Your choice of any flavor between two house-baked sugar cookies

Your choice of any flavor between two house-baked chocolate chip cookies

Real lemon, strawberries, and cane sugar swirled into an ice!

Classic Italian ice flavor. Real lemon and cane sugar processed into an almost creamy frozen treat! Deliziosa!

Nondairy chocolate ice cream made with real cocoa and sugar.

Nondairy ice cream made with molasses and brown sugar with chocolate creme cookies

Nondairy pistachio ice cream with salted pistachios

the PumQueen that you know and love, just vegan/dairy-free!

Chocolate ice cream, brownies, candy-coated mini chocolate chips

Blackberry-vanilla ice cream with real blackberries and chocolate chunks.

Blueberry cheesecake ice cream with real blueberry swirl and hunks of cheesecake

Local (Cleveland, OH) Hillson buttered pecans in smooth nutty base

A Cockeye signature chef-inspired flavor: made with fresh-baked buttermilk pies from Cockeye BBQ’s kitchen

Black cherry and rich chocolate super-premium ice cream w/ chocolate chunks, brownies, and hunks of real black cherries

Increasingly famous chocolate ice cream with local (Cleveland, OH) salted pecans

Cookie dough (molasses, brown sugar) ice cream with chocolate creme cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough

Our Deep Chocolate super-premium ice cream filled with brownies, chocolate sandwich cookies, and chocolate chunks

Award-winning traditional chocolate ice cream. Milk, cream, sugar, cocoa. Look no further.

Award-winning traditional French vanilla ice cream, made with milk, cream, sugar, egg, premium Madagascar vanilla beans

Award-winning strawberry ice cream made with strawberry fruit puree, vanilla, and real strawberries

Cotton candy super-premium ice cream, made with real cotton candy flossugar and loaded with colorful nonpareils & fizzy, crackling cotton candy pieces

Real Ohio wildflower honey, vanilla, and lavender

Banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes

Mint chocolate ice cream: creme de menthe, dark chocolate chunks

IT'S A GRAVEYARD SMASH! All of your favorites from the trick or treat bag. Snickers, Heath, and Butterfinger candies!

A Cockeye signature: Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, and dark chocolate chunks

Traditional green pistachio super-premium ice cream with halved salted pistachios

PINK cake batter super-premium ice cream, house-made icing swirl, white chocolate chips. 100% of the pint proceeds supports Pink Lights the Way!

Pumpkin cheesecake super-premium ice cream with creamy cheesecake pieces

Pumpkin super-premium ice cream with cinnamon and graham cracker swirls

Salted caramel super-premium base filled with chewy brownie pieces

Fruity Pebbles super-premium ice cream

Our French vanilla bean ice cream with maraschino cherries

Coffee-flavored super-premium ice cream made with fresh ground Youngstown Coffee Co. espresso beans, chocolate chunks, and brownies

Cockeye BBQ's Original BBQ sauce, now available in retail jars for bringing Cockeye flavor home!

Cockeye BBQ's Hot BBQ sauce. Add a little kick to your smoked, grilled, or otherwise prepared proteins!

Cockeye BBQ's Hot BBQ sauce. Add a little kick to your smoked, grilled, or otherwise prepared proteins!

Just tell us what size and color at the register!

A cute little koozie that fits Cockeye Creamery pints. You'll wish you had this when you're eating a pint on your couch!

Bottled in Salem, OH!