Skip to Main content

  • New Glarus Bakery

New Glarus Bakery

534 1st St, New Glarus, WI
‌
‌
Sugar Cookie Cut-Outs
Cookie Gift Assortments
Donuts
Morning Roll
Coffeecakes
Puff Pastries
Butter Cookies
Lunch Box Cookies
Ethnic Cookies
Breads
Breadstix, Chips & Mixes
Buns
Chocolates
Chilled Desserts
Cheesecake
Bars
Coffee
Not Coffee
Signature Mugs
Cookie Dough
Pantry Items
Shirts

Featured Items

  • Morning Buns

    Flaky, oversized morning rolls layered with cinnamon swirls and dusted in cinnamon sugar
    $3.75

  • Gipfel

    A buttery treat that's hand-rolled like a croissant, but featuring a richer taste and flakier texture.
    $3.75

  • Cream Horn

    A golden flaky pastry shaped like a horn and filled with our signature buttercream.
    $4.00

Sugar Cookie Cut-Outs

  • Baseball Cookie

    Celebrate baseball season with a white chocolate decorated sugar cookie! A home-run for sure! *Sugar cookies dipped in colorful white chocolate. Designs and colors will vary.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.45

  • Bat

    Meet Batilda, our super cute purple bat who's ready to take flight on Halloween night in her purple white chocolate and sugar cookie costume.
    $2.35

  • Cat Cookie

    $3.00

  • Football- Med

    Kick Off Season with our sugar cookie dipped in colorful white chocolate/dark chocolate. *NOTE: All cookie decorations vary from picture.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.50

  • Ghost Cookie

    Meet Arthur the friendly cookie ghost. Here to delight with white chocolate and sugar cookie costumes
    $2.85

  • Leaf Cookie - Maple

    Swirls of fall colors in decadent white chocolate covered sugar cookie.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.75

  • Monster Sandwich Cookie

    Halloween Party Monsters are here with their buttercream filling between sugar cookie costumes. Of course they are friendly!
    $4.50

  • Pumpkin Cookie

    This pumpkin cookie is a fall delight - sugar cookie dipped in colorful white chocolate. *NOTE: All cookie decorations vary from picture.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.75

  • Pumpkin Face Cookie

    Friendly pumpkins coming to greet you this Halloween. Similar faces like this smiling boo.
    $3.25

Cookie Gift Assortments

  • Butter Cookie Assortment

    This lovely seasonal assortment of our famous Butter Cookies in five varieties (Raspberry Pockets, Lemon Pockets, Apricot Pockets, Sandbissen Shortbread & Butter Stars) will evoke memories of sweet, summery days no matter what time of year it is.
    $25.00

Donuts

  • Apple Cider - Plain

    Apple pie spices, real pressed apple cider infuse our fall favorite cake doughnut, just like Grandma used to make!
    $1.25

  • Apple Cider - Sugared

    Dusted with cinnamon and sugar, these cake doughnuts are flavored with apple pie spices and real pressed apple cider. A truly fall favorite!
    $1.25

  • Apple Fritter

    Lusciously deep fried, filled with apples and cinnamon and drizzled with glaze.
    $2.50

  • Caramel Cream-filled

    Vanilla donut filled with creamy buttercream and topped with a glossy caramel icing. A bakery favorite for many years!
    $2.25

  • Cheese-Filled Donut (24-hour notice)

    A soft pillow-y donut, filled with creamy cheese.
    $2.75

  • Chocolate Cream-filled

    Chocolate donut filled with creamy buttercream and topped with chocolate fudge icing. A bakery favorite for generations!
    $2.25

  • Cinnamon Twist

    Delicious swirly bread perfect for breakfast or anytime.
    $2.00

  • Glazed Ring Donut

    A sweet treat topped with fondant icing that practically melts in your mouth.
    $2.00

  • Long John (not filled)

    A rich, decadent treat topped with glaze.
    $2.00

  • Original Frycakes - Plain

    Plump original buttermilk cake doughnuts featuring the warm, rich flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $1.25

  • Original Frycakes - Sugared

    Handmade and home-fried plump, soft buttermilk cake doughnuts dusted with sugar.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $1.25

  • Pumpkin - Plain

    REAL pumpkin and pumpkin pie spices infuse our customers' favorite cake doughnut of the season (Available Oct & Nov only)
    OUT OF STOCK
    $1.25

  • Pumpkin - Sugared

    REAL pumpkin and pumpkin pie spices infuse our customers' favorite cake doughnut of the season (Available Oct & Nov only) Dusted with cinnamon and sugar
    OUT OF STOCK
    $1.25

  • Pumpkin Crueller

    Real pumpkin and pumpkin pie spices infuse this golden fried sweetdough, topped with in-house vanilla glaze **For a Limited time!
    $2.50

  • Raspberry Berliner

    A traditional vanilla donut filled with a vibrant raspberry filling and topped with in-house made vanilla icing. *filling does contain seeds.
    $2.25

  • Square Donut - Chocolate

    Moist and fluffy square donuts, full of chocolate flavor.
    $2.50

  • Sugar Ring Donut

    Fresh, warm, fluffy donuts, dredged in sugar.
    $2.00

  • Turtle Cream-filled

    Chocolate donut filled with creamy buttercream and topped with a glossy caramel icing, topped with pecans. A bakery favorite for generations!
    $2.25

Morning Roll

  • Cranberry Orange Scone

    Buttery homemade dough bursting with fruity flavors, creating the ultimate balance of richness and sweetness.
    $2.75

  • Danish

    Super-buttery, flaky, light-as-air pastry that's light on the sweetness but heavily delicious.
    $0+

  • Gipfel

    A buttery treat that's hand-rolled like a croissant, but featuring a richer taste and flakier texture.
    $3.75

  • Morning Buns

    Flaky, oversized morning rolls layered with cinnamon swirls and dusted in cinnamon sugar
    $3.75

  • Orange Blossoms

    Danish dough bursting with real ground oranges topped with our vanilla orange glaze.
    $2.75

  • Pumpkin Muffin - No Nut

    Our pumpkin bread in muffin style - golden raisins and no nuts!
    $3.95

  • Pumpkin Scone

    A fall special treat of a pumpkin scone made with real pumpkin. Soft center topped with cream cheese icing.
    $3.00

  • Sticky Bun

    Old-fashioned treat that comes with a decadent caramel glaze and chopped pecans.
    $3.00

Coffeecakes

  • Apple Bread

    Soft cinnamon swirl bread with chunks of apples and homemade vanilla icing.
    $7.25

  • Apple Kuchen

    Cinnamon apple cake with brown sugar struessel on top. Great with coffee or evening dessert with vanilla bean ice cream.
    $6.50

  • Fruit Swirl Coffeecake

    An afternoon delight or breakfast treat, our coffeecakes are light with a delicious fruit or spiced flavors of the season.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.50

  • Pumpkin Bread

    $6.99

Puff Pastries

  • Almond Horn

    Our buttery, house-made puff pastry dough, wrapped around a melting filling of sweet marzipan and finished with a delicate vanilla icing drizzle.
    $3.00

  • Nut Horns

    Flaky cream cheese dough wrapped around the tempting crunch of brown sugar and walnuts topped with a snowy swirl of icing.
    $3.25

  • Shoe Solas

    Delicate puff dough wrapped around pecans and cinnamon and hand-rolled in sugar.
    $3.50

  • Cherry Puff

    A burst of ripe, red cherry filling in a plump puff pastry wrapping, drizzled with a luscious trail of house-made vanila glaze
    $3.00

  • Cream Horn

    A golden flaky pastry shaped like a horn and filled with our signature buttercream.
    $4.00

  • Apple Turnover

    Made with our homemade puff pastry, stuffed with apple filling, and topped off with a drizzle of vanilla glaze.
    $3.00

Butter Cookies

  • Apple Bratzeli Pockets

    A specialty pocket cookie made from our Bratzeli dough and filled with apple pie sauce.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $1.75

  • Bratzeli - 1 doz per pkg

    Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland. 1 doz per pkg.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.75

  • Butter Stars

    Butter stars are hand-iced and sprinkled with colors of the season.

  • Honey Stix

    Gingerbread spiced cookie dipped in white chocolate.

  • Lemon Pockets

    Butter cookie filled with lemon filling

  • Raspberry Pockets

    Butter cookie filled with raspberry filling

  • Sandbissen shortbread

    Shortbread cookie rolled in crystal sugar colors of the season.

  • Swiss Croquettes

    Butter shortbread with candied cherries and toasted almonds

  • Apricot Pockets

    Butter cookie filled with apricot filling

Lunch Box Cookies

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    Packed with chocolate chips, delightfully chewy in the center, with crisp edges.

  • Peanut Butter Cookie

    Golden cookies that are packed with peanut butter flavor with a mildly chewy texture, and a deliciously crumbly edge.

  • Sugar Cookie

    Traditional sugar cookies that are light yet flavorful and rich.

  • Yodeldoodle Cookies

    Check out our latest mouthwatering creation, Yodeldoodle Cookies! These treats are our Swiss twist on the classic snickerdoodle, blending rich buttery goodness with a delicate dusting of cinnamon sugar on top.

  • BOGO Chocolate Chip Cookies

    $16.00

Ethnic Cookies

  • Swiss Croquettes

    Butter shortbread with candied cherries and toasted almonds

  • Bratzeli - 1 doz per pkg

    Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland. 1 doz per pkg.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.75

Breads

  • Alpen Brot

    Whole wheat sourdough with a thick crust.
    $5.75

  • Apple Bread

    Soft cinnamon swirl bread with chunks of apples and homemade vanilla icing.
    $7.25

  • Bavarian Rye

    A combination of sourdough white dough and dark rye flour, dusted with white rye flour.
    $5.75

  • Beer Bread

    Use your favorite beer or club soda to stir up a batch of your own Herbed Beer Bread and make your house smell amazing in the process.
    $7.00

  • Bread Bowls - Call to Order

    Our signature Swiss Bread turned into Bread Bowls. Great for dips and soups!
    $3.50

  • Buttercrust White Bread

    Mildly sweet sandwich bread with a buttery crust that is deliciously soft.
    $3.75

  • Cheesy Baked Potato Bread

    Golden cheddar cheese and fresh chives dance through a soft white potato bread for an utterly unique and dangerously delicious taste experience.
    $6.25

  • Cracked Wheat

    A hearty bread with a nutty, wholesome chew that tastes wonderful on morning toast or in a sandwich.
    $4.00

  • Egg Braid

    Gorgeously-braided bread featuring a fine, light texture inside and a shiny, golden-brown finish on the outside.
    $6.00

  • Farmers Rye

    White sourdough dough combined with dark rye flour, creating a hearty, crispy-crusted bread.
    $5.75

  • Gipfel

    A buttery treat that's hand-rolled like a croissant, but featuring a richer taste and flakier texture.
    $3.75

  • Potato Bread

    A delectable bread featuring a soft, lightweight texture from the potato-flour dough and a versatile artisan taste.
    $5.25

  • Pretzels (Saturdays Only)

    Hand-made, traditional Bavaria-style salted pretzel.
    $5.00

  • Pumpernickel

    This very traditional bread features the soft, light texture of rye flour and the earthy sweetness of a hint of molasses.
    $5.25

  • Raisin Pumpernickel

    Plump, sweet raisins bursting with rich fruity flavor in every bite of this hearty, rye bread.
    $5.75

  • Six Grain

    Six different grains – wheat, rye, oats, barley, corn, flax seed, sesame seeds, and millet – dance through this richly-flavored bread.
    $5.50

  • Sourdough

    This fine-textured bread brings a lightly “sour” flavor, as per the Swiss tradition, to a whole new level with a soft-on-the-inside, crispy-on-the-outside artisan texture and a golden-brown top crust.
    $5.75

  • Swiss Hard Rolls

    Light and airy with a delicious crackly, crunchy crust, which makes them a wonderful mini-sandwich roll.
    $1.50

  • White Bread

    A delicious bread with a very light, soft and fluffy center with a crunchy crust.
    $3.75

Breadstix, Chips & Mixes

  • Original Breadstix

    Savory, buttery, crunchy, best describes our 30+ year love affair with our Plain Breadstix.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.95

  • Hund Crunchies

    Treat your precious “hund” (that’s German for “dog”!) to a delicious, crunchy homemade treat carefully crafted with peanut butter, milk and whole wheat flour.
    $6.50

  • Cheese Breadsticks

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.50

  • Beer Bread

    Use your favorite beer or club soda to stir up a batch of your own Herbed Beer Bread and make your house smell amazing in the process.
    $7.00

Buns

  • Hamburger Buns - 8 pack

    Hamburgers, pulled pork BBQ or chicken salad sandwiches are no match for these buns! Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
    $3.85

  • Weiner Buns - 8 pack

    The best way to hug your brat or hotdog. Add your favorite toppings and enjoy!
    $3.85

  • Popovers / Dinner Rolls - 6 pack

    Buttery layers make our Popover buns a delish addition to any meal or just as they are.
    $3.00

