Skip to Main content
  • Over the Counter

Over The Counter

5596 N High Street, Worthington, OH
Pickup Only
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • Turkey Club

    Stack of thin-sliced turkey breast with bacon, Swiss, spring mix, tomato, & mayo on a grilled tomato swirl bread.
    $15.99
  • 1. BURGERS

    $13.99
  • Tuna Melt

    Dolphin-safe Albacore covered with melted cheddar and Swiss on grilled sourdough
    $13.99

FOOD

1. Appetizers

  • Chicken Tenders

    Juicy tempura-breaded tenders with buttermilk ranch
    $14.99
  • Chicken Wings

    Rubbed, baked and deep fried
    $8.99+
  • Fried Pickle Spears

    Tempura-breaded Kosher dill pickles with buttermilk ranch
    $7.99
  • Pile of Fries

    $5.99
  • Pretzel Bites

    Salted soft pretzels with Guinness beer cheese
    $7.99
  • Brussel Sprouts

    Bacon, red onion, balsamic glaze
    $9.99
  • Spinach Artachoke Dip

    Served with tortilla chips
    $11.99

2. Soups

  • Cup Chicken and Rice

    $5.99
  • Bowl Chicken and Rice

    $8.99
  • Cup French Onion

    $5.99
  • Bowl French Onion

    $8.99
  • Cup Cactus Chili

    $5.99
  • Bowl Cactus Chili

    $8.99
  • Bowl Soup du jour

    $8.99
  • Cup Soup du jour

    $5.99

3. Salads

  • CAESAR Full

    Romaine, garlic croutons and parmesan crisps with Caesar dressing
    $9.99
  • CAESAR Half

    Romaine, garlic croutons and parmesan crisps with Caesar dressing
    $6.99
  • COBB Salad Full

    Romaine, tomato, bacon, hard boiled eggs, red onion & bleu cheese with choice of dressing
    $9.99
  • COBB Salad Half

    Romaine, tomato, bacon, hard boiled eggs, red onion & bleu cheese with choice of dressing
    $6.99
  • ROUTE 23 Full

    Spring mix, fried herbed goat cheese medallions, balsamic marinated shallots, strawberries and candied walnuts with our House 23 dressing
    $9.99
  • ROUTE 23 Half

    Spring mix, fried herbed goat cheese medallions, balsamic marinated shallots, strawberries and candied walnuts with our House 23 dressing
    $6.99

4. Sandwiches and More

All sandwiches are served with kettle chips. You can sustitute another side for an upcharge.
  • 1. BURGERS

    $13.99
  • BLT

    Brown sugar and cayenne spiced bacon, lettuce, tomato, red pepper aioli on multigrain bread
    $12.99
  • Corn Beef Rueben

    Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, thousand island, on grilled rye swirl bread, creamy coleslaw & pickle spear
    $15.99
  • French Dip

    Seared rib-eye, Swiss, crispy onions, on an hoagie bun with au jus
    $16.99
  • Fried Egg Sandwich

    2 fried eggs, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on multigrain bread
    $9.99
  • Grilled Cheese

    Cheddar, provolone, swiss, grilled tomato and spicy mayo on grilled sourdough
    $10.99
  • Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich

    Spicy fried chicken, hot honey glaze, spicy mayo, coleslaw on a kaiser roll. Served with a pickle.
    $15.99
  • Hot Dog

    1/4 lb. Angus beef hot dog with spicy mustard on a New England roll
    $10.99
  • Italian Chicken Sandwich

    Grilled marinated chicken, red peppers, lettuce, tomato, provolone, & pesto aioli on grilled tomato swirl bread.
    $15.99
  • Pulled Pork

    Pulled BBQ pork shoulder roasted in brown sugar and Coca-Cola served on a grilled split-top bun, topped with an onion ring and pickles, served with creamy coleslaw on the side
    $15.99
  • Sloppy Joe

    Sweet & saucy lean beef, red pepper, & onion on a bun with creamy Cole slaw.
    $9.99
  • Tuna Melt

    Dolphin-safe Albacore covered with melted cheddar and Swiss on grilled sourdough
    $13.99
  • Turkey Club

    Stack of thin-sliced turkey breast with bacon, Swiss, spring mix, tomato, & mayo on a grilled tomato swirl bread.
    $15.99
  • Where's Waldo

    Famous Falter's thick-sliced German bologna, bourbon onions, on grilled sourdough. Served with spicy mustard and pickle spear.
    $13.99

5. Sides

  • Chips

    Kettle Chips
    $2.49
  • Cole Slaw

    Fresh and creamy slaw with green peppers and red onions
    $4.49
  • Fried Cod

    $6.99
  • Fruit

    $2.99
  • Fry Basket

    Fresh cut fries with rosemary oil and seasoning salt
    $5.99
  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    $6.99
  • Mac & Cheese Full

    House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
    $10.99
  • Mac & Cheese Half

    House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
    $6.99
  • Onion Rings

    Dipped to order in tempura beer batter
    $6.99
  • Side Sauce

    $0.99
  • Veg: Broccoli

    $3.99
  • Celery

    $0.99
  • Salmon

    $9.99

7. Kids

  • Kid Burger

    $6.99
  • Kid Chicken Tenders

    $6.99
  • Kid Grilled Cheese

    $6.99
  • Kid Mac & Cheese

    $6.99
  • Kid Side Fry

    $3.49
  • Kids Fruit cup

    $2.49
  • Kid Hot Dog

    $5.99

Allergies

  • Dairy Allergy / alergia a los lacteos

  • Gluten Allergy / alergia al gluten

  • Nut Allergy / alergia a las nueces

  • Vegan

  • Vegetarian

Dollar wing weds

  • Wings

    $1.00

DRINKS

  • Apple Juice

    $2.49
  • Cold Brew

    $2.99
  • Cranberry Juice

    $2.49
  • French Press

    $2.99
  • Ginger Beer

    $2.99
  • Grapefruit Juice

    $2.49
  • Hot Chocolate

    $2.79
  • Hot Tea

    $2.99
  • IBC Root Beer

    $2.99
  • Iced Tea

    $2.29
  • Milk

    $2.49
  • Milk Chocolate

    $2.79
  • Orange Juice

    $2.49
  • Pineapple Juice

    $2.49
  • Shirley Temple

    $2.39
  • Soda

    $2.29
  • Tomato Juice

    $2.49
  • Lemonade

    $2.99

Shirley Temple

$2.39
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1

Over the Counter Location and Ordering Hours

(614) 846-1107
5596 N High Street, Worthington, OH 43085
Open now • Closes at 8:30PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement