Hayners Ice Cream, Food & Country Store 148 NY-236
Featured Items
- Regular Size
A traditional medium size (5 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$4.59 - Double Scoop
A double scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream flavor(s) served in a cone or dish!
$6.59 - Kids Size
A traditional kids size (3 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$3.59
Soft Ice Cream
**Soft Ice Cream
- Buckaroo Size
A perfect toddler size (1.5 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$2.15 - Kids Size
A traditional kids size (3 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$3.59 - Regular Size
A traditional medium size (5 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$4.59 - Large Size
A traditional large size (7 turns) cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's premium soft ice cream or Dole Soft Serve!
$5.79 - Doggie Pupparoo Vanilla$2.15
Sundaes (Soft)
- Buckaroo Size Sundae
A perfect toddler size sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$3.79 - Kids Size Sundae
A traditional kid's size sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$4.59 - Regular Size Sundae
A traditional medium size sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$5.79 - Large Size Sundae
A traditional large sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$6.79 - Brownie Lava Sundae
Our molten lava cake brownie sundae exploding with hot fudge with your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream tooped with whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$9.29 - Soft Ice Cream Banana Split
Choose up to three different flavors of Hayner's soft ice cream, up to three different toppings plus whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$8.99 - Vinny Boom Bots Sundae
A special sundae created with our endeared friend Vinny LaBarbera, a local volunteer firefighter & actor who grew up in the Bronx and loves Hayner's Ice Cream! Vinny says our soft vanilla ice cream reminds him of the famous Mr. Softee, which he enjoyed with his dad and family as a kid. Hayner's soft vanilla ice cream with strawberry, hot fudge and marshmallow toppings with whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$7.29 - Mini Vini Sundae
The mini (kids size) version of the Vinny Boom Bots Sundae.
$4.89 - Other MLB Helmet Soft Ice Cream Sundae
Hayner's Soft Ice Cream in a mini MLB helmet with your choice of topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.29 - Yankee MLB Helmet Soft Ice Cream Sundae
Hayner's Soft Ice Cream in a mini MLB helmet with your choice of topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.29 - Red Sox MLB Helmet Soft Ice Cream Sundae
Hayner's Soft Ice Cream in a mini MLB helmet with your choice of topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.29 - Mets MLB Helmet Soft Ice Cream Sundae
Hayner's Soft Ice Cream in a mini MLB helmet with your choice of topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.29
Shakes (Soft)
- Classic Large Shake (16oz)
Our traditional thick old-fashioned shakes made with Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream! .Choose Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry or Coffee
$6.49 - Classic X-Large Shake (24oz.)
Our traditional thick old-fashioned shakes made with Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream! .Choose Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry or Coffee
$7.99
Malts (Soft)
- Classic Large Malt (16oz)
Our traditional thick old-fashioned shakes made with Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream! .Choose Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry or Coffee
$6.49 - Classic X-Large Malt (24oz.)
Our traditional thick old-fashioned shakes made with Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream! .Choose Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry or Coffee
$7.99
Floats (soft)
- Classic Ice Cream Float - Large
Your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavor floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda! Or, make it a Shirley Temple with delicious cherry juice and Starry brand lemon lime soda!
$6.49 - Classic Ice Cream Float - X-Large
Your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavor floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda!
$7.99
Hard & Soft Ice Cream Combos (Soft)
- Double Play
Get creative! Enjoy your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavor and a scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served on a cone or in a dish!
$5.79 - Triple Play
Get creative! Enjoy two of your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavors and a scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served on a cone or in a dish!
$8.29 - Double Play Sundae
Get creative! Enjoy your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavor and a scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served with whip cream, nuts and a chery!
$7.29 - Triple Play Sundae
Get creative! Enjoy two of your favorite Hayner's soft ice cream flavors and a scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served with whipped cream, nuts and a cherry!
$9.29 - "518" Large Shake
The Hayner's "518" Shake is our classic large thick shake with a scoop of your favorite hard ice cream flavor floated on top with whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$6.99 - "518" X-Large Shake
The Hayner's "518" Shake is our x-large classic thick shake with a scoop of your favorite hard ice cream flavor floated on top with whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$8.49
Razzles (Soft)
- Large Razzle
Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream or Dole Soft Serve blended with your favorite candy topping folded throughout!
$7.29 - X-Large Razzle
Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream or Dole Soft Serve blended with your favorite candy topping folded throughout!
$8.99 - Large "Farmstand" Razzle
Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream or Dole Soft Serve blended with fresh fruit throughout!
$7.29 - X-Large "Farmstand" Razzle
Hayner's Premium Soft Ice Cream or Dole Soft Serve blended with fresh fruit throughout!
$8.99
Quarts
Pints
Hard Ice Cream
Scoops (Hard)
- Buckaroo Scoop
A perfect toddler size cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's Hard Ice Cream!
$2.49 - Single Scoop
A single scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served in a cone or dish!
$4.59 - Double Scoop
A double scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream flavor(s) served in a cone or dish!
$6.59 - Triple Scoop
A triple scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream flavor(s) served in a cone or dish!
$8.59 - Vanilla Pupparoo Scoop for Dog$2.49
Sundaes (Hard)
- Buckaroo Size Sundae
A perfect toddler size sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
$3.79 - Single Scoop Sundae
Single scoop of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$5.79 - Double Scoop Sundae
Two scoops of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$8.79 - Triple Scoop Sundae
Three scoops of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$10.29 - Brownie Lava Sundae
Molten lava cake brownie sundae exploding with hot fudge, an extra large scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream with peanut butter topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$11.29 - Custom 3 Scoop Banana Split
Choose any three flavors of our delicious Hayner's hard ice cream with three toppings, whip cream, nuts & a cherry!
$11.29 - Mets MLB Sundae
Single scoop Sundae in a mini baseball hemet with your favorite hard ice cream flavor and topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.99 - Redsox MLB Sundae
Single scoop Sundae in a mini baseball hemet with your favorite hard ice cream flavor and topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.99 - Yankees MLB Sundae
Single scoop Sundae in a mini baseball hemet with your favorite hard ice cream flavor and topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.99 - Other MLB Sundae
Single scoop Sundae in a mini baseball hemet with your favorite hard ice cream flavor and topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
$6.99
Shakes & Malts (Hard)
- Custom Large Shake (16oz.)
Our custom thick milk shake made with 2 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
$7.79 - Custom X-Large Shake (24oz.)
Our custom thick milk shake made with 3 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
$9.59 - Custom Large Malt (16oz.)
Our custom thick milk shake made with 2 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
$7.79 - Custom X-Large Malt (24oz.)
Our custom thick milk shake made with 3 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
$9.59
Ice Cream Floats (Hard)
Quarts
Desserts & More (Order & pick up next day)
10" Fruit Pies (Order & pick up next day)
- 10" Apple Caramel Walnut Pie$18.95
- 10" Apple Pie$16.95
- 10" Blueberry Crisp Pie$17.95
- 10" Blueberry Pie$19.95
- 10" Caramel Apple Pie$17.95OUT OF STOCK
- 10" Cherry Pie$18.95
- 10" Dutch Apple Crisp Pie$16.95
- 10" Fruits of the Forest Pie$18.95
- 10" Peach Praline Pie$17.95
- 10" Pumpkin Pie$16.95OUT OF STOCK
- 10" Raspberry Pie$19.95
- 10" Southern Pecan Pie$21.95
- 10" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie$18.95
9" Ice Cream Pies (Order & pick up next day)
- 6 Pack Ice Cream Sandwiches$10.50
- 9" Cappuccino Cookies & Cream Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Caramel Fudge Ice Cream Pie$17.95OUT OF STOCK
- 9" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup & Snickers Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup & Snickers Ice Cream Pie$19.95
- 9” Coconut Chocolate Almond Dream Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Cookie Monster Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$26.95
- 9" Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Death by Chocolate Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$26.95
- 9" Midnight Caramel River Ride Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9” Milk & Cookies Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Strawberries & Cream Ice Cream Pie$17.95
- 9” Strawberries & Cream Deluxe Ice cream Pie$24.95
- 9” Strawberry Cheesecake Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Trash Can Ice Cream Pie$19.95
- 9” Trash Can Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$26.95OUT OF STOCK
- 9” Vinny Boom Bots Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$25.95
- Chocolate Cherry Chunk Ice Cream Pie (Special order ahead)
Chocolate Cherry Chunk Ice Cream Pie
$25.95
Cookies & Apple Dumplings (Order & pick up next day)
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Acai Bowls & Smoothies
Acai Bowls
- Power Acai Bowl
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, STRAWBERRIES & BANANA BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH SLICED STRAWBERRIES, CHIA SEEDS, RAW PEANUT BUTTER & LOCAL HONEY.
$11.99 - Haynerietta Acai Bowl
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, BANANA & PEANUT BUTTER BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED CHOCOLATE ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH SLICED STRAWBERRIES, BANANA, ALMOND SLIVERS AND LOCAL HONEY.
$11.99 - Tropical Acai Bowl
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, MANGO, PINEAPPLE, STRAWBERRIES & BANANA BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CHIA SEEDS & RAW COCONUT.
$11.99 - Very Berry Acai Bowl
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, BLUEBERRIES, RASPBERRIES, STRAWBERRIES, BLACKBERRIES & BANANAS BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH STRAWBERRIES, FRESH BLUEBERRIES & CHIA SEEDS.
$11.99
Real Fruit Smoothies
- 16oz. Paradise Smoothie
Mango, Pineapple, Bananas & Strawberries blended with Dole Flavor Soft Serve flavor of the day and a Mango base.
$7.29 - 16 oz. Sunrise Smoothie
Peanut Butter, bananas, gluten free granola & honey blended with low fat vanilla frozen yogurt & unsweetened vanilla almond milk base.
$7.29 - 16 oz. Harvest Moon Smoothie
Raspberries, blueberries, strawberries & blackberries blended with low fat frozen vanilla yogurt and a very berry base.
$7.29 - 16 oz. Sunset Smoothie
Strawberries & Bananas blended with low fat frozen vanilla yogurt and a strawberry banana base.
$7.29