  • Jack'd UP Potato Buns - 8 pack

    CALL TO ORDER - The name says it all - our signature Potato Bread loaded up with pepper-jack cheese, aged cheddar cheese & orange-spiced pickles for one tasty sidekick for your burger.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.95

  • Swiss Hard Rolls

    Light and airy with a delicious crackly, crunchy crust, which makes them a wonderful mini-sandwich roll.
    $1.50

Chocolates

  • Boo Z Pumpkin Pie Alp

    Pumpkin pie filling monster mashed with cake and bourbon creme liquor.
    $2.95

  • Hand-Dipped Turtles

    In-house roasted and buttered pecans, topped with caramel and dark chocolate. Qty varies by weight.
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Rum Balls

    Chocolate cake, dark chocolate fudge icing, and rum concoction make up this customers' favorite for more than 30 years.
    $2.25

Chilled Desserts

  • Apple Cinnamon Schnitten

    Celebrate the return of fall with our delicious buttercream layers, featuring rich Korintje cinnamon and a delightful apple pie filling. Enjoy!

  • Bienenstitch "Sting of the Bee"

    A slice of German dessert heaven! Signature Buttercream layered between sweet dough, topped with glazed almonds caramelized in REAL honey. *Product is served cold. Transport in cooler during hot weather seasons.

  • Custard Basket

    This choux pastry is layered with creamy vanilla custard, signature Buttercream, and drizzled with dark chocolate. *Product is served cold. Transport in cooler during hot weather seasons.
    $5.49

  • Eclairs

    Cool and creamy vanilla custard fills this choux pastry topped with rich chocolate icing. *Product is served cold. Transport in cooler during hot weather seasons.
    $4.50

Cheesecake

Creamy and luscious, with more filling than sugar-cookie crust, has been the instigator for more road trips than we can count. Try our year-round Turtle, Rasp, Cherry, Original Plain. Looking for our seasonal flavors? Ask in the comments upon ordering.

  • Apple Pie Cheesecake

    Original cheesecake blended with apple pie filling topped with cinnamon and sugar. A fall-favorite of the season!

  • Black Raspberry Apple Cheesecake

    Black raspberry and apple jelly swirled in original cheesecake.
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Butter-Pecan Cheesecake

    Nutty and buttery notes infused original cheesecake, topped with freshly in-house toasted pecans.

  • Cherry Cheesecake

    Creamy original cheesecake topped with sweet and juicy cherry compote.

  • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Semi-sweet mini chocolate chips meet original cheesecake. Say "cheese" to your new chocolatey friend!
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Original Plain Cheesecake

    Cool and creamy with a hint of lemon, baked low and slow with a sugar cookie crust.

  • Turtle Cheesecake

    A road-trip instigator with its smooth and creamy, luscious filling and thin sugar-cookie crust. Try our year-round Turtle, Raspberry, Cherry, and Original Plain. Looking for our seasonal flavors? Ask in the comments box before adding to cart. We'll confirm all flavors with you upon order receipt. Enjoy!
    OUT OF STOCK

Bars

  • Brownie

    A delectable dessert that is cakey on the outside and fudgy in the middle.
    $3.00

  • Choc Oat Bar

    Decadent bars made with layers of smooth, creamy dark chocolate confection over our homemade buttery oatmeal crumble base.
    $3.00

  • Linzer Bar- Raspberry

    Delicately soft, golden brownie of marzipan with raspberry filling.
    $3.00

  • Peanut Square - Chocolate Cake

    Soft, fluffy chocolate cake covered in our lightly-sweetened buttercream and ground peanuts.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.95

  • Peanut Square - Yellow Cake

    Soft, fluffy butter yellow cake covered in our lightly-sweetened buttercream and ground peanuts.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.95

  • Pumpkin Bar

    This dessert bar celebrates fall at its finest with REAL pumpkin, spices, and in-house cream cheese icing. Available until end of November.
    $3.50

Coffee

  • Latte

    Coffee drink made with espresso and steamed milk.
    $4.75+

  • Kalt BrU

    Delicious cold-pressed coffee that is perfect on a hot summer day.
    $5.75

  • Mocha Latte

    Cafe latte with chocolate that is foamy, milky sweet and lightly chocolatey.
    $5.25+

  • Espresso

    Full-flavored, concentrated coffee shots that is rich, aromatic and velvety all at once.
    $3.25+

  • Cappuccino

    A coffee drink that is made with a shot of espresso topped with steamed milk and milk foam.
    $4.75+

  • Reg Coffee

    In-house Swiss-pressed coffee of medium bodied breakfast blend beans, ground fresh for every.single.cup.
    $3.75+

  • Americano

    Espresso poured over by filtered hot water. A classic cafe beverage.
    $4.00+

Not Coffee

  • Bottle Water

    Drinking water packaged in a plastic bottle.
    $2.50

  • Can Soda

    Sweet, fizzy drink that is non-alcoholic and stored in a can. (Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Ice Tea, Mountain Dew)
    $2.00

  • Chai Tea

    A sweet and spicy tea made from a combination of black tea, ginger and other spices.
    $3.50+

  • Hot Cocoa

    A warm, hearty drink made from cocoa powder, sugar, and milk.
    $4.00+

  • Hot Tea

    A hot, aromatic beverage that is a great accompaniment to breakfast, lunch or dinner.
    $3.00

  • Juice - Orange

    Concentrated fruit juice made from oranges.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.50

  • Milk - White

    Your regular milk drink.
    $2.50

Signature Mugs

  • Pepin Mug - Luv Mug - 14 oz

    OUT OF STOCK
    $32.99

  • Pepin Mug - Lake Mist - 14 oz

    OUT OF STOCK
    $32.99

  • Patriot Mug - Patty Purple - 14 oz

    OUT OF STOCK
    $32.99

  • Patriot Mug - Seafoam Sands - 14 oz

    OUT OF STOCK
    $32.99

Cookie Dough

Cookie Dough to Go! 2lbs of the same dough we use to make our cookies. *Cookie dough is sold frozen/chilled. Approx 32 cookies (1oz per cookie) per each container. **yes, this is made with REAL eggs. Eat after baking :)

  • Cookie Dough - Online Pickup

    $14.00+

Pantry Items

  • Salted Butter - 1 lb

    Creamy fresh, salted butter. Photo by Markus Spiske from Pexels
    $4.99

  • Unsalted Butter - 1 lb

    Unsalted Butter
    $4.99

  • Cake Flour - 1 lb

    Cake flour used in making cookies, pastries and cake for a lighter fluffy product. Photo by Kristiana Pinne on Unsplash
    $1.25

  • Pastry Flour - 1 lb

    Pastry flour. For use in breads, pastries, cookies, cakes, muffins for a tender but not fall apart quality. Photo by Kaboompics .com from Pexels
    $1.25

  • Bread Flour - 1 lb

    Bread flour is all-purpose, contains no leavening additives. Use with dry or cake yeast, baking powder for breads, cookies, pastries, etc.
    $1.25

  • Cracked Wheat Flour - 1 lb

    $1.50

  • White Sugar - 1 lb

    Granulated beet sugar. Photo by C Drying on Unsplash
    $1.25

  • Powdered Sugar - 1 lb

    Powdered sugar or confectioners sugar. Sift before using creates best results for icings, cookies, bars, pastries. Photo by Evan Hein on Unsplash
    $2.00

  • Fresh Cake Yeast - 1 lb

    Fresh, active LaSaffre yeast. Great for use in fresh breads. *do not freeze. *expires 3 weeks from receipt date.
    $4.00

  • Cinnamon - 4 oz

    Ground Korintje Cinnamon, 1.5% strength. Great for cinnamon rolls, breads, oatmeal, toast, and more. Photo by Luísa Schetinger on Unsplash
    $3.50

  • Egg - qty 1

    Fresh, whole egg. Photo by Mae Mu on Unsplash
    $0.45

  • Semi-Sweet Mini Chocolate Chips - 1 lb

    Semi-sweet mini chocolate chips
    $1.63+

Shirts

Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™

  • Cherry Red Shirts - Front/Back Logo

    Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™
    $12.00+

  • Pink Azalea Shirts - Front/Back Logo

    Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™
    $12.00+

  • Sapphire Blue Shirts - Front/Back Logo

    Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™
    $12.00+

  • Mint Green Shirts - Front/Back Logo

    Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™
    $12.00+

  • White Shirts - Front/Back Logo

    Pocket logo with ornate bread wreath logo on the back. In-house design by Kate. T-Shirts are Gildan – Unisex Heavy Cotton™
    $12.00+
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 1.50% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Peanut Square - Chocolate Cake

$4.95

Soft, fluffy chocolate cake covered in our lightly-sweetened buttercream and ground peanuts.

Request advisory
Please enter details of your order if not already chosen from the menu.
1

New Glarus Bakery Location and Ordering Hours

(608) 527-2916
534 1st St, New Glarus, WI 53574
Closed • Opens Saturday at 7AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement