Lefty's Bagels
Featured Items
- Bagel & Schmear$3.45
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily topped with schmear of your choice. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
- Dozen Bagels$17.95
A dozen (12) of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese$7.95
Freshly baked bagel with applewood smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese
Bagels
- A Bagel$1.95
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
- Bagel & Schmear$3.45
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily topped with schmear of your choice. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
- Half Dozen Bagels$9.95
Six of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
- Dozen Bagels$17.95
A dozen (12) of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
- Bialy$1.95
Unlike a bagel, it does not have a hole in the middle, but a depression and is only baked. Filled with classic sauteed onion.
Breakfast
Egg Sandwiches
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese$7.95
Freshly baked bagel with applewood smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese
- The Classic Egg Sammy$5.49
Freshly baked bagel with farm fresh locally raised egg
- Sausage Egg and Cheese$7.95
Freshly baked bagel with sauage patty, egg, and cheese.
- Ham Egg and Cheese$7.95
Freshly baked bagel with black forest ham, scrambled egg, and cheese.
- The Uncle L.E.O.$13.75
Bagel with nova lox, farm fresh egg, and sautéed onion
- I WANT IT ALL$12.75
Your choice of corned beef or pastrami, farm fresh egg, potato latke, and sautéed onion on a fresh bagel
- The Mid-Western$10.95
Western style bagel sandwich, eggs, choice of meat, bell peppers, jack cheese, onions, and fresh pico de gallo.
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
- Lox o' Love$14.95
Freshly baked bagel with Nova Lox and plain cream cheese
- Pastrami Lox$14.95
Freshly baked bagel with Pastrami Smoked Salmon and plain cream cheese
- Whitefish$13.95
Freshly baked bagel with whole Smoked Whitefish and Plain Cream Cheese
- Kippered Salmon$14.95
Our kippered (baked salmon) is made from our fattiest, richest salmon. It’s hot smoked to perfection.
- Sable$16.95
Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Sable and Plain Cream Cheese
- Trout$13.95
Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Trout and Plain Cream Cheese
- Cold Smoked Tuna Loin$14.95
Delicate in taste and beautiful in colour. Served on bagel with schmear.
Breakfast Sides
- Potato Latke$2.95
Shredded potatoes and grated onions bound with flour and eggs, then fried until crispy outside and tender inside
- Bacon Side$2.95
Locally Cured Applewood Smoked Thick Cut Bacon
- Sausage Patty Side$2.95
Maple sausage formed into handmade patties
- Black Forest Ham Side$2.95
Thinly sliced and roasted to perfection
- Beef Salami Side$2.95
100% all Beef Salami
Lunch
Deli Classics
- Pastrami$14.95
Hot pastrami brisket handcrafted and trimmed from premium cuts and cured with a proprietary spice blend, then smoked over natural hardwood. Our pastrami is flavorful but never overbearing.
- Corned Beef$14.95
Hot New York style corned beef with a strong flavor profile, no mild cure here! A classic corned beef with an unforgettable garlic flavor.
- Roast Beef$12.95
New York top round roast beef slow roasted at extremely low temperatures to maintain integrity and keep natural juices intact. The result is a roast beef that is never dry, red throughout with a natural flavor, taste, and texture.
- Oven Roasted Turkey$14.95
- Hardwood Smoked Turkey$14.95
- Turkey Pastrami$14.95
- Beef Salami$11.95
- Black Forest Ham$11.95
Signature Sandwiches
- The New York, New York$15.95
Freshly baked bagel with hot corned beef, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
- King of the Hill$15.95
Freshly baked bagel with roast beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, horseradish cheese or provolone
- BLT$10.95Out of stock
You know - Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, on a freshly baked bagel
- Cousin Rubin$15.95
Freshly baked bagel with hot pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
- The Grand Salami$12.95
Freshly baked bagel with beef salami, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
- Miami Sammy$13.95
Freshly baked bagel with ham, pickles, Swiss cheese, and mayonnaise
- Turkey Club Med$15.95
Freshly baked bagel with turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, Provolone cheese and mayonnaise
- West Coast Avocado$9.95
Fresh avocado, diced tomato, lemon, salt & pepper on a fresh bagel
- Cucumber Dill$6.95Out of stock
Sliced cucumber and dill cream cheese on a bagel of your choice
Salads/Soups/Sides
Deli Salad Sandwiches
- Tuna Salad Sandwich$8.75Out of stock
Home-made tuna salad with tomato and lettuce on freshly baked bagel
- Lefty's Whitefish Salad Sandwich$10.25
Home-made whitefish salad using chunks of smoked whitefish with lettuce and tomato on freshly baked bagel
- Egg Salad Sandwich$7.25Out of stock
Home-made using farm fresh eggs with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel
- Chicken Salad Sandwich$9.25Out of stock
Home-made chicken salad with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel
Deli Sides
Pastries & Treats
Beverages
Hot Drinks
Cold Drinks
- Fountain Soda$2.85
Serving Coca-Cola Products
- Iced Tea$2.85
Iced Classic Black Tea from Firepot Tea (16oz) - Notes of dried cherry and malt.
- Cold Brew Coffee$5.15Out of stock
Haya Cold Brew from Kaldis. Flavor notes of caramel, chocolate, and citrus
- Dr. Browns$2.95
Classic New York Deli Soda
- Milk$3.35
- Chocolate Milk$3.35
- Apple Juice$3.75
A perfect complement to lunch on the road, Martinelli's 10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.
- Orange Juice$3.75
Natalies Orange Juice
- Smart Water$2.89
Deli To Go
Schmear
- Plain Schmear$4.49
8oz container of plain cream cheese
- Garlic & Herb Schmear$4.49
8oz container of garlic and herb cream cheese
- Veggie Schmear$4.49
8oz container of veggie cream cheese
- Nova Lox Schmear$5.49Out of stock
8oz container of nova lox cream cheese
- Scallion Schmear$4.49
8oz container of scallion cream cheese
- Jalapeño Schmear$4.49
8oz container of jalapeño cream cheese
- Strawberry Schmear$4.49Out of stock
8oz container of strawberry cream cheese
- Blueberry Schmear$4.49Out of stock
8oz container of blueberry cream cheese
- Whipped Butter$3.49
- Side of Schmear (2oz)$1.25
- Garlic Hummus Schmear$4.49
Smoked Fish
- Nova Cured Smoked Salmon$10.99+
Brined to perfection, our velvety, lightly smoked New York nova is always a star. 4oz or 8oz pre-packaged
- Pastrami Lox$10.99+
Fresh salmon, salt, sugar and a smoldering fire is all we use to make all of our cold smoked salmon. 4oz or 8oz pre-packaged
- Smoked Whitefish$19.99
Our buttery whitefish hails from the great lakes. Whole or by the pound
- Smoked Sable$41.99
Our Sable is caught in the icy waters off of Alaska. Buttery, rich and a must on any appetizing platter. Available by the pound
- Kippered (baked) Salmon$39.99
Our kippered (baked salmon) is made from our fattiest, richest salmon. It’s hot smoked to perfection. Perfect for a bagel or a salad.
- Cold Smoked Tuna Loin$21.99
Brined in salt/sugar solution then cold smoked. Delicate in taste and beautiful in colour
Kippered (baked) Salmon
Our kippered (baked salmon) is made from our fattiest, richest salmon. It’s hot smoked to perfection. Perfect for a bagel or a salad.