Skip to Main content
Hello! Please first select your pick up date, then browse the menu. Thanks!
  • Fairport Harbor Creamery

Fairport Harbor Creamery

202 High St, Fairport Harbor, OH
Pickup Only
‌
‌
FREAKY FLAVOR BOX
THANKSGIVING '26 - only avail for pick up, 11/25 11A-6P
Ice Cream Pies & Cakes
Ice Cream
Bakery

FREAKY FLAVOR BOX

All 10 freaky flavors, scooped and waiting for you to come pick up, anytime between 10/7 - 10/31 ...the catch? We don't tell you the flavors before you buy :).
  • FREAKY FLAVOR BOX

    All 10 freaky flavors, scooped and waiting for you to come pick up, anytime between 10/7 - 10/31 ...the catch? We don't tell you the flavors before you buy :).
    $31.00

THANKSGIVING '26 - only avail for pick up, 11/25 11A-6P

THANKSGIVING '26 - only avail for pick up, 11/25 11A-6P **if you need an alternate pick up day - please email hello@fairportharborcreamery.com with your pick up day / time and we can see what we can make work for you!
  • Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake ICE CREAM PIE

    graham crust + pumpkin caramel cheesecake ice cream, house caramel, our graham crumbles, buttercream decor
    $36.00
  • Chocolate Turtle ICE CREAM PIE

    chocolate crust + chocolate ice cream layered with house caramel, salty pecans and fudge. buttercream decor
    $36.00
  • 10" Pumpkin Cake

    10", 1 layer spiced pumpkin cake, cream cheese frosting, fall buttercream decor. $36, serves 12+
    $36.00
  • 9" Winterberry Cheesecake

    house graham crust, vanilla cheesecake, house winterberry jam, vanilla buttercream. $32, serves 8+
    $32.00
  • 9" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

    chocolate crust, peanut butter mousse (whipped cream folded into cream cheese & peanut butter blend), chocolate ganache & chocolate decor. $32, serves 8+
    $32.00
  • 9" Pumpkin Coffee Cake

    pumpkin spice sour cream coffee cake, streusel crunch layer & a pumpkin vanilla bean glaze. $17, serves 8+
    $17.00
  • 4" Bourbon Pecan Tart

    graham crust filled with our house bourbon pecan pie filling, pecan pieces and 1/2s, comes with a side of fresh whipped cream
    $6.00
  • 4" Chocolate Caramel Tart

    4" graham crust, house caramel & chocolate ganache, buttercream & chocolate straws/pearls
    $6.00
  • 4" Lemon Curd Tart

    our sugar cookie crust, house lemon curd and decorated with buttercream, lemon zest and while chocolate decor
    $6.00
  • 4" Biscoff Cheesecake Tart

    our ginger molasses crust, house cheesecake mousse, decorated with biscoff cookie butter and biscoff cookie crumbles
    $6.00
  • Box of 4 Tarts

    Choose a mix of any 4 tarts!
    $21.00
  • Cinnamon Rolls, (take&bake, 4)

    tin of 4 of our brioche cinnamon rolls, ready for an overnight pause out of the fridge, and then ready to bake. side of our tangy cream cheese frosting
    $21.00
  • Cinnamon Rolls (take&bake, 6)

    tin of 6 of our brioche cinnamon rolls, ready for an overnight pause out of the fridge, and then ready to bake. side of our tangy cream cheese frosting
    $30.00

Ice Cream Pies & Cakes

Ice Cream Pies

  • Customized Ice Cream Pie **NEED 48HRS NOTICE**

    Don't like our options? We get it. You're the creative genius here! Build your own ice cream pie, add toppings as you please. **NEED 48 HRS NOTICE** If your pick up date isn't 48 hrs from when we receive your order, we will be calling you. Don't make us do that please :)
    $35.00
  • Cookie Dough Fudge Ice Cream Pie

    Chocolate crust, layers of cookie dough ice cream & fudge and house caramel drizzles. Decorated with vanilla buttercream
    OUT OF STOCK
    $37.00
  • Blueberry Lemon Curd Ice Cream Pie

    graham crust, layers of vanilla bean ice cream, our blueberry jam & house lemon curd swirled in, decorated with vanilla buttercream
    $37.00

