries or applesauce
    $8.00
  • Chicken Nuggets

    Chicken nuggets with a choice of fries or applesauce
    $8.00
  • Kids Burger

    Kids' size cheeseburger with American cheese, choice of fries or applesauce
    $8.00

Extra Sides

  • Side French Fries

    $5.00
  • Pineapple Cole Slaw

    $4.00
  • Side Truffle fries

    $7.00
  • Side Mac & Cheese

    Cavatappi noodles, cheddar, monterey jack and smoked gouda sauce, topped with parmesan herb breadcrumb crust
    $5.00
  • Side Homemade Chips

    $4.00
  • Side Tortilla Chips

    $4.00
  • Side Sweet Potato Tots

    $5.00

Forge Party

  • 14 oz Ribeye

    $45.00
  • Great Lakes Perch

    $30.00
  • Cajun Alfredo Rigatoni

    $24.00
  • Sriracha Chicken Sandwich

    $22.00

Side Truffle fries

$7.00
1

Harp and Fiddle Locations and Ordering Hours

Casey's New Buffalo

(269) 469-6400
136 N WHITTAKER ST, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Open now • Closes at 8:30PM

Harp and Fiddle

(847) 720-4466
110 Main St, Park Ridge, IL 60068
Open now • Closes at 8:30PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement