New Online Ordering system is live! Browse Our Menu!

Mama Said Hand Pies Press Bay Alley
118 West Green Street, Ithaca, NY
Pickup Only
Featured Items
West African Meat Pie 1
Local ground beef from Windsong Farm, bell pepper, carrots, potatoes, chicken broth, habanero pepper and spices. Served in our house-made short crust. These pies come with our version of Sosu Kaani, a Senegali-style hot sauce.Cheesecake Brownie
$5.75Blueberry Pie 1
A special blend of wild and cultivated blueberries with a hint of cinnamon & nutmeg and organic sugar in a butter crust and a delicious lemon glaze.
Savory
Tempeh Patty 1
Based loosely on our Jamaican Beef Patty, this pie highlights well-seasoned tempeh with sofrito, house curry blends, coconut milk and scotch bonnet peppers.Vegan Pepper Jack Empanada 1
GF/DF Irish Knish 1
OUT OF STOCKGF Mushroom and Oaxaca Cheese 1
Crimini mushrooms, roasted with onions, local & organic cilantro, scallions, and garlic. Served with housemade salsa verde, using local and organic tomatillos, cilantro, and hot peppers. Wrapped in our gluten free butter crust.OUT OF STOCKGF Pepper Jack Beef Empanada 1
OUT OF STOCKMushroom Oaxaca Cheese 1
Crimini mushrooms, roasted with onions, local & organic cilantro, scallions, and garlic. Served with housemade salsa verde, using local and organic tomatillos, cilantro, and hot peppers. Wrapped in our standard butter crust.OUT OF STOCKPoblano con Queso 1
Poblano peppers, roasted and mixed with manchego cheese, queso fresco, cream cheese and fresh garlic. Served with our homemade salsa.Potato & NYS Cheddar 1
Our best-selling pie includes buttery mashed potatoes with a N.Y.S. 3-year aged Welsh-style Cheddar (from Jake's Cheese Company in Deansboro, NY), English mustard and 'sneaky' onions. Served in our standard short crust.OUT OF STOCKSpanakopita 1
Delightful and refreshing combination of spinach, dill, feta, bechamel, scallion, lemon, garlic all wrapped in a purse of our short crust.Spinach, Egg & Pepper Jack Cheese 1
Pepper Jack Beef Empanada 1
An empanada with local ground beef, carrot, corn, jalapeno, onion, garlic, house made chipotle orange salsa, Cabot Pepper Jack Cheese.OUT OF STOCKSausage Gravy, Scrambled Egg, Cheddar 1
Swiss Pantry Pie 1
Local bacon that we marinate with black pepper, juniper berry and other spices, that we then saute with apple, leek, potato, raclette and Jarlsberg cheeses, brown sugar.OUT OF STOCKSauce 1
$0.75Irish Knish 1
This vegan Irish potato pie is based on the Colcannon, (mashed potatoes hash with onions and greens) but is made using substitutions of vegan based cheese and vegan butter in tandem with caramelized onions, and kale. We make a vegan short crust for this pie. In the end, it tastes like a knish, the Jewish potato pastry. Contains soy, coconut, cocoa butter, sesame and sunflower.OUT OF STOCKVegan Mushroom & "Cheese" 1
Crimini mushrooms, Daiya vegan cheese, roasted with onions, local & organic cilantro, scallions, and garlic. Served with housemade salsa verde, using local and organic tomatillos, cilantro, and hot peppers. Wrapped in our vegan crust.OUT OF STOCKVegan Spanakopita 1
OUT OF STOCKGF Poblano con Queso 1
Poblano peppers, roasted and mixed with manchego cheese, queso fresco, cream cheese and fresh garlic. Served with our homemade salsa.OUT OF STOCKGF Potato Cheddar 1
Our best-selling pie includes buttery mashed potatoes with a N.Y.S. 3-year aged Welsh-style Cheddar (from Jake's Cheese Company in Deansboro, NY), English mustard and 'sneaky' onions. Served in our gluten free short crust.OUT OF STOCKChorizo and Peppers 1
Japanese Beef Curry 1
OUT OF STOCKWest African Meat Pie 1
Local ground beef from Windsong Farm, bell pepper, carrots, potatoes, chicken broth, habanero pepper and spices. Served in our house-made short crust. These pies come with our version of Sosu Kaani, a Senegali-style hot sauce.
Sweet
Cherry Pie 1
NYS tart cherries & organic sugar in our all butter crust topped with almond flavored (but naturally nut free!) glaze.Blueberry Pie 1
A special blend of wild and cultivated blueberries with a hint of cinnamon & nutmeg and organic sugar in a butter crust and a delicious lemon glaze.Peach Pie 1
OUT OF STOCKIrish Apple Pie 1
Local apples, sweetened and spiced, served in our shortbread crust.OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Sour Cream Coffee Cake 1
OUT OF STOCK$4.50Vegan Jam Tarts 1
OUT OF STOCK$5.95Chocolate Chip Cookie 1
OUT OF STOCK$2.70Polka Dot Cookie 1
$2.50Ricciarelli 1
OUT OF STOCK$2.00Chocolate Ricciarelli 1
OUT OF STOCK$2.25GF/DF Cherry Pie 1
NYS tart cherries & organic sugar in our gluten free, dairy free crust topped with almond glaze.OUT OF STOCKGF/DF Blueberry Pie 1
A special blend of wild and cultivated blueberries with a hint of cinnamon & nutmeg and organic sugar in a gluten free crust topped with our delicious lemon glaze.OUT OF STOCKLemon&Strawberry Moon Cookie 1
OUT OF STOCK$4.25Whoopie Pie 1
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Guava con Queso Pastelitos 1
OUT OF STOCK$3.50Chocolate Frangipane Puff Pastry 1
OUT OF STOCK$6.25Cheesecake Brownie
$5.75Brioche Apple Roll with Vanilla Cardamom Glaze
$6.50Pumpkin Scone
$5.75
Drinks
Bruce Cost Ginger Ale Original 1
This delicious, sparkling and rich unfiltered soda is made with whole ginger (long enjoyed for digestive comfort) and pure cane sugar & all our flavors start with this deliciously simple formula.$3.00Passion Fruit with Turmeric Ginger Ale 1
Bruce Cost's passion fruit flavor blends the distinct tropical tang of passion fruit and the historically treasured medicinal [and ginger’s cousin] turmeric with our original ginger ale giving it a beautiful, bold yellow color with an array of health benefits.$3.00Blood Orange & Meyer Lemon Ginger Ale1
This Bruce Cost ginger ale features a sweet citrus explosion with a slight and welcome bitterness combined the essences of Blood Oranges and Meyer Lemons with fresh ginger undertones.$3.00Pomegranate Hibiscus Ginger Ale 1
$3.00Spindrift 1
$2.50Harney&Sons Watermelon 1
$3.15Harney&Sons Pineapple 1
$3.15Just Water 1
$2.65
Polka Dot Cookie 1
$2.50
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1