Ice Cream Cakes

  • Sprinkle Cake IC / Choc Cake Ice Cream Cake

    chocolate cake + fudge / oreo dirt layer + sprinkle cake batter, covered in fresh house made whipped cream & decorated with vanilla buttercream
    $58.00
  • Cookie Dough IC / Van Cake Ice Cream Cake

    vanilla cake + fudge / oreo dirt layer + cookie dough ice cream, covered in fresh house made whipped cream & decorated with vanilla buttercream
    $58.00

Ice Cream

Ice Cream

  • FREAKY FLAVOR SCOOP

    $2.75
  • Sampler

    Choose 4 flavors for your sampler. Comes in a compartmentalized container to keep your flavors from touching!
    $8.25
  • Pup Cup

    $1.00
  • Apple Cider Float (12OZ)

  • 3oz cup Waffle Cone Chips

    $0.50
  • Caramel Apple Drumstick

    $8.00

To-Go Treats

  • House Drumstick With Peanuts

    classic drumstick with vanilla ice cream, chocolate dipped + peanuts, made in house
    $7.00
  • BYO Ice Cream Sammy

    Build Your Own Ice Cream Sammy!- choose a cookie option- choose a ice cream flavor (single scoop amount)- add toppings for us to roll them in!
    $7.50
  • Seasonal To-Go Sundaes

    $9.00
  • Ice Cream Sammy

    $7.00
  • Spongebob Bar

    $3.60
  • Lemon Italian Ice

    $3.60
  • Strawberry Italian Ice

    $3.60
  • Raspberry Almond IC Cake Slice

    white almond cake / raspberry jam & almonds / vanilla ice cream w/ raspberry jam swirls / house whip, more jam & chopped almonds
    $12.25
  • 24oz Reese's Blast

    Layers of vanilla & chocolate ice cream + Reese's chunks, pb drizzles & fudge drizzles
    $16.00
  • Chocolate Sprinkle IC Cake Slice

    Chocolate cake + fudge/Oreo dirt layer + chocolate sprinkle cake ice cream + fresh whip, fudge drizzles, more chocolate cake
    $12.25

Pints (2026)

  • *BOOZY* Chocolate Pint

    Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey infused chocolate ice cream
    $11.75
  • *BOOZY* Mint Pint

    whiskey and creme de menthe infused mint ice cream
    $11.50
  • *BOOZY* PB Cinnamon Whiskey

    cinnamon Jack Daniels whiskey infused peanut butter & cinnamon ice cream
    $11.95
  • *BOOZY* Raspberry Peach Dole Whip

    peach vodka infused raspberry dole whip (sorbet, dairy free/vegan)
    $11.75
  • *BOOZY* Vanilla Pint

    kahlua and seven brothers expresso vodka infused vanilla ice cream (approx. 4% - 4.5% ABV per pint)
    $11.50
  • Banana Biscoff Pint

    a roasted banana and biscoff ice cream
    $9.85
  • Banana Cream Pie Pint

    fresh banana ice cream with house brown butter, oat & vanilla wafer crumble
    $9.75
  • Butter Pecan Pint

    butter pecan ice cream + buttery toasted pecans mixed in
    $9.75
  • Cardamom Coffee Pint

    cardamom spice and coffee ice cream
    $9.75
  • Cherry Dole Whip Pint

    disney's dole whip - cherry flavored! vegan, gluten free, soy free
    $9.50
  • Chocolate M&M Brownie Pint

    chocolate ice cream + mini m&ms and chunks of our house triple chocolate brownies
    $10.00
  • Chocolate Pint

    chocolate ice cream made with Extra Brute cocoa powder, making a sinfully delicious chocolate ice cream
    $9.75
  • Cookie Dough Pint

    vanilla bean ice cream + house edible cookie dough crumbles
    $9.75
  • Cookies & Cream Pint

    vanilla ice cream + Oreo cookie chunks
    $9.75
  • Dark Chocolate Raspberry Pint

    our darkest chocolate ice cream + house raspberry jam streaks
    $10.00
  • Key Lime Pie Pint

    pure key lime juice & lime zest infused ice cream + house graham crumbles
    $9.75
  • Mint Chip Pint

    green mint ice cream + soft chocolate flakes
    $9.65
  • PB Oreo Pint

    real peanut butter ice cream + oreo chunks
    $9.75
  • PB Smores Pint

    peanut butter and graham soaked ice cream + marshmallow cream streaks & butterfinger & reeses pieces mixed in
    $10.00
  • Pineapple Dole Whip Pint

    gluten free / soy free / dairy free / vegan Pineapple Dole Whip
    $9.50
  • Pumpkin Oreo Pint

    pumpkin spice ice cream + Oreos chunks
    $9.75
  • Salted Caramel Pint

    caramel ice cream + salted caramel streaks
    $9.65
  • Strawberry Pint

    strawberry ice cream + house roasted strawberries
    $9.75
  • Vanilla Bean Pint

    classic vanilla ice cream made with pure Mexican vanilla and vanilla bean
    $9.65
  • VEGAN Apple Pint

    vegan apple compote ice cream, with cinnamon and Mexican vanilla
    $10.00
  • VEGAN Strawberries & Cream Pint

    vegan coconut cream ice cream with house strawberry jam streaks
    $9.95

Toppings To Go (8oz)

  • Caramel Topping To Go Container

    8oz of caramel sauce
    $5.00
  • Cherries To Go Container

    8oz of maraschino cherries
    $4.00
  • House Crunch Coat

    house candied peanuts & rainbow sprinkles
    $5.50
  • Homemade Jam

    8oz of our homemade jam
    $7.00
  • Hot fudge To Go Container

    8oz of hot fudge
    $5.00
  • PB Sauce To Go Container

    8oz of peanut butter sauce
    $5.50
  • Sprinkles To Go Container

    8oz of sprinkles
    $3.00
  • Strawberry Sauce (not jam!) To Go Container

    8oz of strawberry sauce
    $4.00
  • Waffle Cones (2)

    2 waffle cones, for ice cream cone making at home!
    $2.00
  • Whipped Cream Can

    Did you forget the whip? We've got you!
    $4.25
  • House Caramel

    $7.00

Bakery

COOKIE

  • 1/2 Dozen Cookies (6)

    $15.00
  • Bakers Dozen Cookies (13)

    $29.50
  • Brown Butter Cookie

    $3.00
  • Salty Choc. Chip Cookie

    $3.10
  • Peanut Butter Cookie

    $3.00
  • Chocolate Orange Cookie

    $3.05
  • Cowboy Cookie

    $3.05

BROWNIE / BAR

  • Triple Chocolate Brownie

    our fudgey chocolate brownie with milk and semi-sweet chocolate chunks
    $3.50
  • S'Moress Brownie

    $4.50

EXTRAS

  • Oatmeal Cream Pie

    $6.50
  • Sausage Cheddar Scone

    $4.25
  • Blueberry Lemon Scone

    $4.25
  • German Chocolate Cake Slice

    $6.00
  • Apple Blondie Tart

    $4.50
  • Almond Croissant Bar

    brown butter shortbread cookie on the bottom, house frangipane filling and short bread crumbles on top. Topped with sliced almonds and some powdered sugar...as close as we can get to an almond croissant!
    $4.25
  • Black Forest Cakelet

    $5.00
  • Pumpkin Coffee Cake

    $4.50
  • Maple Pecan Cream Pie

    $6.75
  • Apple Cheesecake Filled Cookie

    $5.25
  • Brown Sugar "poptart" Bar

    a shortbread base with a cinnamon/brown sugar/butter filling and topped with more shortbread - glazed with a Maple glaze
    $4.00
  • Cookies & Cream Cake Slice

    $6.00

Take & Bake Menu

  • Take&Bake Brown Butter Cookies (6)

    6 of our brown butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake! comes with parchment and directions
    $15.00
  • Take&Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (6)

    6 of our chocolate chip cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper, instructions, and enough Maldon salt for all 6
    $15.00
  • Take&Bake Peanut Butter Cookies (6)

    6 of our peanut butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper & instructions
    $15.00
  • 4 Take&Bake Scones, savory only

    Call for current flavor option! It will always be cheesey, but if you need to know specifics -- 440-898-0030
    $14.50

PB Oreo Pint

$9.75

real peanut butter ice cream + oreo chunks

1

Fairport Harbor Creamery Location and Ordering Hours

(440) 898-0030
202 High St, Fairport Harbor, OH 44077
Open now • Closes at 8:45PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement