Skip to Main content
BEFORE CHECKOUT PLEASE CHECK YOUR PICKUP TIME!

  • Third Proof Pizzeria

Third Proof Pizzeria

263 Changebridge Road, Pine Brook, NJ
Pickup Only
‌
‌
specials
Pizza
Chicken Cutlets
Sides
Desserts
Beverages

Featured Items

  • New Haven Style

    Thin crust. Light mozz. Heavy sauce. Extra parm. Baked very crispy.
    $22.00

  • Cheese Pizza

    Fresh, whole milk & park skim mozzarella blend. Organic milled tomatoes. Finished with basil and parm.
    $21.00

  • Pepperoni Hot Honey

    Cheese base. Crispy cupping pepperoni. Finished with Whipped ricotta, basil, parm, and our own hot honey.
    $29.00

specials

  • French Onion Pizza

    LONG AWAITED. ITS BACK. 8 hour caramelized onions in beef bone broth and Cabernet Sauvignon reduction. Gruyère Cheese. Finished with chives.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $30.00

  • sourdough bagels.

    100% sourdough bagels. 100% organic grains. Only available Sunday starting 9am. Orders placed for other times will be canceled or only available for pickup on Sunday morning.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00+

  • sourdough bombolone

    preorder only for Sunday sept 20th. 100% sourdough bombolone. soft Italian donuts with your choice filling. third proof x crislukes. orders placed for other times will be canceled or only available for pickup on sunday morning.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

  • sourdough loaf

    100% organic grains & 100% sourdough. ingredients: flour, water, & sea salt. preorder for sunday pickup only.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $13.00

Pizza

  • Cheese Pizza

    Fresh, whole milk & park skim mozzarella blend. Organic milled tomatoes. Finished with basil and parm.
    $21.00

  • New Haven Style

    Thin crust. Light mozz. Heavy sauce. Extra parm. Baked very crispy.
    $22.00

  • Marinara

    Organic milled tomatoes. Shaved garlic. Sicilian oregano. Finished with Basil & EVOO finish. ***NO CHEESE***
    $17.00

  • Pepperoni

    Cheese pizza base. Crispy cupping pepperoni. Finished with parm & basil.
    $25.00

  • Pepperoni Hot Honey

    Cheese base. Crispy cupping pepperoni. Finished with Whipped ricotta, basil, parm, and our own hot honey.
    $29.00

  • Vodka Sauce

    Creamy house vodka sauce. Fresh, whole milk, part skim mozzarella. Finished with basil and parm.
    $26.00

  • Vodka Roni

    Our Vodka Sauce pie topped with Ezzo Pepperoni. Finished with fresh basil & grated parm.
    $28.00

  • White

    Garlic. Ricotta. Provolone. Fresh, whole milk, & part skim mozzarella blend. Finished with basil and parm.
    $25.00

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Crispy chicken cutlet tossed in buffalo sauce. Mozzarella cheese blend. Finished with ranch & chives.
    $29.00

  • Burrata

    Organic milled tomatos. Shaved Garlic. Finished with Burrata, Basil, Parm & EVOO.
    $29.00

  • Mushroom & Onion

    Fresh, whole milk & part skim mozzarella. caramelized onions, thyme. No sauce. Finished with parm.
    $25.00

Chicken Cutlets

  • Marinara Chicken Parm

    Three crispy chicken cutlets, topped with melted mozzarella, house marinara, basil, and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    $22.00

  • Vodka Chicken Parm

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with melted mozzarella, creamy vodka sauce, basil, and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    $22.00

  • Buffalo Chicken Cutlet

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with house buffalo sauce, seed oil free ranch, and chives. ***NO CHEESE*** FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    $20.00

  • Lemon Zest Chicken Cutlet

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with lemon zest & juice, parsley, EVOO and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    $20.00

Sides

  • Ceasar Salad

    Chopped romaine lettuce, sourdough croutons, & parmigiano reggiano. With house made Caesar dressing. Contains pasteurized egg yolks and anchovies in the dressing.
    $10.00+

  • Garlic Knots

    Five knots. Tossed in garlic butter and parmigiano reggiano. Choice of marinara or vodka for dipping.
    $7.00

  • flat iron pepper flakes

    $1.00

  • freshly grated parmesan

    $1.00

  • vodka sauce 4oz

    $1.50

  • marinara sauce 4oz

    $1.00

  • ranch 4oz

    $1.50

  • ceasar dressing 4oz

    $1.50

Desserts

  • Browned Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookie

    Brown butter, chocolate chunk cookie. Crispy on the outside and goey on the inside. Flakey salt. Baked every day.
    $5.00

Beverages

  • Mexican Coke

    $4.25

  • Mexican Sprite

    $4.25

  • Mountain Valley Water Still

    $3.00

  • Mountain Valley Water Sparkling

    $3.00

  • Diet Coke Glass Bottle

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

  • Just Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • Diet Coke Can

    $3.00

  • Root Beer

    $4.00

  • Sparkling Coconut Water

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

Ceasar Salad

$0.00

Chopped romaine lettuce, sourdough croutons, & parmigiano reggiano. With house made Caesar dressing. Contains pasteurized egg yolks and anchovies in the dressing.

Customize your item

Size

Required
Select 1

Add on

Select up to 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Third Proof Pizzeria Location and Ordering Hours

(973) 287-7220
263 Changebridge Road, Pine Brook, NJ 07058
Open now • Closes at 8PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement