Skip to Main content
All Pickup and Delivery times are estimates. We hand make our pies and during peak times, especially Friday to Sunday, there may be delays.
  • Salvatore's Tomato Pies

  • 10 N Livingston Street, Madison, WI121 East Main Street, Sun Prairie, WI5511 Monona Drive, Monona, WI5507 Monona Drive, Monona, WI

Salvatore's Tomato Pies Monona

5507 Monona Drive, Monona, WI
‌
‌
Everyday
Merchandise
To-Go Beverages & Utensils

Featured Items

  • 16” BYO

    Pies start with olive oil, Wisconsin whole milk Mozzarella, and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
    $19.95
  • Garlic Bread

    Toasted Baguette, Garlic Butter, SarVecchio Parmesan, and Confit Garlic. Served with House Marinara.
    $10.00
  • 16" Fat Uncle Tony

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce
    $27.50

Everyday

Appetizers

  • Italian Chili Oil Fried Ravioli

    breaded cheese and sausage filled ravioli, house Italian chili oil, romano cheese, scallions & pepper curls. **contains nuts**
    $15.00
  • Proscuitto & Melon Broken Pizzetta

    crispy fried pizza crust broken into chips, topped with burrata, farm fresh cantaloupe, prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic reduction
    OUT OF STOCK
    $18.00
  • Aperol-Orange Sticky Ribs

    baby back pork ribs, house Campari-Orange glaze, orange slices, parsley
    $19.50
  • Burrata

    Burrata, Flyte Family Farm tomatoes, arugula, fig balsamic reduction, lemon, olive oil, grilled bread
    $14.00
  • Fried Calamari

    Crispy Deep-fried Fresh Squid and peppers. Served with Red Sauce and lemon. Add Dynamite Sauce 3
    $17.50
  • Garlic Bread

    Toasted Baguette, Garlic Butter, SarVecchio Parmesan, and Confit Garlic. Served with House Marinara.
    $10.00
  • Meatballs

    Grandma Aversano’s Meatballs- Three of our famous meatballs, Romano, parsley, grilled bread.
    $12.50
  • French Fries

    12 oz., Lightly Seasoned
    $8.00
  • Chicken Wings

    8 Chicken Wings. Choice of Sauce or Dry Rub
    $16.50
  • Caesar Fries

    Battered Fries, Romano Cheese, Caesar Dressing Optional Truffle Oil
    $12.00
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    (6) fried mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce.
    $12.50
  • Brussel Sprouts

    *BACK FOR A LIMITED TIME* Crisp Brussels sprouts with garlic, hot honey, ricotta salata and lemon–yogurt sauce.
    $13.00
  • Frittatina Napoletana

    Neapolitan fried pasta fritters with prosciutto cotto, peas, provolone, bucatini and bescimella. Garnished with Pea Pesto, Sarvecchio, and Chive. 3 per order.
    $11.00

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Romaine, Shaved SarVecchio, Parmesan Crisps, House Caesar Dressing and Fresh Dill
    $14.00
  • Market Salad

    Mixed Greens with Market Vegetables, SarVecchio, and House Seasonal Vinaigrette
    $12.50

Snacks

  • Charred Shishito Pepper

    grilled shishito peppers, olive oil, salt & pepper with choice of pepperoni aioli or tahini vinaigrette
    $8.00
  • Stracchino Beer Cheese Spread

    Stracchino cheese, spotted cow, crostini and cornichons
    $9.00
  • Potato Chips

    $3.00

Sandwiches

  • Meatball Sub

    Grandma's Meatballs, Garlic Butter, Provolone and Red Sauce on Italian Deli Bread
    $12.50

Pasta and Entrees

  • Grilled Flat Iron Tagliata

    Grilled Flat Iron Tagliata 8 oz. prime flat iron steak grilled and sliced over arugula, tomato and SarVecchio. Served with fries and choice of compound butter.
    $32.00
  • Bucatini and Meatballs

    $24.00
  • Gemelli Verde

    Gemelli, house pistachio pesto, grilled chicken, burrata.
    $22.00
  • Fritto Misto di Mare

    Fried calamari, smelt, cod & shrimp with capers. Served with lemon aioli and garnished with fresh herbs and lemon wedges.
    $31.50
  • Tomato Risotto

    *This item requires at least 30 minutes to prepare.* Green Barn Farms tomato confit, SarVecchio parmesan, roasted cherry tomato, fresh mozzarella pearls, basil, tomato infused olive oil
    $26.00

Build Your Own Pie

  • 10” BYO

    Pies start with olive oil, Wisconsin whole milk Mozzarella, and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie. *No half and halfs*
    $13.95
  • 16” BYO

    Pies start with olive oil, Wisconsin whole milk Mozzarella, and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
    $19.95

10" & GF Pies

  • 10” BYO

    Pies start with olive oil, Wisconsin whole milk Mozzarella, and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie. *No half and halfs*
    $13.95
  • 10" Tomato Pie

    *To add additional toppings please navigate to the Build Your Own Pie.* The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, and Fresh Basil. Think Margherita. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910.
    $14.25
  • 10" Fat Uncle Tony

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce,
    $17.25
  • 10” Figgy Piggy

    Wine poached figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, toasted pepitas, drizzle of hot honey.
    $17.95
  • 10” Gabagooln’t

    Vegan mozzarella, red sauce, Vegan pepperoni, banana peppers, chili flakes.
    $17.25
  • 10" Go Go Gochu

    Whole milk mozzarella, house KBBQ sauce, kimchi, chicken, scallions, ginger-soy dressed arugula, seesame seeds
    $17.25
  • 10" Joey Bananas

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Mix of Fresno and Jalapeño Peppers , Banana Peppers, Hot Honey
    $17.25
  • 10" Sal’s Supreme

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, Sausage, Cremini Mushroom, Yellow Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive
    $17.95
  • 10" Walter White

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Spinach, Italian Sausage, Ricotta, Roasted Garlic, Lemon Olive Oil, Chili Flake
    $17.25
  • 10" Woodsman

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives *Cannot be made VEGAN*
    $17.95
  • 10" The Forbidden Fruit

    Whole milk mozzarella, pineapple whipped feta, garlic butter, pineapple tidbits, Italian herb roasted pork, onion, roasted cherry tomatoes
    OUT OF STOCK
    $18.00
  • 10" Calabazas of the Dead

    Roasted tomatillo salsa (medium spice), Keewaydin Farms roasted kabocha squash, Alsum's sweet corn, crumbled chorizo, queso fresco, cilantro, Green Barn Farms red onion
    $18.00

16" Pies

  • 16” BYO

    Pies start with olive oil, Wisconsin whole milk Mozzarella, and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
    $19.95
  • 16" Tomato Pie

    *To add additional toppings please navigate to the Build Your Own Pie* The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, and Fresh Basil. Think Margherita. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910.
    $20.25
  • 16" Fat Uncle Tony

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce
    $27.50
  • 16” Figgy Piggy

    Wine poached figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, toasted pepitas, drizzle of hot honey.
    $28.25
  • 16” Gabagooln’t

    Vegan mozzarella, red sauce, Vegan pepperoni, banana peppers, chili flakes
    $27.50
  • 16" Go Go Gochu

    Whole milk mozzarella, house KBBQ sauce, kimchi, chicken, scallions, ginger-soy dressed arugula, seesame seeds
    $27.50
  • 16" Joey Bananas

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Mix of Fresno and Jalapeño Peppers , Banana Peppers, Hot Honey
    $27.50
  • 16" Sal’s Supreme

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, Sausage, Cremini Mushroom, Yellow Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive
    $28.25
  • 16” Walter White

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Spinach, Italian Sausage, Ricotta, Roasted Garlic, Lemon Olive Oil, Chili Flake
    $27.50
  • 16" Woodsman

    Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives *Cannot be made VEGAN*
    $29.25
  • 16" The Forbidden Fruit

    Whole milk mozzarella, pineapple whipped feta, garlic butter, pineapple tidbits, Italian herb roasted pork, onion, roasted cherry tomatoes
    OUT OF STOCK
    $29.50
  • 16" Calabazas of the Dead

    Roasted tomatillo salsa (medium spice), Keewaydin Farms roasted kabocha squash, Alsum's sweet corn, crumbled chorizo, queso fresco, cilantro, Green Barn Farms red onion
    $29.50

Dessert

  • Butterscotch Budino

    Italian-style pudding, served with Whipped Crème Fraiche, Biscotti, and Smoked Salt
    $9.00
  • Chocolate Cake

    Scratch-made chocolate cake with dark chocolate ganache and house chocolate syrup.
    $8.00
  • Tiramisu

    Espresso-dipped Ladyfingers, Mascarpone Cheese, and Chocolate Sauce, topped with Cocoa Powder and Chocolate Sauce
    $8.00
  • Mom's Cannoli (2)

    Sweetened Almond Ricotta and Pistachio
    $9.00

Sides & Extras

  • Side of Ranch (2oz)

    $2.50
  • Side of Bleu Cheese (2oz)

    $2.00
  • Side of Red Sauce (4oz)

    $2.00
  • Side of Seasonal Vinaigrette (2oz)

    $1.00
  • Side of Caesar Dressing (4oz)

    $2.00
  • Side of Buffalo (4oz)

    $2.00
  • Side of Korean BBQ (4oz)

    $2.00
  • Side of Hot Honey (1oz)

    $2.00
  • Parmesan Packets

  • Red Pepper Packets


Merchandise

Frozen Pies

For wholesale inquiries please visit - https://bit.ly/salswholesale
  • 10" Tomato Pie FROZEN

    $11.00
  • 10" Pepperoni FROZEN

    $12.00
  • 10" Fat Uncle Tony FROZEN

    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.00
  • 10" Woodsman FROZEN

    $15.00
  • 10" Vegan Supreme FROZEN

    $16.00

City Tins

  • City Tin 2026

    $30.00

To-Go Beverages & Utensils

Drinks

  • Diet Coke, 12oz

    Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
    $3.00
  • Sprite Zero Sugar

    Clear, crisp lemon-lime flavored, zero sugar soda will keep you refreshed and inspired
    $3.95
  • Ginger Ale 12 oz

    $3.00
  • Fresca Grapefruit Citrus, 12oz

    Fresca is the everything-in-one sparkling, zero calorie, citrus flavored soda
    $3.00
  • Sprecher Root Beer

    16 oz Root Beer
    $4.50
  • Cock n Bull Ginger Beer

    $4.50
  • Diet Cock n Bull Ginger Beer

    O calories
    $4.50
  • San Pellegrino

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.50
  • Strawberry Soda-WiscoPop

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00
  • Topo Chico Sabores Raspberry Lemon

    Experience the refreshing blend of raspberry and lemon flavors
    $4.50
  • Topo Chico Sabores Tangerine Ginger

    Experience the refreshing blend of tangerine and ginger flavors
    $4.50
  • Topo Chico Sabores Tropical Mango

    Experience the refreshing blend of tropical mango flavors
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.50
  • Sparkle Ginger Lime Water

    Unsweetened
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00
  • 2L Lemonade

    $5.50
  • 2L Root Beer

    $5.50
  • 2L Coke

    $5.00
  • 2L Coke Zero

    $5.00
  • 2L Sprite

    $5.00

Plates and Utensils

  • Napkins

  • Paper Plate

    $0.25
  • Plastic Fork

    $0.05
  • Plastic Knife

    $0.05
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

16" Woodsman

$29.25

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives *Cannot be made VEGAN*

Customize your item

Woodsman Toppings

Optional

16" Cheese & Sauce

Optional

16" Protein

Optional

16" Veggies

Optional

Make it a Proper Dinner

Select up to 1

Finish at Home (Best for Takeout & Delivery)

Select up to 1

VEGAN SUBS

Select up to 1

ALLERGY ALERT

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Salvatore's Tomato Pies Locations and Hours

Catering

(608) 305-8611
5511 Monona Drive, Monona, WI 53716
Closed • Opens Sunday at 11AM
View menu

Livingston

(608) 305-8885
10 N Livingston Street, Madison, WI 53703
Closed • Opens Sunday at 11AM
View menu

Monona

(608) 305-8611
5507 Monona Drive, Monona, WI 53716
Closed • Opens Sunday at 4AM
View menu

Sun Prairie

(608) 318-1761
121 East Main Street, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement