Skip to Main content
BEFORE CHECKOUT PLEASE CHECK YOUR PICKUP TIME!

  • Third Proof Pizzeria

Third Proof Pizzeria

263 Changebridge Road, Pine Brook, NJ
Pickup Only
‌
‌
specials
Pizza
Chicken Cutlets
Sides
Desserts
Beverages

Featured Items

  • New Haven Style

    Thin crust. Light mozz. Heavy sauce. Extra parm. Baked very crispy.
    $22.00

  • Cheese Pizza

    Fresh, whole milk & park skim mozzarella blend. Organic milled tomatoes. Finished with basil and parm.
    $21.00

  • Garlic Knots

    Five knots. Tossed in garlic butter and parmigiano reggiano. Choice of marinara or vodka for dipping.
    $7.00

specials

  • French Onion Pizza

    LONG AWAITED. ITS BACK. 8 hour caramelized onions in beef bone broth and Cabernet Sauvignon reduction. Gruyère Cheese. Finished with chives.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $30.00

  • sourdough bagels.

    100% sourdough bagels. 100% organic grains. Only available Sunday starting 9am. Orders placed for other times will be canceled or only available for pickup on Sunday morning.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00+

  • sourdough bombolone

    preorder only for Sunday sept 20th. 100% sourdough bombolone. soft Italian donuts with your choice filling. third proof x crislukes. orders placed for other times will be canceled or only available for pickup on sunday morning.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

  • sourdough loaf

    100% organic grains & 100% sourdough. ingredients: flour, water, & sea salt. preorder for sunday pickup only.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $13.00

Pizza

  • Cheese Pizza

    Fresh, whole milk & park skim mozzarella blend. Organic milled tomatoes. Finished with basil and parm.
    $21.00

  • New Haven Style

    Thin crust. Light mozz. Heavy sauce. Extra parm. Baked very crispy.
    $22.00

  • Marinara

    Organic milled tomatoes. Shaved garlic. Sicilian oregano. Finished with Basil & EVOO finish. ***NO CHEESE***
    $17.00

  • Pepperoni

    Cheese pizza base. Crispy cupping pepperoni. Finished with parm & basil.
    $25.00

  • Pepperoni Hot Honey

    Cheese base. Crispy cupping pepperoni. Finished with Whipped ricotta, basil, parm, and our own hot honey.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $29.00

  • Vodka Sauce

    Creamy house vodka sauce. Fresh, whole milk, part skim mozzarella. Finished with basil and parm.
    $26.00

  • Vodka Roni

    Our Vodka Sauce pie topped with Ezzo Pepperoni. Finished with fresh basil & grated parm.
    $28.00

  • White

    Garlic. Ricotta. Provolone. Fresh, whole milk, & part skim mozzarella blend. Finished with basil and parm.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.00

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Crispy chicken cutlet tossed in buffalo sauce. Mozzarella cheese blend. Finished with ranch & chives.
    $29.00

  • Burrata

    Organic milled tomatos. Shaved Garlic. Finished with Burrata, Basil, Parm & EVOO.
    $29.00

  • Mushroom & Onion

    Fresh, whole milk & part skim mozzarella. caramelized onions, thyme. No sauce. Finished with parm.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.00

Chicken Cutlets

  • Marinara Chicken Parm

    Three crispy chicken cutlets, topped with melted mozzarella, house marinara, basil, and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00

  • Vodka Chicken Parm

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with melted mozzarella, creamy vodka sauce, basil, and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00

  • Buffalo Chicken Cutlet

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with house buffalo sauce, seed oil free ranch, and chives. ***NO CHEESE*** FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

  • Lemon Zest Chicken Cutlet

    Three chicken cutlets, topped with lemon zest & juice, parsley, EVOO and grated parm. FRIED IN AVOCADO OIL.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

Sides

  • Ceasar Salad

    Chopped romaine lettuce, sourdough croutons, & parmigiano reggiano. With house made Caesar dressing. Contains pasteurized egg yolks and anchovies in the dressing.
    $10.00+

  • Garlic Knots

    Five knots. Tossed in garlic butter and parmigiano reggiano. Choice of marinara or vodka for dipping.
    $7.00

  • flat iron pepper flakes

    $1.00

  • freshly grated parmesan

    $1.00

  • vodka sauce 4oz

    $1.50

  • marinara sauce 4oz

    $1.00

  • ranch 4oz

    $1.50

  • ceasar dressing 4oz

    $1.50

Desserts

  • Browned Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookie

    Brown butter, chocolate chunk cookie. Crispy on the outside and goey on the inside. Flakey salt. Baked every day.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

Beverages

  • Mexican Coke

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.25

  • Mexican Sprite

    $4.25

  • Mountain Valley Water Still

    $3.00

  • Mountain Valley Water Sparkling

    $3.00

  • Diet Coke Glass Bottle

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

  • Just Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • Diet Coke Can

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

  • Root Beer

    $4.00

  • Sparkling Coconut Water

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

French Onion Pizza

$30.00

LONG AWAITED. ITS BACK. 8 hour caramelized onions in beef bone broth and Cabernet Sauvignon reduction. Gruyère Cheese. Finished with chives.

Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Third Proof Pizzeria Location and Ordering Hours

(973) 287-7220
263 Changebridge Road, Pine Brook, NJ 07058
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 11AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement