Skip to Main content
gluten free bagels now available on WEEKENDS ONLY (SATURDAY AND SUNDAY)
please click here to place a catering order
  • proper bagel

Banner image

proper bagel

2011 Belmont Boulevard, Nashville, TN
Pickup Only
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • new yorker

    farm egg, applewood bacon or sausage, yellow american cheese & ketchup.
    $9.75
  • garlic rosemary cream cheese & egg

    farm egg, applewood bacon, roasted garlic & rosemary cream cheese.
    $9.75
  • plain cream cheese

    $5.50

proper merch

  • b-boy short sleeve

    printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton
    $27.00
  • old school short sleeve

    printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton
    $27.00
  • 1977 crewneck sweatshirt

    as colour's relaxed fit crewneck - 80% cotton / 20% recycled polyester fleece
    $60.00
  • proper tote bag

    the proper tote - perfect for bagels by the dozen
    $25.00
  • b-boy longsleeve

    printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton
    $45.00

proper breakfast

  • new yorker

    farm egg, applewood bacon or sausage, yellow american cheese & ketchup.
    $9.75
  • gouda & egg

    farm egg, applewood bacon or sausage, smoked gouda cheese & spicy maple ketchup.
    $10.50
  • garlic rosemary cream cheese & egg

    farm egg, applewood bacon, roasted garlic & rosemary cream cheese.
    $9.75
  • avocado & egg

    farm egg, avocado, plain cream cheese, arugula & house-made tomato jam.
    $12.25
  • the breakfast "sangwich"

    *CONTAINS TREE NUTS* farm egg, grilled pistachio mortadella, american cheese, hashbrowns, ketchup or spicy mustard.
    $11.50
  • pastrami & egg

    farm egg, hot pastrami, american cheese, & spicy mustard
    $12.75
  • pesto & egg

    farm egg, pesto, avocado, tomato & swiss cheese.
    $11.75
  • jersey's finest

    farm egg, pork roll, american cheese & yellow mustard
    $10.25
  • leo

    scrambled farm eggs, sautéed chopped nova & onions with scallion dill cream cheese.
    $12.75

bagels with custom cream cheese

  • pumpkin pie cream cheese

    $7.25
  • plain cream cheese

    $5.50
  • scallion dill cream cheese

    $6.50
  • roasted garlic and rosemary cream cheese

    $6.50
  • fresh veggie cream cheese

    $6.50
  • jalapeño bacon cream cheese

    $6.50
  • olive cream cheese

    $7.00
  • lavender honey cream cheese

    $6.50
  • blueberry pie cream cheese

    $6.50
  • strawberry shortcake cream cheese

    $6.50
  • cookie dough cream cheese

    $6.50
  • dill pickle cream cheese

    $6.50
  • lox cream cheese with capers & onions

    capers & onions are already mixed in. they can't be removed!
    $7.25
  • birthday cake cream cheese

    $6.50
  • walnut raisin cream cheese

    $7.00
  • vegan scallion cream cheese

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $7.75
  • vegan cinnamon hazelnut cream cheese

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $7.75

fish sandwiches

  • nova

    *CLASSIC LOX SANDWICH* hand sliced smoked fish flown in from brooklyn, n.y. with scallion dill cream cheese, capers, red onion, & tomato. comes with house pickles. sandwich only, not offered as open-faced, or deconstructed.
    $15.50
  • pastrami nova

    *CLASSIC LOX SANDWICH* hand sliced smoked fish seasoned with savory pastrami spices flown in from brooklyn, n.y. with scallion dill cream cheese, capers, red onion, & tomato. comes with house pickles. sandwich only, not offered as open-faced, or deconstructed.
    $15.50
  • belly lox (extremely salty)

