
Mythical Pizza 1855 Valley Road, #200
1855 Valley Road, #200, Berkeley Springs, WV
Featured Items

Daddy Bigfoot - 14" Custom Pizza (8-Cut)
Enjoy your pizza exactly the way you want it! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edges and finishes!$15.00
Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni$15.00
Mozzarella Monster (Standard Cheese Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella$15.00
The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt
The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt Head-to-Head Showdown!
Each week, our bracket of customer creations will go head-to-head! Purchase your favorite pies, cast your votes, and help crown the most LEGENDARY pizza of them all!

Mothman's Mac Attack by Peyton McCoy
alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, pulled pork, bacon, mac and cheese; after bake: crispy fried onions, ranch drizzle$18.50
Jersey Devil Italian Stallion by Beth Smith
garlic oil, sasquatch seasoning, mozzarella, provolone, ham, salami, pepperoni, cherry tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers after bake: arcadian lettuce and Italian dressing drizzle$18.50
Build Your Own Pizza Pie & Salads
You know what you're craving! Grab your favorite pizza or salad and top it exactly the way you want!

Daddy Bigfoot - 14" Custom Pizza (8-Cut)
Enjoy your pizza exactly the way you want it! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edges and finishes!$15.00
Lil' Mothman - 10" Custom Pizza (4-Cut)
A smaller, personalized version of your favorite pizza! Enjoy a 7" pizza fully customized for you!$10.00
Baby Squonk - 5" Custom Pizza (2-Cut)
Enjoy a 5" personal mini pizza, fully customized for your taste! A great option for picky and small eaters.$6.00
Flatwoods Foldover - 14" Calzone Pizza
Half-Pizza, Half-Calzone! Pick your toppings of a normal pizza on one side, and a filled calzone on the other.$19.00
Grafton Monster - 10" DEEP DISH Pizza
Legendary 10" DEEP DISH pizza is full of cheese & toppings, covered in marinara and Parmesan cheese!$22.00
9" Pizza BOWL (KETO Friendly)
Load up with out the carbs! Choose your sauces, cheese, proteins and veggies for an out-of-this-world meal!$10.00
10" Fattyhead KETO Pizza (KETO Friendly)
Made with mozzarella, cream cheese, eggs and almond flour. This KETO friendly crust is only 6g net carbs per crust!$19.00
10" Cauliflower Crust Pizza (Gluten-Friendly)
Our gluten-friendly cauliflower crust has an incredible punch of flavor!$18.00
7" French-Bread Loaf Pizza
You've BEGGED us, so now it's your time! Enjoy a 7" French Hoagie open faced and made YOUR WAY!$10.00
Drizzled Calzone
Calzone with Mozzarella, Ricotta, your choice of meats & veggies, baked golden and drizzled your way.$14.75+
Stuffed Stromboli
Stromboli with marinara, cheese, your choice of meats & veggies. Served with a dipper.$15.75
The Flight of the SQUONKS
A flight of three 5" Baby Squonk pizzas of our Signature Pies! Special requests to remove toppings, no substitutions.$19.75
Mama Nessie's Family Salad
Our Arcadian lettuce blend is your base for this gigantic salad, custom made to your appetite! Served with 2 packets of dressing. If additional is needed, please order under ‘Salad Dressings’ menu.$14.25
Baby Nessie's Personal Salad
Our Arcadian lettuce blend is your base for this personal size salad, custom made for you with the toppings you crave! Served with 1 packet of dressing. If additional is needed, please order under ‘Salad Dressings’ menu.$9.25
Signature Pies
Our Signature Pies are our crew and customer favorite combinations! Try one today, or customize your own to your liking!

Mozzarella Monster (Standard Cheese Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella$15.00
Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni$15.00
Stand By Meat (Mothman's Fav - Meat Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham$17.00
Alabama White THANG
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, cherry tomatoes, chopped basil (after bake: sasquatch seasoning and sea salt)$21.00
Alfredo vs. Predator (AVP)
alfredo, mozzarella, smoked turkey burnt ends, green peppers, corn, jalapeño peppers (after bake: barbecue drizzle)$18.00
Attack of the 50' Meatball
marinara, mozzrella, romano cheese meatballs, banana peppers, fire roasted red peppers, chopped basil$21.00
Balsamic S.T.R.I.P.E.S.
marinara, mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, diced tomatoes (after bake: fresh spinach and balsamic glaze)$18.00
Big Trouble in Hot Chicken
nashville hot, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, red onions, fire roasted red peppers, dill pickles (after bake: ranch drizzle)$20.00
The Blair Squatch Project
canadian spice, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, smoked turkey burnt ends, bacon, red onion, green pepper w/ smoked turkey burnt ends & barbecue stuffed crust and cryptid-craving home-fry edge (after bake: barbecue drizzle)$30.00
Close Encounters (Of The Veggie Kind)
alfredo, mozzarella, diced tomatoes, green peppers, marinated mushrooms, red onions, chopped basil, garlic roasted brussels sprouts (after bake: basil pesto sprinkle)$20.00
Dude, Where's My Pesto!?
basil pesto, ricotta, fresh mushrooms, fire roasted red peppers, chopped garlic (after bake: honey sriracha drizzle)$22.00
E.T. The Extra-Toppings Supreme
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham, marinated mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives$17.00
Flatwood Bueller's Day Off
marinara, mozzarella, diced ham, pineapple, jalapeño peppers$19.00
The Great Pretzel Escape
garlic oil, cheddar, sausage, jalapeños, red onion on pretzel style salt & garlic edge, served w/ nacho cheese dipper$18.00
The Karate Cryptid
teriyaki, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, pineapple, green peppers$19.00
A Krampus Story
garlic oil, mozzarella, ricotta, steak, green peppers, red onions, marinated mushrooms, sasquatch seasoning$19.00
A Nightmare on Braxie Street
alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar, ricotta, bacon, chicken (after bake: fresh spinach & honey sriracha drizzle)$22.00
No Country For Mild Cryptids
mango habanero, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, buffalo tossed breaded chicken, bacon, pineapple, red onions, jalapeño (after bake: ranch drizzle)$22.00
Pastanormal Activity
alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar, penne pasta, chicken, bacon, smoked turkey burnt ends (after bake: barbecue drizzle)$22.00
POULTRYGEIST
buffalo, cheddar, chicken, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers (after bake: ranch drizzle)$18.00
QUADZILLA - King of Pepperoni
marinara, full-coverage pepperoni (after bake: mike’s hot honey drizzle & red pepper flakes)$21.50
The Princess Brine
garlic oil, mozzarella, dill pickles, bacon (after bake: ranch drizzle)$18.00
Raiders of the Lost Sauce
traditional tomato pie: marinara, chopped basil, sprinkled with parmesan cheese$17.00
The TURKINATOR
sweet chili, cheddar, smoked turkey burnt ends, red onions (after bake: fresh spinach, buffalo drizzle)$18.00
Smokey and the Bigfoot
barbecue, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, bacon, green peppers, corn (after bake: barbecue drizzle)$20.00
Sprout-Man and the Masters of the Pizzeria
garlic oil, mozzarella, bacon, feta, red onions, garlic roasted brussels sprouts (after bake: balsamic glaze)$22.00
Uncle Beak
ranch, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, red onion (after bake: fresh spinach, ranch drizzle)$20.00
Breakers (Subs)
Breakers | Break the Rules
Not a sandwich. Not a pizza. Break the rules.
Kraken's Noodles (Pasta)
Penne Pasta Bowls
Unleash bold flavors with our new Kraken Noodle Bowls! All pasta bowls start with garlic oil and penne pasta!

Build Your Own Kraken's Noodles
Build your own Kraken’s Noodles with your choice of sauces, cheeses, meats, and veggies!$8.00+
Beast of Busco Bowl
marinara, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, green peppers$10.00+
Mothman's Mushroom Bowl
basil pesto, mozzarella, sausage, marinated mushrooms, cherry tomatoes$10.00+
Jersey Devil Fury Bowl
buffalo, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, jalapeno peppers$10.00+
Ozark Howler Bowl
garlic parmesan, mozzarella, cheddar, ricotta, smoked burnt turkey ends$12.00+
The Red-Eyed INFERNO Bowl
nashville hot, cheddar, chicken, red onions, banana peppers and finished with mike's hot honey$12.50+
Braxie's Meatball Bowl
marinara, mozzarella, romano cheese meatballs$10.00+
Enter The Mothman Bowl
teriyaki, mozzarella, chicken, pineapple, green peppers$12.00+
Mango-Man Prophecies Bowl
mango habanero, mozzarella, diced chicken, roasted red peppers, corn$12.00+
Honey, I Spiced The Cryptids Bowl
canadian spice, cheddar-jack, bacon, breaded chicken, red onion$12.00+
BIG(FOOT) Starters & Wings
Batsquatch Wings
That's right....WINGS! Our BATSQUATCH Wings are baked to perfection in your favorite Mythical Pizza sauces!

