Lefty's Bagels
Featured Items
- Bagel & Schmear
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily topped with schmear of your choice. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
$3.45 - Dozen Bagels
A dozen (12) of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
$17.95 - Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Freshly baked bagel with applewood smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese
$7.95
Bagels
- A Bagel
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
$1.95 - Bagel & Schmear
One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily topped with schmear of your choice. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!
$3.45 - Half Dozen Bagels
Six of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
$9.95 - Dozen Bagels
A dozen (12) of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!
$17.95 - Bialy
Unlike a bagel, it does not have a hole in the middle, but a depression and is only baked. Filled with classic sauteed onion.
$1.95
Breakfast
Egg Sandwiches
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Freshly baked bagel with applewood smoked bacon, and cheddar cheese
$7.95 - The Classic Egg Sammy
Freshly baked bagel with farm fresh locally raised egg
$5.49 - Sausage Egg and Cheese
Freshly baked bagel with sauage patty, egg, and cheese.
$7.95 - Ham Egg and Cheese
Freshly baked bagel with black forest ham, scrambled egg, and cheese.
$7.95 - The Uncle L.E.O.
Bagel with nova lox, farm fresh egg, and sautéed onion
$13.75 - I WANT IT ALL
Your choice of corned beef or pastrami, farm fresh egg, potato latke, and sautéed onion on a fresh bagel
$12.75 - The Mid-Western
Western style bagel sandwich, eggs, choice of meat, bell peppers, jack cheese, onions, and fresh pico de gallo.
$10.95
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
- Lox o' Love
Freshly baked bagel with Nova Lox and plain cream cheese
$14.95 - Pastrami Lox
Freshly baked bagel with Pastrami Smoked Salmon and plain cream cheese
$14.95 - Whitefish
Freshly baked bagel with whole Smoked Whitefish and Plain Cream Cheese
$13.95 - Kippered Salmon
Our kippered (baked salmon) is made from our fattiest, richest salmon. It’s hot smoked to perfection.
$14.95 - Sable
Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Sable and Plain Cream Cheese
$16.95 - Trout
Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Trout and Plain Cream Cheese
$13.95 - Cold Smoked Tuna Loin
Delicate in taste and beautiful in colour. Served on bagel with schmear.
$14.95
Breakfast Sides
- Potato Latke
Shredded potatoes and grated onions bound with flour and eggs, then fried until crispy outside and tender inside
$2.95 - Bacon Side
Locally Cured Applewood Smoked Thick Cut Bacon
$2.95 - Sausage Patty Side
Maple sausage formed into handmade patties
$2.95 - Black Forest Ham Side
Thinly sliced and roasted to perfection
$2.95 - Beef Salami Side
100% all Beef Salami
$2.95
Potato Latke
Shredded potatoes and grated onions bound with flour and eggs, then fried until crispy outside and tender inside
Lunch
Deli Classics
- Pastrami
Hot pastrami brisket handcrafted and trimmed from premium cuts and cured with a proprietary spice blend, then smoked over natural hardwood. Our pastrami is flavorful but never overbearing.
$14.95 - Corned Beef
Hot New York style corned beef with a strong flavor profile, no mild cure here! A classic corned beef with an unforgettable garlic flavor.
$14.95 - Roast Beef
New York top round roast beef slow roasted at extremely low temperatures to maintain integrity and keep natural juices intact. The result is a roast beef that is never dry, red throughout with a natural flavor, taste, and texture.