    *CLASSIC LOX SANDWICH* hand sliced smoked fish flown in from brooklyn, n.y. with scallion dill cream cheese, capers, red onion, & tomato. comes with house pickles. sandwich only, not offered as open-faced, or deconstructed.
    $15.50
  • whitefish piece

    filleted whitefish piece - flown in from brooklyn, n.y. with scallion dill cream cheese, capers, red onion, & tomato. comes with house pickles. sandwich only, not offered as open-faced, or deconstructed
    $15.50

butters & jams

  • plain butter

    $4.25
  • fresh strawberry butter

    $4.75
  • mixed berry jam

    $4.75
  • avocado bagel

    $5.50
  • peanut butter

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.75
  • cinnamon sugar butter

    $4.75

toasts

  • hot honey smashed avocado

    fresh smashed avo, whipped feta and hot honey cream cheese, topped with lemon basil oil dressed arugula, everything seeds, & hot honey drizzle
    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.50
  • tuna melt

    tuna salad, house-made pickle relish, tomato, muenster cheese, & house-made basil oil
    $13.75
  • open faced smoked salmon toast

    hand sliced nova scotia salmon, sliced avocado, tomato, cucumber, julienned red onions, & lemon dill aioli
    OUT OF STOCK
    $17.50

proper lunch

  • reuben

    corned beef, house-made caraway sauerkraut, swill cheese & russian dressing.
    $12.50
  • rachel

    pastrami, house-made caraway sauerkraut, swiss cheese & russian dressing.
    $12.50
  • pesto chicken melt

    herbed chicken with house pesto, avocado, arugula, muenster cheese & mayo.
    $13.50
  • turkey blta

    oven roasted turkey, applewood bacon, tomato, avocado, arugula with balsamic drizzle & mayo.
    $13.50
  • turkey & brie cheese

    oven roasted turkey, stone ground honey mustard, arugula, granny smith apples & brie cheese.
    $12.50
  • veggie burger

    house-made vegan veggie burger with avocado, tomato jam & arugula.
    $13.50
  • fresh mozzarella

    fresh mozzarella, house-made olive tapenade, tomato, arugula, balsamic drizzle & basil oil.
    $11.00
  • grilled cheese

    inside out bagel w/ melted swiss, cheddar, & muenster cheese
    $9.00
  • honey maple ham melt

    honey maple ham with cheddar cheese & mustard
    $10.50
  • custom turkey sandwich

    build it your way turkey sandwich
    $9.00

proper salad sandwiches

  • classic tuna salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $11.00
  • veggie tuna salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $11.25
  • chunky chicken salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $11.50
  • waldorf chicken salad

    *CONTAINS NUTS* topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $11.50
  • spicy buffalo chicken salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw. (contains bleu cheese)
    $11.50
  • classic egg salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $10.50
  • whitefish salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $14.00
  • baked salmon salad

    topped with tomato, arugula and pickled red onion. comes with a side of pickle slaw.
    $14.00

deli & market by the pound

  • 1/2lb classic tuna

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $10.00
  • 1lb classic tuna

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $20.00
  • 1/2lb veggie tuna

    tuna salad mixed with carrots, celery & radish
    $10.50
  • 1lb veggie tuna

    tuna salad mixed with carrots, celery & radish
    $21.00
  • 1/2lb chunky chicken

    chicken salad with celery. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $11.00
  • 1lb chunky chicken

    chicken salad with celery. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $22.00
  • 1/2lb waldorf chicken

    *CONTAINS NUTS* chicken salad with grapes, walnuts, raisins, and celery. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $11.00
  • 1lb waldorf chicken

    *CONTAINS NUTS* chicken salad with grapes, walnuts, raisins, and celery. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $22.00
  • 1/2lb spicy buffalo chicken salad

    spicy buffalo sauce, bleu cheese, carrots & celery
    $11.00
  • 1lb spicy buffalo chicken salad

    spicy buffalo sauce, bleu cheese, carrots & celery
    $22.00
  • 1/2lb egg salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $8.75
  • 1lb egg salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $17.50
  • 1/2lb whitefish salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $11.50
  • 1lb whitefish salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $23.00
  • 1/2lb baked salmon salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $11.50
  • 1lb baked salmon salad

    by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $23.00
  • small penne pasta

    penne pasta, sundried tomato, basil, artichoke hearts, asiago cheese. by the pound in a container.
    $8.25
  • large penne pasta

    penne pasta, sundried tomato, basil, artichoke hearts, asiago cheese. by the pound in a container.
    $16.50
  • small israeli

    cucumber, onion, tomato, parsley.
    $7.00
  • large israeli

    cucumber, onion, tomato, parsley.
    $14.00
  • small roasted brussel sprouts

    asiago cheese, olive oil, by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $7.00
  • large roasted brussel sprouts

    asiago cheese, olive oil - by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $14.00
  • small vegan spicy veggies

    onions, bell peppers, carrots. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $7.00
  • large vegan spicy veggies

    onions, bell peppers, carrots. by the pound in a container, bagels not included.
    $14.00
  • small kale salad

    *CONTAINS NUTS* honey balsamic dressing marinated kale, apples, cranberries, almonds.
    $8.00
  • large kale salad

    *CONTAINS NUTS* honey balsamic dressing marinated kale, apples, cranberries, almonds.
    $16.00
  • 1/2lb beets

    bleu cheese, walnuts & chives
    $8.00
  • 1lb beets

    bleu cheese, walnuts & chives
    $16.00
  • 1/2lb potato salad

    mayo, dill, mustard seeds
    $7.50
  • 1lb potato salad

    mayo, dill, mustard seed
    $15.00
  • small tortellini salad

    tortellini, corn, pickled onion, bell peppers, feta
    $8.25
  • large tortellini salad

    tortellini, corn, pickled onion, bell peppers, feta
    $16.50
  • 1/2lb house olives

    marinated
    $8.50
  • 1lb house olives

    marinated
    $17.00
  • small fresh mozzarella salad

    fresh mozzarella with balsamic drizzle, tomato and basil
    $12.50
  • large fresh mozzarella salad

    fresh mozzarella with balsamic drizzle, tomato and basil
    $25.00

cream cheese by the pound - no bagels included

  • 1/2 pumpkin pie

    $10.00
  • 1 lb pumpkin pie

    $20.00
  • 1/2 plain cream cheese

    $6.50
  • 1 lb plain cream cheese

    $13.00
  • 1/2 lb olive cream cheese

    $10.00
  • 1 lb olive cream cheese

    $20.00
  • 1/2 scallion dill

    $8.00
  • 1 lb scallion dill

    $16.00
  • 1/2 fresh veggie

    $8.00
  • 1 lb fresh veggie

    $16.00
  • 1/2 roasted garlic and rosemary

    $9.50
  • 1 lb roasted garlic and rosemary

    $19.00
  • 1/2 lox cream cheese with capers

    $10.00
  • 1 lb lox cream cheese with capers

    $20.00
  • 1/2 jalapeño bacon

    $9.75
  • 1 lb jalapeño bacon

    $19.50
  • 1/2 dill pickle

    $9.50
  • 1 lb dill pickle

    $19.00
  • 1/2 lavender honey

    $9.50
  • 1 lb lavender honey

    $19.00
  • 1/2 strawberry shortcake

    $9.50
  • 1 lb strawberry shortcake

    $19.00
  • 1/2 birthday cake

    $9.50
  • 1 lb birthday cake

    $19.00
  • 1/2 blueberry

    $9.50
  • 1 lb blueberry pie

    $19.00
  • 1/2 cookie dough

    $10.00
  • 1 lb cookie dough

    $20.00
  • 1/2 walnut raisin cream cheese

    $9.50
  • 1 lb walnut raisin cream cheese

    $19.00
  • 1/2 lb vegan scallion

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $10.25
  • 1 lb vegan scallion

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $20.50
  • 1/2 lb vegan cinnamon and hazelnut

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $10.25
  • 1 lb vegan cinnamon and hazelnut

    *CONTAINS SOY*
    $20.50

hand sliced smoked salmon by the pound

  • 1/4 lb nova scotia salmon

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    $16.50
  • 1/2 lb nova scotia salmon

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    $33.00
  • 1 lb nova scotia salmon

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    $66.00
  • 1/4 lb pastrami nova

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.50
  • 1/2 lb pastrami nova

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $33.00
  • 1 lb pastrami nova