BATSQUATCH Wings (10 Wings)
10 Bone-In or Boneless Wings, tossed in your choice of sauce!$12.50
BATSQUATCH Jumbo Pack (30 Wings)
30 Bone-In or Boneless Wings, split into 3 flavors of 10, tossed in your favorite sauces.$30.00
The Cryptid Club PARTY PACK (50 Wings)
two sets of 25 wings each with two 4oz dippers bone-in or boneless together in a large box naked or finished in any of our sauce options$48.00
BIG(FOOT) Breads
From tasty rolls to bubbly cheesy garlic breadsticks, we have your cravings covered!

Garlic Bread [No Cheese]
garlic oil, chopped garlic, sasquatch seasoning$8.00+
Cheesy Garlic Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, sasquatch seasoning$9.00+
Cheesesteak Garlic Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, cheddar, steak, green pepper, red onion, sasquatch seasoning$11.00+
Mothman's Spicy Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, pepperoni, red pepper flakes$10.00+
Feta-n-Pesto Folded Bread
pesto, feta, mozzarella w. garlic oil drizzle$7.00
Jalapeño-n-Cheese Folded Bread
alfredo, mozzarella, jalapeños w. honey sriracha drizzle$7.00
Buffalo-n-Bleu Folded Bread
buffalo, mozzarella, bleu cheese w. buffalo drizzle$7.00
Tomato-n-Balsamic Folded Bread
chopped garlic, mozzarella, diced tomato w. balsamic glaze$7.00
Cryptid Rolls
Paranormal Pretzels
house dough prepped into three dippable sticks, coated with a garlic butter and coarse sea salt, served w/ mucho queso
Drinks
Drinks
Enjoy ice-cold Pepsi products or dive into new flavors with our Mythical Test Kitchen drinks!

20oz LIFEWTR
LIFEWTR premium bottled water, pH balanced with electrolytes for taste.$3.00
Juice Box
Apple Juice with no added sugar and 100% daily vitamin C.$1.50
Alani Cherry Slush
Tastes like a chilled cherry slushie with a rush of retro sweetness!$3.75
Alani Sherbet Swirl
A sweet swirl of raspberry, orange and lime sherbet.$3.75
Alani Breezeberry
Tart blue raspberries sprinkled with a sweet citrus frost.$3.75
2 Liter Pepsi
Pepsi-Cola, the bold, refreshing cola.$4.75
2 Liter Pepsi Zero
Pepsi Zero Sugar is here—bold, refreshing, zero calories, and full of flavor!$4.75
2 Liter Mug Root Beer
Mug’s creamy vanilla and spiced sweetness enjoyed for over 65 years.$4.75
2 Liter Schweppes Ginger Ale
Bold, crisp, and bubbly ginger ale—perfectly refreshing.$4.75
Cryptid Club Sodas
Quench your thirst with Mythical Pizza's exclusive Cryptid Club Sodas—crafted with real cane sugar and legendary flavor!