$12.95 - Oven Roasted Turkey$14.95
- Hardwood Smoked Turkey$14.95
- Turkey Pastrami$14.95
- Beef Salami$11.95
- Black Forest Ham$11.95
Signature Sandwiches
- The New York, New York
Freshly baked bagel with hot corned beef, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
$15.95 - King of the Hill
Freshly baked bagel with roast beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, horseradish cheese or provolone
$15.95 - BLT
You know - Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, on a freshly baked bagel
$10.95 - Cousin Rubin
Freshly baked bagel with hot pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
$15.95 - The Grand Salami
Freshly baked bagel with beef salami, Swiss cheese and deli mustard
$12.95 - Miami Sammy
Freshly baked bagel with ham, pickles, Swiss cheese, and mayonnaise
$13.95 - Turkey Club Med
Freshly baked bagel with turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, Provolone cheese and mayonnaise
$15.95 - West Coast Avocado
Fresh avocado, diced tomato, lemon, salt & pepper on a fresh bagel
$9.95 - OUT OF STOCKCucumber Dill
Sliced cucumber and dill cream cheese on a bagel of your choice
OUT OF STOCK$6.95
Salads/Soups/Sides
Deli Salad Sandwiches
- OUT OF STOCKTuna Salad Sandwich
Home-made tuna salad with tomato and lettuce on freshly baked bagel
OUT OF STOCK$8.75 - OUT OF STOCKLefty's Whitefish Salad Sandwich
Home-made whitefish salad using chunks of smoked whitefish with lettuce and tomato on freshly baked bagel
OUT OF STOCK$10.25 - OUT OF STOCKEgg Salad Sandwich
Home-made using farm fresh eggs with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel
OUT OF STOCK$7.25 - OUT OF STOCKChicken Salad Sandwich
Home-made chicken salad with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel
OUT OF STOCK$9.25
Deli Sides
Soups
Pastries & Treats
Beverages
Hot Drinks
Cold Drinks
- Fountain Soda
Serving Coca-Cola Products
$2.85 - Iced Tea
Iced Classic Black Tea from Firepot Tea (16oz) - Notes of dried cherry and malt.
$2.85 - OUT OF STOCKCold Brew Coffee
Haya Cold Brew from Kaldis. Flavor notes of caramel, chocolate, and citrus
OUT OF STOCK$5.15 - Dr. Browns
Classic New York Deli Soda
$2.95 - Milk$3.35
- Chocolate Milk$3.35
- Apple Juice
A perfect complement to lunch on the road, Martinelli's 10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.
$3.75 - Orange Juice
Natalies Orange Juice
$3.75 - Smart Water$2.89
Deli To Go
Schmear
- OUT OF STOCKPlain Schmear
8oz container of plain cream cheese
OUT OF STOCK$4.49 - Garlic & Herb Schmear
8oz container of garlic and herb cream cheese
$4.49 - Veggie Schmear
8oz container of veggie cream cheese
$4.49 - Nova Lox Schmear
8oz container of nova lox cream cheese
$5.49 - Scallion Schmear
8oz container of scallion cream cheese
$4.49 - Jalapeño Schmear
8oz container of jalapeño cream cheese
$4.49 - Strawberry Schmear
8oz container of strawberry cream cheese
$4.49 - Blueberry Schmear
8oz container of blueberry cream cheese
$4.49 - Whipped Butter$3.49
- Side of Schmear (2oz)$1.25
- Garlic Hummus Schmear$4.49
Smoked Fish
- Nova Cured Smoked Salmon
Brined to perfection, our velvety, lightly smoked New York nova is always a star. 4oz or 8oz pre-packaged
$10.99+ - Pastrami Lox
Fresh salmon, salt, sugar and a smoldering fire is all we use to make all of our cold smoked salmon. 4oz or 8oz pre-packaged
$10.99+ - Smoked Whitefish
Our buttery whitefish hails from the great lakes. Whole or by the pound
$19.99 - Smoked Sable
Our Sable is caught in the icy waters off of Alaska. Buttery, rich and a must on any appetizing platter. Available by the pound
$41.99 - Kippered (baked) Salmon
Our kippered (baked salmon) is made from our fattiest, richest salmon. It’s hot smoked to perfection. Perfect for a bagel or a salad.
$39.99 - Cold Smoked Tuna Loin
Brined in salt/sugar solution then cold smoked. Delicate in taste and beautiful in colour
$21.99