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $66.00
  • 1/4 lb belly lox (extremely salty)

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.50
  • 1/2 lb belly lox (extremely salty)

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $33.00
  • 1 lb belly lox (extremely salty)

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-sliced to order
    OUT OF STOCK
    $66.00
  • 1/4 lb whitefish

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-filleted to order
    $9.50
  • 1/2 lb whitefish

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-filleted to order
    $19.00
  • 1 lb whitefish

    flown in from Brooklyn, NY & skillfully hand-filleted to order
    $38.00

bagels by the dozen

if pairing with cream cheese, we suggest a minimum of 1 pound of cream cheese per half dozen and 1 and 1/2 pounds of cream cheese per dozen. please note: salt bagels are extremely salty
  • baker's dozen (13 bagels)

    please note if adding gluten free bagels to your dozen, they will all be in one bag. we cannot guarantee they are free from cross-contamination.
    $23.00
  • half dozen

    please note if adding gluten free bagels to your dozen, they will all be in one bag. we cannot guarantee they are free from cross-contamination.
    $13.50

soup & green salads

  • matzah ball chicken noodle soup

    house-made matzah ball chicken noodle soup
    $8.00
  • caprese salad

    fresh mozzarella, arugula, tomato, kalamata olive, avocado, basil oil & balsamic drizzle.
    $15.50
  • cobb salad

    arugula, bacon, turkey, avocado, egg, bermuda onion, tomato & balsamic dressing on the side.
    $15.50
  • greek salad w/ balsamic chicken

    balsamic-glazed chicken breast, arugula, pickled onion, tomato, feta, kalamata olives, banana peppers & balsamic dressing on the side.
    $15.50
  • berry & bleu

    arugula, oven roasted turkey, blueberries, strawberries, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, sunflower seeds, & house-made balsamic dressing
    $16.50

pastries

  • black & white cookie

    authentic New York black-and-white cookies
    $5.50
  • rainbow marzipan bar

    classic new york - style tri color rainbow marzipan bar / cookie (contains almond).
    $6.50
  • pumpkin chai spice cupcake

    pumpkin cupcake topped with chai buttercream & a sprinkle of pumpkin spice
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.50
  • pumpkin spice bread pudding

    housemade bread pudding made with our pumpkin bagels, vanilla, pumpkin spice and a drizzle of salted caramel. served cold or heat at home.
    $5.50
  • strawberry poptart

    housemade fresh strawberry pop tart
    $6.25
  • cinnamon & brown sugar poptart

    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.25
  • funfetti sugar cookie bar

    funfetti sugar cookie bars with buttercream frosting decorated for fall
    $7.00
  • hazelnut & chocolate ganache crumb square

    hazelnut & chocolate ganache crumb square.
    $6.00
  • cinnamon crumb coffee cake loaf

    $5.00
  • chocolate chip sour cream cake

    housemade chocolate chip sour cream cake topped with chocolate drizzle.
    $6.00
  • chocolate chip fudge brownie

    $5.00
  • cinnamon ruggalah

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00
  • chocolate ruggalah

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00
  • raspberry ruggalah

    $5.00
  • italian butter cookie cherry

    new york style italian butter cookie sandwich filled with cherry preserves & topped with powdered sugar *contains almond*
    $4.00
  • italian butter cookie sprinkle

    new york style italian butter cookie sandwich filled will chocolate ganache & topped with sprinkles *contains almond*
    $4.00
  • cinnamon roll

    large house made cinnamon roll with cream cheese glaze
    $6.00
  • coconut macaroons (GF)

    gluten-free chocolate-dipped coconut macaroons (6 per bag).
    $6.00
  • chocolate fudge gluten free donut

    gluten-free chocolate fudge baked donut with sprinkles.
    $4.00
  • chocolate chip cookie (GF)

    housemade gluten free chocolate chip cookie
    $4.50
  • linzer cookie

    raspberry jam filled linzer cookie topped with powdered sugar
    $5.50
  • peanut butter & chocolate ganache pie

    slice of double peanut butter & chocolate ganache pie with a shortbread crust
    $6.50
  • mini apple pie

    classic miniature apple pie with a lattice crust topped with powdered sugar
    $5.00
  • chocolate dipped chocolate chip cookie