Squonk Tears Club Soda
Crisp, fizzy club soda, perfect on its own or as a mixer.$3.75
Chupacabra Black Cherry Soda
Bold black cherry soda that sinks its flavor fangs into your taste buds.OUT OF STOCK$3.75
Cryptid Cola
The fan-favorite, limited edition, and legendary refreshment is back!$3.75
Hodag Orange Creamsicle Crush
A frosty burst of orange and creamy vanilla for a legendary sip!$3.75
Mothman's West Virginia SCREAM SODA (Cream Soda)
Made with the finest vanilla for the ultimate cream soda!$3.75
SQUONK (Raspberry Lime Rickey Soda)
A refreshing twist on raspberry-lime rickey—sparkling raspberry limeade!$3.75
Perilous Pineapple
Our sweet tropical pineapple soda is made with real pineapple!$3.75
Grafton Monster Groovy Grape Soda
This provides a bold, fruity grape flavor. A fan favorite!$3.75
Bigfoot Brew Birch Beer
A sharp yet smooth blend of sweet birch and wintergreen mint.$3.75
Regulär Wolpertinger Weuzelbier (Root Beer)
Our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.OUT OF STOCK$3.75
Diät Wolpertinger Weuzelbier (Diet Root Beer)
Our diet version of our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.$3.75
Sasquatch Sarsaparilla
Made with sassafras root extract and provides hints of licorice, caramel, vanilla and wintergreen.$3.75
Flatwoods FANTAsie (Orange)
With just the right amount of sweet and tangy, our Flatwoods FANTAsie is the perfect soda for you.$3.75
Mixed Case of Cryptid Club Soda (24 Pack)
A 24-pack of Cryptid Club Sodas, hand-mixed by staff. *Cases are random; special requests not guaranteed.$75.00
Sweet Legends
Desserts
From our Hand-Filled Cannolis to our decadent Mothman Tiramisu, we've got your sweet tooth covered!

1/4 lb. MONSTER Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our HUGE 1/4 lb. cookies, baked fresh daily with semi-sweet and milk chocolate chunks.$3.75
2/$6 MONSTER Chocolate Chip Cookies
Grab TWO of these delicious TRIPLE CHOCOLATE Cookies!$6.00
1/4 lb. MONSTER S'more Cookie
Our giant 1/4 lb. cookies, baked fresh with Mini Kisses, dark chocolate, marshmallows, and grahams.$3.75
2/$6 MONSTER S'more Cookies
Grab TWO of these delicious Chocolate, Marshmallow and Graham Cracker Cookies!$6.00
1/4 lb. MONSTER Apple Caramel Crisp Cookie
$3.75
2/$6 MONSTER Apple Caramel Crisp Cookies
$6.00
MONSTER BOX - 9 Assorted Monster Cookies
NINE Assorted MONSTER Cookies ready to share!$25.00
Mothman Tiramisu
Tiramisu with layers of mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, a hint of liqueur, and a cocoa dusting.$7.99
Cookie Butter Banana Cheesecake
$7.99
Grandma Bigfoot's Iced Carrot Cake
$7.99
Tatzelwurm's Barvarian Custard Apple Pie
OUT OF STOCK$7.99
Grafton Monster Pumpkin Patch Cheesecake
$7.99
Wendigo's Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Pie (Gluten-Friendly)
$7.99
Hand-Filled Cannoli
MADE TO ORDER! Our cannolis are out of this world!$4.75
Add-Ons & Extras
Dippers
From dippers to dressing, and spices galore!

14oz Bottle of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha
Our sweet honey meets sriracha heat with red chili peppers. Perfect for any dish!$13.99
12oz Bottle of Mike's Hot Honey
Mike's Hot Honey—the original honey infused with chilies, perfect for drizzling on your favorites.$13.99
4oz Ranch Dipper
This creamy and thick ranch dip is the ideal dipper for your favorite pizza!$2.25
4oz Bleu Cheese Dipper
$2.25
Grandioso Garlic Sauce Dipper
This garlic sauce provides a creamy, savory taste that is a must-have addition for your pizza!$1.50
SauceCraft Garlic Parmesan Dipper
This flavor-packed sauce is made with parmesan cheese, garlic, vinegar, and salt for a rich, savory taste.$1.50SauceCraft Sweet Chili Dipper
$1.50
Nacho Cheese Dipper
TOSTITOS Nacho Cheese Cup is delicious, tangy Nacho Cheese Dip ready to upgrade your favorite pizza, wings or pasta!$2.00
Mike's Hot Honey Dipper
Made with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers, and tangy vinegar!$2.50
Dipper of Marinara
Our Vegan-Friendly Classic Marinara is ready to be your dipper of choice!$1.00
Dipper of Buffalo
Grab a side of the rich, buttery flavor of Buffalo! The heat is mild – but the flavor is anything but.$1.00
Dipper of Honey Sriracha
Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's the perfect dipper for pizza!$1.00
Dipper of Barbecue
This deliciously thick and tangy-sweet barbecue adds a level of smokiness to any pizza!$1.00
Dipper of Basil Pesto

Dipper of Sweet Chili
A bold sauce with red chili peppers and garlic for a sweet, tart, mildly spicy kick.$1.00
Dipper of Teriyaki
$1.00
Dipper of Nashville Hot
$1.00
Dipper of Canadian Spice

Dipper of Mango Habenero

Dipper of Sweet Vidalia Onion

Dipper of Balsamic Glaze
This acidic, velvety liquid is a delicious add-on for any pizza or salad!$1.00
Dipper of Basil Pesto
Our nut-free basil pesto is the ultimate flavor dipper!$1.00
Parmesan Packet
Parmesan Cheese delivers just the right amount of savory, sharp flavor to pizzas, pasta dishes, salads and more!$0.15
Crushed Red Pepper Packet
Crushed Pepper Packets provides those who like to add "zest" to their meals with a spicy solution!$0.15
Salad Dressings
Why did the lettuce always invite the dressing to parties? Because it knew how to mix things up!

Raspberry Vinagrette - Fat Free
This is a light bodied dressing, deep maroon red in color with red bell pepper visible throughout.$1.50
Creamy Caesar
Rich and creamy flavor with pleasant anchovy, garlic and Romano cheese notes.$1.50
Golden Italian
Robust flavor with garlic, onion and tangy lemon notes, a truly authentic Italian flavored dressing.$1.50
Balsamic Vinaigrette
Made from balsamic vinegar, this dressing makes an excellent complement to olive oil.$1.50
Country French (Fat Free)
A smooth moderate bodied dressing accentuated by a fruity tomato notes in a tangy vinegar and spice background.$1.50
Thousand Island
A creamy classic with just the right amount of pickle relish and spice.$1.50
Ranch
With a taste that's cool and tangy, ranch dressing blends the familiar flavors of garlic, onion, and spices.$1.50
Honey Mustard
Sweetened with honey and packed with a unique blend of mustard and spices.$1.50
Blue Cheese
A full bodied spoonable dressing with visible blue cheese chunks.$1.50
Utensils & Napkins
Help us reduce waste! Order from here if you need utensils, napkins or plates!

Cutlery (Knife & Fork) w/ Napkin and Salt/Pepper
A disposable knife and fork set with a napkin and salt and pepper packets. One set included.$0.09
Styrofoam Plate
A sturdy, disposable foam plate for easy serving and cleanup. One plate included.$0.09
Extra Napkins (3)
Three extra disposable napkins for your order.$0.03
Add-On Catering Options
Catering Items
BIGFOOT Behemoth Salad
Our BIGFOOT Behemoth Salad is a colossal 9x13 catering tray bursting with a fresh blend of Arcadian mixed greens and spinach, topped with juicy tomatoes, sliced black olives, fresh mushrooms, crisp green peppers, and zesty red onions. Served with 10 dressing packets, it’s a vibrant, flavor-packed salad perfect for satisfying a crowd of veggie lovers. A legendary choice for any gathering or event!$45.00Chupacannoli Tray
A tray of 20 hand-filled cannolis with creamy filling, chocolate chips, and a light dusting of powdered sugar.$65.00Mothman's Tiramisu Tray
4lb tray of Italian dessert made with mascarpone cheese, lady fingers soaked in espresso, and lightly dusted with cocoa powder. Will be provided uncut and frozen for best transportation options.$90.00Cryptid Confection Tray (50 Cookies)
Includes an assortment of 50 freshly baked MONSTER Cookies, featuring our signature Chocolate Chip and Seasonal varieties. Soft, chewy, and packed with flavor, these legendary cookies are the perfect way to satisfy every sweet tooth at your gathering.$65.00Cryptid Cookie Collection (25 Assorted Cookies)
Includes an assortment of 25 freshly baked MONSTER Cookies, featuring our signature Chocolate Chip and Seasonal varieties. Soft, chewy, and packed with flavor, these legendary cookies are the perfect way to satisfy every sweet tooth at your gathering.$40.00Utensils & Plates - 10 Pack (10 Utensils Sets/10 Plates)
$1.00Mini Cryptid Collection (15 Cookies)
Includes (15) Monster Cookies$30.00

Stuffed Stromboli
$15.75
Stromboli with marinara, cheese, your choice of meats & veggies. Served with a dipper.
Customize your item
Sauce Options
Required
Select 1
Meat Toppings
Optional
Vegetable Toppings
Optional
Dipper Selection
Required
Select 1
Stromboli Cheese
Required
Select 1
Add-On Dippers
Select up to 2
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1