    $4.50

sides

  • micro green side salad

    $3.00
  • side of avocado

    $4.50
  • side of bacon

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00
  • side of capers

    $3.00
  • side of pickle slaw

    $1.00
  • side of tomato

    $3.50
  • side of onion

    $2.50
  • side of english cucumber

    $2.50
  • side of lemon

    3 slices
    $0.75
  • side of strawberry butter

    $3.00
  • side of peanut butter

    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.50
  • side of butter 2oz

    $2.50
  • side of mixed berry jam

    $2.50
  • pickle spear

    $0.75
  • side of hot honey

    $2.50
  • side of lemon aoli

    $1.50

crema coffee drinks - no decaf offered

  • iced pumpkin pie latte

    real pumpkin mixed with brown sugar & pumpkin spice. pro tip - add salted maple cold foam!
    $9.50
  • hot pumpkin pie latte

    real pumpkin mixed with brown sugar & pumpkin spice.
    $9.50
  • 12 oz drip coffee

    no decaf offered
    $4.00
  • 16 oz iced coffee

    we HIGHLY suggest not adding mocha or caramel to iced coffee as it does not break down well!
    $4.75
  • 12 oz hot latte

    prepared with a double-shot of espresso
    $5.75
  • 16 oz iced latte

    prepared with a double-shot of espresso. pro tip - add our seasonal salted maple cold foam!
    $6.25
  • iced espresso tonic

    $6.25
  • strawberry lemonade espresso tonic

    $7.50
  • fresh lemonade espresso tonic

    espresso, club soda, splash of house-made lemonade
    $7.00
  • 12 oz cappuccino

    $5.75
  • cortado

    espresso mixed with steamed milk
    $4.75
  • 12 oz hot americano

    double-shot of espresso over hot water
    $4.75
  • 16 oz iced americano

    $5.25
  • double shot of espresso

    double-shot of espresso
    $4.25
  • steamer

    $4.00
  • café au lait

    $5.00
  • crema coffee box

    locally roasted crema coffee box. comes with cups, creamers, and sugars.
    $50.00

proper cold drinks

  • fresh-squeezed lemonade

    $5.00
  • honey lavender lemonade

    $6.25
  • fresh strawberry lemonade

    $6.50
  • natalie’s orange juice

    natalie's fresh-squeezed orange juice
    $5.00
  • iced unsweetened black tea

    $3.50
  • arnold palmer

    half unsweet tea, half lemonade
    $5.00
  • whole milk

    16oz
    $2.75
  • house-made chocolate milk

    16oz // house-made dark chocolate syrup
    $4.00
  • martinelli's apple juice

    $4.00
  • dr. browns soda

    $3.25
  • Coca-Cola, Can

    Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
    $2.25
  • canada dry ginger ale

    $2.25
  • fiji water

    $3.00
  • san pellegrino

    $3.50
  • perrier sparkling water

    $3.25

dream street donation

purchase a half dozen bagels + cream cheese bundle (or a few) for neighbors who need extra support right now and pay it forward. Dream Street Tennessee will distribute bagels + cream cheese daily to nashville community members in need.
  • dream street half dozen

    If you’re able to lend a hand and pay it forward, please consider supporting neighbors in our community who are dealing with a gap in their SNAP/EBT coverage.
    $13.50
  • dream street half dozen + plain cream cheese

    If you’re able to lend a hand and pay it forward, consider supporting neighbors in our community who are dealing with a gap in their SNAP/EBT coverage.
    $18.50

cinnamon crumb coffee cake loaf

$5.00
Request advisory
SPECIAL REQUESTS WILL NOT BE HONORED. PLEASE DO NOT EVEN TRY!!! no refunds once your order is placed. allergies only will be honored in this section.
1

proper bagel Location and Ordering Hours

(615) 928-7276
2011 Belmont Boulevard, Nashville, TN 37212
Open now • Closes at 2:45PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement